The bonds of manhood: public life, homosociality, and hegemonic masculinity in Massachusetts, 1630-1787

Inspired by feminist historians who called upon scholars to examine gender as a socially constructed phenomenon, this project's overarching goal is to historicize manhood by providing a survey of men's experiences as men from the late sixteenth- to the late-eighteenth-century. Specifically...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Author: Reardon, Matthew James
Other Authors: Midtrød, Tom Arne, 1976-
Format: Others
Language:English
Published: University of Iowa 2012
Subjects:
Online Access:https://ir.uiowa.edu/etd/2969
https://ir.uiowa.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=3116&context=etd
id ndltd-uiowa.edu-oai-ir.uiowa.edu-etd-3116
record_format oai_dc
spelling ndltd-uiowa.edu-oai-ir.uiowa.edu-etd-31162019-10-13T05:05:50Z The bonds of manhood: public life, homosociality, and hegemonic masculinity in Massachusetts, 1630-1787 Reardon, Matthew James Inspired by feminist historians who called upon scholars to examine gender as a socially constructed phenomenon, this project's overarching goal is to historicize manhood by providing a survey of men's experiences as men from the late sixteenth- to the late-eighteenth-century. Specifically, it explores, how, why, and in what ways hegemonic norms of manhood changed in Massachusetts from its founding to the ratification of the United States Constitution. It also investigates the formation of and relationships between hegemonic and subordinate masculinities in the early modern British Atlantic. Both the transmission and reception of manhood in early Massachusetts are explored. That is, I have consulted the books, novels, plays, newspapers, and laws, that formulated, established, and enforced hegemonic norms, and men's letters, diaries, letterbooks, and commentary which evince their assimilation. I have tried to explain what masculine ideals obtained over time, and what men did to reach those standards. Not all my conclusions fit tidily into the existing historiography on early American manhood. Early chapters complicate the picture typically painted of Puritan Massachusetts's patriarchal gendered order. By highlighting its fraternal networks of gendered power, I found that a bifurcated gendered order was largely responsible for the civilization's unique social stability. Historians examining this subject generally conclude that men's ideas about what it meant to be a man changed little from the founding of the colonies to the outbreak of the American Revolution. The standard narrative is that a communal manhood prevailed throughout America until the very end of the eighteenth-century when it was suddenly replaced by a more individualistic "manliness." Not until after the liberating forces of the Revolution, the market economy, and political democracy had reshaped American society, it is asserted, were men truly able to pursue individualistic goals in their personal and professional lives. I discovered that this dating is late by about a century, and that historians have mistaken causes for effects in the relationship between the American Revolution and the rise of autonomous manhood. It was not a consequence of the Revolution, I argue here, but a cause of the event. 2012-05-01T07:00:00Z dissertation application/pdf https://ir.uiowa.edu/etd/2969 https://ir.uiowa.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=3116&context=etd Copyright 2012 Matthew James Reardon Theses and Dissertations eng University of IowaMidtrød, Tom Arne, 1976- History
collection NDLTD
language English
format Others
sources NDLTD
topic History
spellingShingle History
Reardon, Matthew James
The bonds of manhood: public life, homosociality, and hegemonic masculinity in Massachusetts, 1630-1787
description Inspired by feminist historians who called upon scholars to examine gender as a socially constructed phenomenon, this project's overarching goal is to historicize manhood by providing a survey of men's experiences as men from the late sixteenth- to the late-eighteenth-century. Specifically, it explores, how, why, and in what ways hegemonic norms of manhood changed in Massachusetts from its founding to the ratification of the United States Constitution. It also investigates the formation of and relationships between hegemonic and subordinate masculinities in the early modern British Atlantic. Both the transmission and reception of manhood in early Massachusetts are explored. That is, I have consulted the books, novels, plays, newspapers, and laws, that formulated, established, and enforced hegemonic norms, and men's letters, diaries, letterbooks, and commentary which evince their assimilation. I have tried to explain what masculine ideals obtained over time, and what men did to reach those standards. Not all my conclusions fit tidily into the existing historiography on early American manhood. Early chapters complicate the picture typically painted of Puritan Massachusetts's patriarchal gendered order. By highlighting its fraternal networks of gendered power, I found that a bifurcated gendered order was largely responsible for the civilization's unique social stability. Historians examining this subject generally conclude that men's ideas about what it meant to be a man changed little from the founding of the colonies to the outbreak of the American Revolution. The standard narrative is that a communal manhood prevailed throughout America until the very end of the eighteenth-century when it was suddenly replaced by a more individualistic "manliness." Not until after the liberating forces of the Revolution, the market economy, and political democracy had reshaped American society, it is asserted, were men truly able to pursue individualistic goals in their personal and professional lives. I discovered that this dating is late by about a century, and that historians have mistaken causes for effects in the relationship between the American Revolution and the rise of autonomous manhood. It was not a consequence of the Revolution, I argue here, but a cause of the event.
author2 Midtrød, Tom Arne, 1976-
author_facet Midtrød, Tom Arne, 1976-
Reardon, Matthew James
author Reardon, Matthew James
author_sort Reardon, Matthew James
title The bonds of manhood: public life, homosociality, and hegemonic masculinity in Massachusetts, 1630-1787
title_short The bonds of manhood: public life, homosociality, and hegemonic masculinity in Massachusetts, 1630-1787
title_full The bonds of manhood: public life, homosociality, and hegemonic masculinity in Massachusetts, 1630-1787
title_fullStr The bonds of manhood: public life, homosociality, and hegemonic masculinity in Massachusetts, 1630-1787
title_full_unstemmed The bonds of manhood: public life, homosociality, and hegemonic masculinity in Massachusetts, 1630-1787
title_sort bonds of manhood: public life, homosociality, and hegemonic masculinity in massachusetts, 1630-1787
publisher University of Iowa
publishDate 2012
url https://ir.uiowa.edu/etd/2969
https://ir.uiowa.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=3116&context=etd
work_keys_str_mv AT reardonmatthewjames thebondsofmanhoodpubliclifehomosocialityandhegemonicmasculinityinmassachusetts16301787
AT reardonmatthewjames bondsofmanhoodpubliclifehomosocialityandhegemonicmasculinityinmassachusetts16301787
_version_ 1719265591067410432