Brain Network to Placebo and Nocebo Responses in Acute Experimental Lower Back Pain: A Multivariate Granger Causality Analysis of fMRI Data

Background and Objective: Placebo and nocebo responses are widely observed. Herein, we investigated the nocebo hyperalgesia and placebo analgesia responses in brain network in acute lower back pain (ALBP) model using multivariate Granger causality analysis (GCA). This approach analyses functional ma...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Cai, G. (Author), Cui, S. (Author), Huang, S. (Author), Shi, Y. (Author), Wu, W. (Author), Yang, J. (Author), Zeng, Y. (Author)
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Frontiers Media S.A. 2021
Subjects:
GCA
Online Access:View Fulltext in Publisher
LEADER 04106nam a2200613Ia 4500
001 10.3389-fnbeh.2021.696577
008 220427s2021 CNT 000 0 und d
020 |a 16625153 (ISSN) 
245 1 0 |a Brain Network to Placebo and Nocebo Responses in Acute Experimental Lower Back Pain: A Multivariate Granger Causality Analysis of fMRI Data 
260 0 |b Frontiers Media S.A.  |c 2021 
856 |z View Fulltext in Publisher  |u https://doi.org/10.3389/fnbeh.2021.696577 
520 3 |a Background and Objective: Placebo and nocebo responses are widely observed. Herein, we investigated the nocebo hyperalgesia and placebo analgesia responses in brain network in acute lower back pain (ALBP) model using multivariate Granger causality analysis (GCA). This approach analyses functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) data for lagged-temporal correlation between different brain areas. Method: After completing the ALBP model, 20 healthy subjects were given two interventions, once during a placebo intervention and once during a nocebo intervention, pseudo-randomly ordered. fMRI scans were performed synchronously during each intervention, and visual analog scale (VAS) scores were collected at the end of each intervention. The fMRI data were then analyzed using multivariate GCA. Results: Our results found statistically significant differences in VAS scores from baseline (pain status) for both placebo and nocebo interventions, as well as between placebo and nocebo interventions. In placebo network, we found a negative lagged-temporal correlation between multiple brain areas, including the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (DLPFC), secondary somatosensory cortex area, anterior cingulate cortex (ACC), and insular cortex (IC); and a positive lagged-temporal correlation between multiple brain areas, including IC, thalamus, ACC, as well as the supplementary motor area (SMA). In the nocebo network, we also found a positive lagged-temporal correlation between multiple brain areas, including the primary somatosensory cortex area, caudate, DLPFC and SMA. Conclusion: The results of this study suggest that both pain-related network and reward system are involved in placebo and nocebo responses. The placebo response mainly works by activating the reward system and inhibiting pain-related network, while the nocebo response is the opposite. Placebo network also involves the activation of opioid-mediated analgesia system (OMAS) and emotion pathway, while nocebo network involves the deactivation of emotional control. At the same time, through the construction of the GC network, we verified our hypothesis that nocebo and placebo networks share part of the same brain regions, but the two networks also have their own unique structural features. © Copyright © 2021 Shi, Cui, Zeng, Huang, Cai, Yang and Wu. 
650 0 4 |a adult 
650 0 4 |a analgesia 
650 0 4 |a anterior cingulate 
650 0 4 |a anxiety 
650 0 4 |a Article 
650 0 4 |a brain region 
650 0 4 |a caudate nucleus 
650 0 4 |a dopamine 
650 0 4 |a dorsolateral prefrontal cortex 
650 0 4 |a emotion 
650 0 4 |a female 
650 0 4 |a functional magnetic resonance imaging 
650 0 4 |a GCA 
650 0 4 |a Granger causality analysis 
650 0 4 |a human 
650 0 4 |a human experiment 
650 0 4 |a hyperalgesia 
650 0 4 |a insula 
650 0 4 |a low back pain 
650 0 4 |a male 
650 0 4 |a multivariate analysis 
650 0 4 |a nerve cell network 
650 0 4 |a nocebo effect 
650 0 4 |a nocebo hyperalgesia 
650 0 4 |a normal human 
650 0 4 |a opioid 
650 0 4 |a placebo analgesia 
650 0 4 |a placebo effect 
650 0 4 |a reward 
650 0 4 |a reward system 
650 0 4 |a secondary somatosensory cortex 
650 0 4 |a supplementary motor area 
650 0 4 |a thalamus 
650 0 4 |a visual analog scale 
700 1 |a Cai, G.  |e author 
700 1 |a Cui, S.  |e author 
700 1 |a Huang, S.  |e author 
700 1 |a Shi, Y.  |e author 
700 1 |a Wu, W.  |e author 
700 1 |a Yang, J.  |e author 
700 1 |a Zeng, Y.  |e author 
773 |t Frontiers in Behavioral Neuroscience