Examining Scholarly Influence: A Study in Hirsch Metrics and Social Network Analysis

• Main Author: Takeda, Hirotoshi
• Format: Others
• Published: Digital Archive @ GSU 2011
• Subjects: Bibliometric; Hirsch Metric; Journal Ranking; Scholarly Influence; Social Influence; Social Network Analysis; Management Information Systems
• Online Access: http://digitalarchive.gsu.edu/cis_diss/44; http://digitalarchive.gsu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1044&context=cis_diss

This dissertation research is focused on how we, as researchers, ‘influence’ others researchers. In particular, I am concerned with the notion of what constitutes the ‘influence’ of a scholar and how ‘influence’ is conferred upon scholars. This research is concerned with the construct called ‘scholarly influence’. Scholarly influence is of interest because a clear “theory of scholarly influence” does not yet exist. Rather a number of surrogate measures or concepts that are variable are used to evaluate the value of one’s academic work. ‘Scholarly influence’ is broken down into ‘ideational influence’ or the influence that one has through publication and the uptake of the ideas presented in the publication, and ‘social influence’ or the influence that one has through working with other researchers. Finally through the use of the definition of ‘scholarly influence’ this dissertation tries to commence a definition of ‘quality’ in scholarly work.