The use of rapid dengue diagnostic tests in a routine clinical setting in a dengue-endemic area of Colombia

There is insufficient evidence of the usefulness of dengue diagnostic tests under routine conditions. We sought to analyse how physicians are using dengue diagnostics to inform research and development. Subjects attending 14 health institutions in an endemic area of Colombia with either a clinical d...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Lyda Osorio, Marcela Uribe, Gloria Ines Ardila, Yaneth Orejuela, Margarita Velasco, Anilza Bonelo, Beatriz Parra
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Instituto Oswaldo Cruz, Ministério da Saúde 2015-06-01
Series:Memórias do Instituto Oswaldo Cruz.
Subjects:
Online Access:http://www.scielo.br/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S0074-02762015000400510&lng=en&tlng=en
id doaj-fe292c326b4a46a6a1ccb4d68f3b4e7b
record_format Article
spelling doaj-fe292c326b4a46a6a1ccb4d68f3b4e7b2020-11-25T01:34:52ZengInstituto Oswaldo Cruz, Ministério da SaúdeMemórias do Instituto Oswaldo Cruz.1678-80602015-06-01110451051610.1590/0074-02760140359S0074-02762015000400510The use of rapid dengue diagnostic tests in a routine clinical setting in a dengue-endemic area of ColombiaLyda OsorioMarcela UribeGloria Ines ArdilaYaneth OrejuelaMargarita VelascoAnilza BoneloBeatriz ParraThere is insufficient evidence of the usefulness of dengue diagnostic tests under routine conditions. We sought to analyse how physicians are using dengue diagnostics to inform research and development. Subjects attending 14 health institutions in an endemic area of Colombia with either a clinical diagnosis of dengue or for whom a dengue test was ordered were included in the study. Patterns of test-use are described herein. Factors associated with the ordering of dengue diagnostic tests were identified using contingency tables, nonparametric tests and logistic regression. A total of 778 subjects were diagnosed with dengue by the treating physician, of whom 386 (49.5%) were tested for dengue. Another 491 dengue tests were ordered in subjects whose primary diagnosis was not dengue. Severe dengue classification [odds ratio (OR) 2.2; 95% confidence interval (CI) 1.1-4.5], emergency consultation (OR 1.9; 95% CI 1.4-2.5) and month of the year (OR 3.1; 95% CI 1.7-5.5) were independently associated with ordering of dengue tests. Dengue tests were used both to rule in and rule out diagnosis. The latter use is not justified by the sensitivity of current rapid dengue diagnostic tests. Ordering of dengue tests appear to depend on a combination of factors, including physician and institutional preferences, as well as other patient and epidemiological factors.http://www.scielo.br/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S0074-02762015000400510&lng=en&tlng=endenguediagnosishealth servicesdecision making
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Lyda Osorio
Marcela Uribe
Gloria Ines Ardila
Yaneth Orejuela
Margarita Velasco
Anilza Bonelo
Beatriz Parra
spellingShingle Lyda Osorio
Marcela Uribe
Gloria Ines Ardila
Yaneth Orejuela
Margarita Velasco
Anilza Bonelo
Beatriz Parra
The use of rapid dengue diagnostic tests in a routine clinical setting in a dengue-endemic area of Colombia
Memórias do Instituto Oswaldo Cruz.
dengue
diagnosis
health services
decision making
author_facet Lyda Osorio
Marcela Uribe
Gloria Ines Ardila
Yaneth Orejuela
Margarita Velasco
Anilza Bonelo
Beatriz Parra
author_sort Lyda Osorio
title The use of rapid dengue diagnostic tests in a routine clinical setting in a dengue-endemic area of Colombia
title_short The use of rapid dengue diagnostic tests in a routine clinical setting in a dengue-endemic area of Colombia
title_full The use of rapid dengue diagnostic tests in a routine clinical setting in a dengue-endemic area of Colombia
title_fullStr The use of rapid dengue diagnostic tests in a routine clinical setting in a dengue-endemic area of Colombia
title_full_unstemmed The use of rapid dengue diagnostic tests in a routine clinical setting in a dengue-endemic area of Colombia
title_sort use of rapid dengue diagnostic tests in a routine clinical setting in a dengue-endemic area of colombia
publisher Instituto Oswaldo Cruz, Ministério da Saúde
series Memórias do Instituto Oswaldo Cruz.
issn 1678-8060
publishDate 2015-06-01
description There is insufficient evidence of the usefulness of dengue diagnostic tests under routine conditions. We sought to analyse how physicians are using dengue diagnostics to inform research and development. Subjects attending 14 health institutions in an endemic area of Colombia with either a clinical diagnosis of dengue or for whom a dengue test was ordered were included in the study. Patterns of test-use are described herein. Factors associated with the ordering of dengue diagnostic tests were identified using contingency tables, nonparametric tests and logistic regression. A total of 778 subjects were diagnosed with dengue by the treating physician, of whom 386 (49.5%) were tested for dengue. Another 491 dengue tests were ordered in subjects whose primary diagnosis was not dengue. Severe dengue classification [odds ratio (OR) 2.2; 95% confidence interval (CI) 1.1-4.5], emergency consultation (OR 1.9; 95% CI 1.4-2.5) and month of the year (OR 3.1; 95% CI 1.7-5.5) were independently associated with ordering of dengue tests. Dengue tests were used both to rule in and rule out diagnosis. The latter use is not justified by the sensitivity of current rapid dengue diagnostic tests. Ordering of dengue tests appear to depend on a combination of factors, including physician and institutional preferences, as well as other patient and epidemiological factors.
topic dengue
diagnosis
health services
decision making
url http://www.scielo.br/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S0074-02762015000400510&lng=en&tlng=en
work_keys_str_mv AT lydaosorio theuseofrapiddenguediagnostictestsinaroutineclinicalsettinginadengueendemicareaofcolombia
AT marcelauribe theuseofrapiddenguediagnostictestsinaroutineclinicalsettinginadengueendemicareaofcolombia
AT gloriainesardila theuseofrapiddenguediagnostictestsinaroutineclinicalsettinginadengueendemicareaofcolombia
AT yanethorejuela theuseofrapiddenguediagnostictestsinaroutineclinicalsettinginadengueendemicareaofcolombia
AT margaritavelasco theuseofrapiddenguediagnostictestsinaroutineclinicalsettinginadengueendemicareaofcolombia
AT anilzabonelo theuseofrapiddenguediagnostictestsinaroutineclinicalsettinginadengueendemicareaofcolombia
AT beatrizparra theuseofrapiddenguediagnostictestsinaroutineclinicalsettinginadengueendemicareaofcolombia
AT lydaosorio useofrapiddenguediagnostictestsinaroutineclinicalsettinginadengueendemicareaofcolombia
AT marcelauribe useofrapiddenguediagnostictestsinaroutineclinicalsettinginadengueendemicareaofcolombia
AT gloriainesardila useofrapiddenguediagnostictestsinaroutineclinicalsettinginadengueendemicareaofcolombia
AT yanethorejuela useofrapiddenguediagnostictestsinaroutineclinicalsettinginadengueendemicareaofcolombia
AT margaritavelasco useofrapiddenguediagnostictestsinaroutineclinicalsettinginadengueendemicareaofcolombia
AT anilzabonelo useofrapiddenguediagnostictestsinaroutineclinicalsettinginadengueendemicareaofcolombia
AT beatrizparra useofrapiddenguediagnostictestsinaroutineclinicalsettinginadengueendemicareaofcolombia
_version_ 1725069909678882816