Present and Future Wind Energy Resources in Western Canada

Wind power presently plays a minor role in Western Canada as compared to hydroelectric power in British Columbia and coal and natural gas thermal power generation in Alberta. However, ongoing reductions in the cost of wind power generation facilities and the increasing costs of conventional power...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Author: Daines, Jeffrey Thomas
Other Authors: Monahan, Adam Hugh
Language:English
en
Published: 2015
Subjects:
GCM
RCM
Online Access:http://hdl.handle.net/1828/6703
id ndltd-uvic.ca-oai-dspace.library.uvic.ca-1828-6703
record_format oai_dc
collection NDLTD
language English
en
sources NDLTD
topic Dynamical downscaling
global climate model
NARR
North American Regional Reanalysis
Canadian Regional Climate Model
CRCM
ECHAM5
CGCM3
Western Canada
British Columbia
Alberta
bias correction
change factor
wind energy resources
electrical power generation
quantile-quantile matching
calibration
wind speeds
airport weather stations
GCM
RCM
simulation
wind power density
relative change
A2 emissions scenario
spellingShingle Dynamical downscaling
global climate model
NARR
North American Regional Reanalysis
Canadian Regional Climate Model
CRCM
ECHAM5
CGCM3
Western Canada
British Columbia
Alberta
bias correction
change factor
wind energy resources
electrical power generation
quantile-quantile matching
calibration
wind speeds
airport weather stations
GCM
RCM
simulation
wind power density
relative change
A2 emissions scenario
Daines, Jeffrey Thomas
Present and Future Wind Energy Resources in Western Canada
description Wind power presently plays a minor role in Western Canada as compared to hydroelectric power in British Columbia and coal and natural gas thermal power generation in Alberta. However, ongoing reductions in the cost of wind power generation facilities and the increasing costs of conventional power generation, particularly if the cost to the environment is included, suggest that assessment of the present and future wind field in Western Canada is of some importance. To assess present wind power, raw hourly wind speeds and homogenized monthly mean wind speeds from 30 stations in Western Canada were analyzed over the period 1971-2000 (past). The hourly data were adjusted using the homogenized monthly means to attempt to compensate for differences in anemometer height from the standard height of 10m and changes in observing equipment at stations. A regional reanalysis product, the North American Regional Reanalysis (NARR), and simulations conducted with the Canadian Regional Climate Model (CRCM) driven with global reanalysis boundary forcing, were compared to the adjusted station wind-speed time-series and probability distributions. The NARR had a better temporal correlation with the observations, than the CRCM. We posit this is due to the NARR assimilating regional observations, whereas the CRCM did not. The NARR was generally worse than the CRCM in reproducing the observed speed distribution, possibly due to the crude representation of the regional topography in NARR. While the CRCM was run at both standard (45 km) and fine (15 km) resolution, the fine grid spacing does not always provide better results: the character of the surrounding topography appears to be an important factor for determining the level of agreement. Multiple simulations of the CRCM at the 45 km resolution were also driven by two global climate models (GCMs) over the periods 1971-2000 (using only historic emissions) and 2031-2060 (using the A2 emissions scenario). In light of the CRCM biases relative to the observations, these simulations were calibrated using quantile-quantile matching to the adjusted station observations to obtain ensembles of 9 and 25 projected wind speed distributions for the 2031-2060 period (future) at the station locations. Both bias correction and change factor techniques were used for calibration. At most station locations modest increases in mean wind speed were found for most of the projected distributions, but with a large variance. Estimates of wind power density for the projected speed distributions were made using a relationship between wind speed and power from a CRCM simulation for both time periods using the 15km grid. As would be expected from the wind speed results and the proportionality of wind power to the cube of wind speed, wind power at the station locations is more likely than not to increase in the 2031-2060 period from the 1971-2000 period. Relative changes in mean wind speeds at station locations were found to be insensitive to the station observations and choice of calibration technique, suggesting that we estimate relative change at all 45km grid points using all pairs of past/future mean wind speeds from the CRCM simulations. Overall, our results suggest that wind energy resources in Western Canada are reasonably likely to increase at least modestly in the future. === Graduate === 0725 === 0608 === jtdaines@uvic.ca
author2 Monahan, Adam Hugh
author_facet Monahan, Adam Hugh
Daines, Jeffrey Thomas
author Daines, Jeffrey Thomas
author_sort Daines, Jeffrey Thomas
title Present and Future Wind Energy Resources in Western Canada
title_short Present and Future Wind Energy Resources in Western Canada
title_full Present and Future Wind Energy Resources in Western Canada
title_fullStr Present and Future Wind Energy Resources in Western Canada
title_full_unstemmed Present and Future Wind Energy Resources in Western Canada
title_sort present and future wind energy resources in western canada
publishDate 2015
url http://hdl.handle.net/1828/6703
work_keys_str_mv AT dainesjeffreythomas presentandfuturewindenergyresourcesinwesterncanada
_version_ 1716818604345786368
spelling ndltd-uvic.ca-oai-dspace.library.uvic.ca-1828-67032015-09-19T15:50:12Z Present and Future Wind Energy Resources in Western Canada Daines, Jeffrey Thomas Monahan, Adam Hugh Curry, Charles L. Dynamical downscaling global climate model NARR North American Regional Reanalysis Canadian Regional Climate Model CRCM ECHAM5 CGCM3 Western Canada British Columbia Alberta bias correction change factor wind energy resources electrical power generation quantile-quantile matching calibration wind speeds airport weather stations GCM RCM simulation wind power density relative change A2 emissions scenario Wind power presently plays a minor role in Western Canada as compared to hydroelectric power in British Columbia and coal and natural gas thermal power generation in Alberta. However, ongoing reductions in the cost of wind power generation facilities and the increasing costs of conventional power generation, particularly if the cost to the environment is included, suggest that assessment of the present and future wind field in Western Canada is of some importance. To assess present wind power, raw hourly wind speeds and homogenized monthly mean wind speeds from 30 stations in Western Canada were analyzed over the period 1971-2000 (past). The hourly data were adjusted using the homogenized monthly means to attempt to compensate for differences in anemometer height from the standard height of 10m and changes in observing equipment at stations. A regional reanalysis product, the North American Regional Reanalysis (NARR), and simulations conducted with the Canadian Regional Climate Model (CRCM) driven with global reanalysis boundary forcing, were compared to the adjusted station wind-speed time-series and probability distributions. The NARR had a better temporal correlation with the observations, than the CRCM. We posit this is due to the NARR assimilating regional observations, whereas the CRCM did not. The NARR was generally worse than the CRCM in reproducing the observed speed distribution, possibly due to the crude representation of the regional topography in NARR. While the CRCM was run at both standard (45 km) and fine (15 km) resolution, the fine grid spacing does not always provide better results: the character of the surrounding topography appears to be an important factor for determining the level of agreement. Multiple simulations of the CRCM at the 45 km resolution were also driven by two global climate models (GCMs) over the periods 1971-2000 (using only historic emissions) and 2031-2060 (using the A2 emissions scenario). In light of the CRCM biases relative to the observations, these simulations were calibrated using quantile-quantile matching to the adjusted station observations to obtain ensembles of 9 and 25 projected wind speed distributions for the 2031-2060 period (future) at the station locations. Both bias correction and change factor techniques were used for calibration. At most station locations modest increases in mean wind speed were found for most of the projected distributions, but with a large variance. Estimates of wind power density for the projected speed distributions were made using a relationship between wind speed and power from a CRCM simulation for both time periods using the 15km grid. As would be expected from the wind speed results and the proportionality of wind power to the cube of wind speed, wind power at the station locations is more likely than not to increase in the 2031-2060 period from the 1971-2000 period. Relative changes in mean wind speeds at station locations were found to be insensitive to the station observations and choice of calibration technique, suggesting that we estimate relative change at all 45km grid points using all pairs of past/future mean wind speeds from the CRCM simulations. Overall, our results suggest that wind energy resources in Western Canada are reasonably likely to increase at least modestly in the future. Graduate 0725 0608 jtdaines@uvic.ca 2015-09-17T22:29:35Z 2015-09-17T22:29:35Z 2015 2015-09-17 Thesis http://hdl.handle.net/1828/6703 English en Available to the World Wide Web http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/2.5/ca/