Analysis of 2009 ENR Best Projects in Texas to Determine the Impact of Project Delivery System Used

• Main Author: Rajan, Navaneethan
• Other Authors: Smith, James
• Format: Others
• Language: en_US
• Published: 2011
• Subjects: Project Delivery Method; Engineering News Record; ENR Best Projects; Design-Build; Construction Management at Risk
• Online Access: http://hdl.handle.net/1969.1/ETD-TAMU-2010-12-8925

Competitive Bidding, Competitive Sealed Proposal, construction management agency, construction management at risk, Design-Build, Design-Build-Bridging, and job order contracting are seven project delivery methods that are commonly used in the state of Texas today. This paper empirically compares the cost, schedule, and change order management performance of these project delivery methods in 2009 Engineering News Record (ENR) Best Construction Projects in Texas, using the data collected from the projects representative of the population. Also information is collected on lessons learned from these projects. The thesis included development of survey instrument, getting approval from Institutional Review Board (IRB), data collection from the industry, statistical analysis and inferences. Based on the data collected, project performances were measured in terms of five identified variables and then plotted in the form of probability distribution curves to understand the characteristics of the target population. Then, the results were grouped into six categories based on project delivery methods used and compared to understand their impacts on these projects. Findings revealed predominant usage of CM at Risk PDM, and better cost and schedule performance of CM at Risk, Design-Build, and Owner customized PDM. Detailed performance metrics, results, interpretations and conclusions are presented.