Characterizing and decomposing the neural correlates of individual differences in reading ability among adolescents with task-based fMRI

To better characterize the neural correlates of the full spectrum of reading ability, this fMRI study examined how variations in reading ability correlate with task-based brain activity during reading among a large community sample of adolescents (N = 234). In addition, complimentary approaches taki...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Kai Wang, Daniel R. Leopold, Marie T. Banich, Andrew E. Reineberg, Erik G. Willcutt, Laurie E. Cutting, Stephanie N. Del Tufo, Lee A. Thompson, John Opfer, Frank J. Kanayet, Zhong-Lin Lu, Stephen A. Petrill
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Elsevier 2019-06-01
Series:Developmental Cognitive Neuroscience
Online Access:http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1878929318302378
id doaj-73fd4589e2514d209d51d54e24ddbb91
record_format Article
spelling doaj-73fd4589e2514d209d51d54e24ddbb912020-11-25T02:12:00ZengElsevierDevelopmental Cognitive Neuroscience1878-92932019-06-0137Characterizing and decomposing the neural correlates of individual differences in reading ability among adolescents with task-based fMRIKai Wang0Daniel R. Leopold1Marie T. Banich2Andrew E. Reineberg3Erik G. Willcutt4Laurie E. Cutting5Stephanie N. Del Tufo6Lee A. Thompson7John Opfer8Frank J. Kanayet9Zhong-Lin Lu10Stephen A. Petrill11University of Colorado Boulder, United States; Corresponding author at: Institute of Cognitive Science, University of Colorado Boulder, Room 182B, 1777 Exposition Dr., Boulder, CO, 80301, United States.University of Colorado Boulder, United StatesUniversity of Colorado Boulder, United StatesUniversity of Colorado Boulder, United StatesUniversity of Colorado Boulder, United StatesVanderbilt University, United StatesVanderbilt University, United StatesCase Western Reserve University, United StatesThe Ohio State University, United StatesThe Ohio State University, United StatesThe Ohio State University, United StatesThe Ohio State University, United StatesTo better characterize the neural correlates of the full spectrum of reading ability, this fMRI study examined how variations in reading ability correlate with task-based brain activity during reading among a large community sample of adolescents (N = 234). In addition, complimentary approaches taking advantage of empirical as well as independent meta-analytic information were employed to isolate neural substrates of domain-general executive processes that are predictive of reading ability. Age-related differences in brain activity were also examined. Better reading was associated with increased activation in left anterior and inferior temporal regions and parts of orbitofrontal cortex, along with reduced activation in the thalamus and left frontal eye field (FEF). Converging evidence suggests that FEF activity corresponds to executive processes during reading. In contrast, activity in temporal regions is likely to reflect cognitive processes specific to reading. Older adolescents also demonstrated increased activation in an orbitofrontal region that overlaps with the aforementioned age-independent, reading-related regions, along with reduced activity in parietal and occipital regions. These results suggest that comparedto poor readers, proficient readers benefit from efficient reading-specific processes and require less executive effort, implemented via the FEF, during a reading comprehension task. Keywords: Executive Function, Reading, Frontal eye field, fMRI, Individual differenceshttp://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1878929318302378
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Kai Wang
Daniel R. Leopold
Marie T. Banich
Andrew E. Reineberg
Erik G. Willcutt
Laurie E. Cutting
Stephanie N. Del Tufo
Lee A. Thompson
John Opfer
Frank J. Kanayet
Zhong-Lin Lu
Stephen A. Petrill
spellingShingle Kai Wang
Daniel R. Leopold
Marie T. Banich
Andrew E. Reineberg
Erik G. Willcutt
Laurie E. Cutting
Stephanie N. Del Tufo
Lee A. Thompson
John Opfer
Frank J. Kanayet
Zhong-Lin Lu
Stephen A. Petrill
Characterizing and decomposing the neural correlates of individual differences in reading ability among adolescents with task-based fMRI
Developmental Cognitive Neuroscience
author_facet Kai Wang
Daniel R. Leopold
Marie T. Banich
Andrew E. Reineberg
Erik G. Willcutt
Laurie E. Cutting
Stephanie N. Del Tufo
Lee A. Thompson
John Opfer
Frank J. Kanayet
Zhong-Lin Lu
Stephen A. Petrill
author_sort Kai Wang
title Characterizing and decomposing the neural correlates of individual differences in reading ability among adolescents with task-based fMRI
title_short Characterizing and decomposing the neural correlates of individual differences in reading ability among adolescents with task-based fMRI
title_full Characterizing and decomposing the neural correlates of individual differences in reading ability among adolescents with task-based fMRI
title_fullStr Characterizing and decomposing the neural correlates of individual differences in reading ability among adolescents with task-based fMRI
title_full_unstemmed Characterizing and decomposing the neural correlates of individual differences in reading ability among adolescents with task-based fMRI
title_sort characterizing and decomposing the neural correlates of individual differences in reading ability among adolescents with task-based fmri
publisher Elsevier
series Developmental Cognitive Neuroscience
issn 1878-9293
publishDate 2019-06-01
description To better characterize the neural correlates of the full spectrum of reading ability, this fMRI study examined how variations in reading ability correlate with task-based brain activity during reading among a large community sample of adolescents (N = 234). In addition, complimentary approaches taking advantage of empirical as well as independent meta-analytic information were employed to isolate neural substrates of domain-general executive processes that are predictive of reading ability. Age-related differences in brain activity were also examined. Better reading was associated with increased activation in left anterior and inferior temporal regions and parts of orbitofrontal cortex, along with reduced activation in the thalamus and left frontal eye field (FEF). Converging evidence suggests that FEF activity corresponds to executive processes during reading. In contrast, activity in temporal regions is likely to reflect cognitive processes specific to reading. Older adolescents also demonstrated increased activation in an orbitofrontal region that overlaps with the aforementioned age-independent, reading-related regions, along with reduced activity in parietal and occipital regions. These results suggest that comparedto poor readers, proficient readers benefit from efficient reading-specific processes and require less executive effort, implemented via the FEF, during a reading comprehension task. Keywords: Executive Function, Reading, Frontal eye field, fMRI, Individual differences
url http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1878929318302378
work_keys_str_mv AT kaiwang characterizinganddecomposingtheneuralcorrelatesofindividualdifferencesinreadingabilityamongadolescentswithtaskbasedfmri
AT danielrleopold characterizinganddecomposingtheneuralcorrelatesofindividualdifferencesinreadingabilityamongadolescentswithtaskbasedfmri
AT marietbanich characterizinganddecomposingtheneuralcorrelatesofindividualdifferencesinreadingabilityamongadolescentswithtaskbasedfmri
AT andrewereineberg characterizinganddecomposingtheneuralcorrelatesofindividualdifferencesinreadingabilityamongadolescentswithtaskbasedfmri
AT erikgwillcutt characterizinganddecomposingtheneuralcorrelatesofindividualdifferencesinreadingabilityamongadolescentswithtaskbasedfmri
AT laurieecutting characterizinganddecomposingtheneuralcorrelatesofindividualdifferencesinreadingabilityamongadolescentswithtaskbasedfmri
AT stephaniendeltufo characterizinganddecomposingtheneuralcorrelatesofindividualdifferencesinreadingabilityamongadolescentswithtaskbasedfmri
AT leeathompson characterizinganddecomposingtheneuralcorrelatesofindividualdifferencesinreadingabilityamongadolescentswithtaskbasedfmri
AT johnopfer characterizinganddecomposingtheneuralcorrelatesofindividualdifferencesinreadingabilityamongadolescentswithtaskbasedfmri
AT frankjkanayet characterizinganddecomposingtheneuralcorrelatesofindividualdifferencesinreadingabilityamongadolescentswithtaskbasedfmri
AT zhonglinlu characterizinganddecomposingtheneuralcorrelatesofindividualdifferencesinreadingabilityamongadolescentswithtaskbasedfmri
AT stephenapetrill characterizinganddecomposingtheneuralcorrelatesofindividualdifferencesinreadingabilityamongadolescentswithtaskbasedfmri
_version_ 1724911295996624896