A Rapid Gas-Chromatography/Mass-Spectrometry Technique for Determining Odour Activity Values of Volatile Compounds in Plant Proteins: Soy, and Allergen-Free Pea and Brown Rice Protein

Plant-based protein sources have a characteristic aroma that limits their usage in various meat-alternative formulations. Despite being the most popular plant-based protein, the allergenicity of soy protein severely restricts the potential adoption of soy protein as an animal substitute. Thereby, al...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Anika Singh, Yuan Shi, Perrine Magreault, David D. Kitts, Maciej Jarzębski, Przemysław Siejak, Anubhav Pratap-Singh
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: MDPI AG 2021-07-01
Series:Molecules
Subjects:
Online Access:https://www.mdpi.com/1420-3049/26/13/4104
id doaj-de706dc90c4a4cf38d92d96b0065646a
record_format Article
spelling doaj-de706dc90c4a4cf38d92d96b0065646a2021-07-15T15:43:07ZengMDPI AGMolecules1420-30492021-07-01264104410410.3390/molecules26134104A Rapid Gas-Chromatography/Mass-Spectrometry Technique for Determining Odour Activity Values of Volatile Compounds in Plant Proteins: Soy, and Allergen-Free Pea and Brown Rice ProteinAnika Singh0Yuan Shi1Perrine Magreault2David D. Kitts3Maciej Jarzębski4Przemysław Siejak5Anubhav Pratap-Singh6Natural Health and Food Products Research Group, Centre for Applied Research & Innovation (CARI), British Columbia Institute of Technology, 4355 Mathissi Pl, Burnaby, BC V5G 4S8, CanadaFood, Nutrition and Health, Faculty of Land & Food Systems, 2205 East Mall, The University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC V6T 1Z4, CanadaCursus Ingénieur Agroalimentaire, 65, Rue de Saint-Brieuc, CS 84215 Rennes, FranceFood, Nutrition and Health, Faculty of Land & Food Systems, 2205 East Mall, The University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC V6T 1Z4, CanadaDepartment of Physics and Biophysics, Faculty of Food Science and Nutrition, Poznań University of Life Sciences, Wojska Polskiego 38/42, 60-637 Poznań, PolandDepartment of Physics and Biophysics, Faculty of Food Science and Nutrition, Poznań University of Life Sciences, Wojska Polskiego 38/42, 60-637 Poznań, PolandFood, Nutrition and Health, Faculty of Land & Food Systems, 2205 East Mall, The University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC V6T 1Z4, CanadaPlant-based protein sources have a characteristic aroma that limits their usage in various meat-alternative formulations. Despite being the most popular plant-based protein, the allergenicity of soy protein severely restricts the potential adoption of soy protein as an animal substitute. Thereby, allergen-free plant-protein sources need to be characterized. Herein, we demonstrate a rapid solid-phase-microextraction gas-chromatography/mass-spectrometry (SPME-GC/MS) technique for comparing the volatile aroma profile concentration of two different allergen-free plant-protein sources (brown rice and pea) and comparing them with soy protein. The extraction procedure consisted of making a 1:7 <i>w</i>/<i>v</i> aqueous plant protein slurry, and then absorbing the volatile compounds on an SPME fibre under agitation for 10 min at 40 °C, which was subsequently injected onto a GC column coupled to an MS system. Observed volatile concentrations were used in conjunction with odour threshold values to generate a Total Volatile Aroma Score for each protein sample. A total of 76 volatile compounds were identified. Aldehydes and furans were determined to be the most dominant volatiles present in the plant proteins. Both brown rice protein and pea protein contained 64% aldehydes and 18% furans, with minor contents of alcohols, ketones and other compounds. On the other hand, soy protein consisted of fewer aldehydes (46%), but a more significant proportion of furans (42%). However, in terms of total concentration, brown rice protein contained the highest intensity and number of volatile compounds. Based on the calculated odour activity values of the detected compounds, our study concludes that pea proteins could be used as a suitable alternative to soy proteins in applications for allergen-free vegan protein products without interfering with the taste or flavour of the product.https://www.mdpi.com/1420-3049/26/13/4104plant proteinvolatile aroma compoundsodour threshold valuepea proteinrice proteinsoy protein
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Anika Singh
Yuan Shi
Perrine Magreault
David D. Kitts
Maciej Jarzębski
Przemysław Siejak
Anubhav Pratap-Singh
spellingShingle Anika Singh
Yuan Shi
Perrine Magreault
David D. Kitts
Maciej Jarzębski
Przemysław Siejak
Anubhav Pratap-Singh
A Rapid Gas-Chromatography/Mass-Spectrometry Technique for Determining Odour Activity Values of Volatile Compounds in Plant Proteins: Soy, and Allergen-Free Pea and Brown Rice Protein
Molecules
plant protein
volatile aroma compounds
odour threshold value
pea protein
rice protein
soy protein
author_facet Anika Singh
Yuan Shi
Perrine Magreault
David D. Kitts
Maciej Jarzębski
Przemysław Siejak
Anubhav Pratap-Singh
author_sort Anika Singh
title A Rapid Gas-Chromatography/Mass-Spectrometry Technique for Determining Odour Activity Values of Volatile Compounds in Plant Proteins: Soy, and Allergen-Free Pea and Brown Rice Protein
title_short A Rapid Gas-Chromatography/Mass-Spectrometry Technique for Determining Odour Activity Values of Volatile Compounds in Plant Proteins: Soy, and Allergen-Free Pea and Brown Rice Protein
title_full A Rapid Gas-Chromatography/Mass-Spectrometry Technique for Determining Odour Activity Values of Volatile Compounds in Plant Proteins: Soy, and Allergen-Free Pea and Brown Rice Protein
title_fullStr A Rapid Gas-Chromatography/Mass-Spectrometry Technique for Determining Odour Activity Values of Volatile Compounds in Plant Proteins: Soy, and Allergen-Free Pea and Brown Rice Protein
title_full_unstemmed A Rapid Gas-Chromatography/Mass-Spectrometry Technique for Determining Odour Activity Values of Volatile Compounds in Plant Proteins: Soy, and Allergen-Free Pea and Brown Rice Protein
title_sort rapid gas-chromatography/mass-spectrometry technique for determining odour activity values of volatile compounds in plant proteins: soy, and allergen-free pea and brown rice protein
publisher MDPI AG
series Molecules
issn 1420-3049
publishDate 2021-07-01
description Plant-based protein sources have a characteristic aroma that limits their usage in various meat-alternative formulations. Despite being the most popular plant-based protein, the allergenicity of soy protein severely restricts the potential adoption of soy protein as an animal substitute. Thereby, allergen-free plant-protein sources need to be characterized. Herein, we demonstrate a rapid solid-phase-microextraction gas-chromatography/mass-spectrometry (SPME-GC/MS) technique for comparing the volatile aroma profile concentration of two different allergen-free plant-protein sources (brown rice and pea) and comparing them with soy protein. The extraction procedure consisted of making a 1:7 <i>w</i>/<i>v</i> aqueous plant protein slurry, and then absorbing the volatile compounds on an SPME fibre under agitation for 10 min at 40 °C, which was subsequently injected onto a GC column coupled to an MS system. Observed volatile concentrations were used in conjunction with odour threshold values to generate a Total Volatile Aroma Score for each protein sample. A total of 76 volatile compounds were identified. Aldehydes and furans were determined to be the most dominant volatiles present in the plant proteins. Both brown rice protein and pea protein contained 64% aldehydes and 18% furans, with minor contents of alcohols, ketones and other compounds. On the other hand, soy protein consisted of fewer aldehydes (46%), but a more significant proportion of furans (42%). However, in terms of total concentration, brown rice protein contained the highest intensity and number of volatile compounds. Based on the calculated odour activity values of the detected compounds, our study concludes that pea proteins could be used as a suitable alternative to soy proteins in applications for allergen-free vegan protein products without interfering with the taste or flavour of the product.
topic plant protein
volatile aroma compounds
odour threshold value
pea protein
rice protein
soy protein
url https://www.mdpi.com/1420-3049/26/13/4104
work_keys_str_mv AT anikasingh arapidgaschromatographymassspectrometrytechniquefordeterminingodouractivityvaluesofvolatilecompoundsinplantproteinssoyandallergenfreepeaandbrownriceprotein
AT yuanshi arapidgaschromatographymassspectrometrytechniquefordeterminingodouractivityvaluesofvolatilecompoundsinplantproteinssoyandallergenfreepeaandbrownriceprotein
AT perrinemagreault arapidgaschromatographymassspectrometrytechniquefordeterminingodouractivityvaluesofvolatilecompoundsinplantproteinssoyandallergenfreepeaandbrownriceprotein
AT daviddkitts arapidgaschromatographymassspectrometrytechniquefordeterminingodouractivityvaluesofvolatilecompoundsinplantproteinssoyandallergenfreepeaandbrownriceprotein
AT maciejjarzebski arapidgaschromatographymassspectrometrytechniquefordeterminingodouractivityvaluesofvolatilecompoundsinplantproteinssoyandallergenfreepeaandbrownriceprotein
AT przemysławsiejak arapidgaschromatographymassspectrometrytechniquefordeterminingodouractivityvaluesofvolatilecompoundsinplantproteinssoyandallergenfreepeaandbrownriceprotein
AT anubhavpratapsingh arapidgaschromatographymassspectrometrytechniquefordeterminingodouractivityvaluesofvolatilecompoundsinplantproteinssoyandallergenfreepeaandbrownriceprotein
AT anikasingh rapidgaschromatographymassspectrometrytechniquefordeterminingodouractivityvaluesofvolatilecompoundsinplantproteinssoyandallergenfreepeaandbrownriceprotein
AT yuanshi rapidgaschromatographymassspectrometrytechniquefordeterminingodouractivityvaluesofvolatilecompoundsinplantproteinssoyandallergenfreepeaandbrownriceprotein
AT perrinemagreault rapidgaschromatographymassspectrometrytechniquefordeterminingodouractivityvaluesofvolatilecompoundsinplantproteinssoyandallergenfreepeaandbrownriceprotein
AT daviddkitts rapidgaschromatographymassspectrometrytechniquefordeterminingodouractivityvaluesofvolatilecompoundsinplantproteinssoyandallergenfreepeaandbrownriceprotein
AT maciejjarzebski rapidgaschromatographymassspectrometrytechniquefordeterminingodouractivityvaluesofvolatilecompoundsinplantproteinssoyandallergenfreepeaandbrownriceprotein
AT przemysławsiejak rapidgaschromatographymassspectrometrytechniquefordeterminingodouractivityvaluesofvolatilecompoundsinplantproteinssoyandallergenfreepeaandbrownriceprotein
AT anubhavpratapsingh rapidgaschromatographymassspectrometrytechniquefordeterminingodouractivityvaluesofvolatilecompoundsinplantproteinssoyandallergenfreepeaandbrownriceprotein
_version_ 1721298805040611328