A unified discrepancy-based approach for balancing efficiency and robustness in state-space modeling estimation, selection, and diagnosis

• Main Author: Hu, Nan
• Other Authors: Cavanaugh, Joseph E.
• Format: Others
• Language: English
• Published: University of Iowa 2016
• Subjects: discrepancy; influence diagnostic; robust model selection; robust parameter estimation; state-space model; time series analysis; Applied Mathematics
• Online Access: https://ir.uiowa.edu/etd/2224; https://ir.uiowa.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=6791&context=etd

Due to its generality and flexibility, the state-space model has become one of the most popular models in modern time domain analysis for the description and prediction of time series data. The model is often used to characterize processes that can be conceptualized as "signal plus noise," where the realized series is viewed as the manifestation of a latent signal that has been corrupted by observation noise. In the state-space framework, parameter estimation is generally accomplished by maximizing the innovations Gaussian log-likelihood. The maximum likelihood estimator (MLE) is efficient when the normality assumption is satisfied. However, in the presence of contamination, the MLE suffers from a lack of robustness. Basu, Harris, Hjort, and Jones (1998) introduced a discrepancy measure (BHHJ) with a non-negative tuning parameter that regulates the trade-off between robustness and efficiency. In this manuscript, we propose a new parameter estimation procedure based on the BHHJ discrepancy for fitting state-space models. As the tuning parameter is increased, the estimation procedure becomes more robust but less efficient. We investigate the performance of the procedure in an illustrative simulation study. In addition, we propose a numerical method to approximate the asymptotic variance of the estimator, and we provide an approach for choosing an appropriate tuning parameter in practice. We justify these procedures theoretically and investigate their efficacy in simulation studies. Based on the proposed parameter estimation procedure, we then develop a new model selection criterion in the state-space framework. The traditional Akaike information criterion (AIC), where the goodness-of-fit is assessed by the empirical log-likelihood, is not robust to outliers. Our new criterion is comprised of a goodness-of-fit term based on the empirical BHHJ discrepancy, and a penalty term based on both the tuning parameter and the dimension of the candidate model. We present a comprehensive simulation study to investigate the performance of the new criterion. In instances where the time series data is contaminated, our proposed model selection criterion is shown to perform favorably relative to AIC. Lastly, using the BHHJ discrepancy based on the chosen tuning parameter, we propose two versions of an influence diagnostic in the state-space framework. Specifically, our diagnostics help to identify cases that influence the recovery of the latent signal, thereby providing initial guidance and insight for further exploration. We illustrate the behavior of these measures in a simulation study.