Unintended effects of immigration policies for government and migrants

• Main Authors: Baumann, Mechthild, Lorenz, Astrid, Rosenow, Kerstin
• Other Authors: Budrich UniPress,
• Format: Others
• Language: English
• Published: Universitätsbibliothek Leipzig 2014
• Subjects: Europa; USA; Einwanderung; Einwanderungspolitik; Grenzkontrolle; Europe; immigration; immigration policy; border control; ddc:320; ddc:325
• Online Access: http://nbn-resolving.de/urn:nbn:de:bsz:15-qucosa-158366; http://nbn-resolving.de/urn:nbn:de:bsz:15-qucosa-158366; http://www.qucosa.de/fileadmin/data/qucosa/documents/15836/Baumann%20Lorenz%20Rosenow%202011%20Unintended%20Effects%20of%20Immigration%20Policies.pdf

In this chapter, we draw empirical and theoretical conclusions based on the various analyses contained in this volume that focus on the European and U.S. migration regimes. We conclude that immigration policies have a multitude of unintended effects which affect both migrants and governments in the countries of origin, transit, and arrival. This chapter begins with an overview of the interest policies inside and outside the ‘defended’ territories. In the U.S. a lucrative internal market of border control has emerged, whereas the EU’s externalized border control includes the neighboring countries. The second part describes the unintended effects arising due to inconsistent general policies of the countries of arrival and origin, which often contradict the official immigration policies. Following this, the limited effect of border control measures on immigrants and their journeys are discussed. In the fourth section we explore in more detail the unintended effects in the form of new areas of cooperation, including new forms of self-organization, local interest groups, and sanctuary movements. The final section summarizes the various unintended effects and offers recommendations for decision makers in the field of migration policy.