Alignment of Qx100/Qx200 Droplet Digital (Bio-Rad) and QuantStudio 3D (Thermofisher) Digital PCR for Quantification of BCR-ABL1 in Ph+ Chronic Myeloid Leukemia

In recent years, the digital polymerase chain reaction has received increasing interest as it has emerged as a tool to provide more sensitive and accurate detection of minimal residual disease. In order to start the process of data alignment, we assessed the consistency of the BCR-ABL1 quantificatio...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Carmen Fava, Simona Bernardi, Enrico Marco Gottardi, Roberta Lorenzatti, Laura Galeotti, Francesco Ceccherini, Francesco Cordoni, Filomena Daraio, Emilia Giugliano, Aleksandar Jovanovski, Jessica Petiti, Marta Varotto, Davide Barberio, Giovanna Rege-Cambrin, Paola Berchialla, Veronica Sciannameo, Michele Malagola, Giuseppe Saglio, Domenico Russo
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: MDPI AG 2021-05-01
Series:Diseases
Subjects:
CML
Online Access:https://www.mdpi.com/2079-9721/9/2/35
id doaj-fc53b0a8c5ce458983965d3c6ea2be53
record_format Article
spelling doaj-fc53b0a8c5ce458983965d3c6ea2be532021-05-31T23:13:40ZengMDPI AGDiseases2079-97212021-05-019353510.3390/diseases9020035Alignment of Qx100/Qx200 Droplet Digital (Bio-Rad) and QuantStudio 3D (Thermofisher) Digital PCR for Quantification of BCR-ABL1 in Ph+ Chronic Myeloid LeukemiaCarmen Fava0Simona Bernardi1Enrico Marco Gottardi2Roberta Lorenzatti3Laura Galeotti4Francesco Ceccherini5Francesco Cordoni6Filomena Daraio7Emilia Giugliano8Aleksandar Jovanovski9Jessica Petiti10Marta Varotto11Davide Barberio12Giovanna Rege-Cambrin13Paola Berchialla14Veronica Sciannameo15Michele Malagola16Giuseppe Saglio17Domenico Russo18Department of Clinical and Biological Sciences, University of Turin, AOU San Luigi Gonzaga, Orbassano, 10043 Turin, ItalyUnit of Blood Diseases and Stem Cell Transplantation, DPT of Clinical and Experimental Sciences, University of Brescia, ASST SpedaliCivili di Brescia, 25123 Brescia, ItalyDivision of Internal Medicine and Hematology, San Luigi Gonzaga Hospital, Orbassano, 10043 Turin, ItalyDivision of Internal Medicine and Hematology, San Luigi Gonzaga Hospital, Orbassano, 10043 Turin, ItalyPhymtechSrl, Via F.lli Rosselli 8, Madonna dell’Acqua, San Giuliano Terme, 56017 Pisa, ItalyPhymtechSrl, Via F.lli Rosselli 8, Madonna dell’Acqua, San Giuliano Terme, 56017 Pisa, ItalyPhymtechSrl, Via F.lli Rosselli 8, Madonna dell’Acqua, San Giuliano Terme, 56017 Pisa, ItalyDivision of Internal Medicine and Hematology, San Luigi Gonzaga Hospital, Orbassano, 10043 Turin, ItalyDivision of Internal Medicine and Hematology, San Luigi Gonzaga Hospital, Orbassano, 10043 Turin, ItalyDepartment of Clinical and Biological Sciences, University of Turin, AOU San Luigi Gonzaga, Orbassano, 10043 Turin, ItalyDepartment of Clinical and Biological Sciences, University of Turin, AOU San Luigi Gonzaga, Orbassano, 10043 Turin, ItalyBioclarmas.r.l. Research and Molecular Diagnostics, 10126 Torino, ItalyBioclarmas.r.l. Research and Molecular Diagnostics, 10126 Torino, ItalyDivision of Internal Medicine and Hematology, San Luigi Gonzaga Hospital, Orbassano, 10043 Turin, ItalyDepartment of Clinical and Biological Sciences, University of Turin, AOU San Luigi Gonzaga, Orbassano, 10043 Turin, ItalyUnit of Biostatistics, Department of Cardiac, Thoracic and Vascular Sciences, Epidemiology and Public Health, University of Padova, 35128 Padova, ItalyUnit of Blood Diseases and Stem Cell Transplantation, DPT of Clinical and Experimental Sciences, University of Brescia, ASST SpedaliCivili di Brescia, 25123 Brescia, ItalyDepartment of Clinical and Biological Sciences, University of Turin, AOU San Luigi Gonzaga, Orbassano, 10043 Turin, ItalyUnit of Blood Diseases and Stem Cell Transplantation, DPT of Clinical and Experimental Sciences, University of Brescia, ASST SpedaliCivili di Brescia, 25123 Brescia, ItalyIn recent years, the digital polymerase chain reaction has received increasing interest as it has emerged as a tool to provide more sensitive and accurate detection of minimal residual disease. In order to start the process of data alignment, we assessed the consistency of the BCR-ABL1 quantification results of the analysis of 16 RNA samples at different levels of disease. The results were obtained by two different laboratories that relied on The Qx100/Qx200 Droplet Digital PCR System (Bio-Rad) and Quant Studio 3D dPCR System (Thermofisher) platforms. We assessed the compatibility between the estimated values by linear regression, Bland–Altman bias-plot, and Mann–Whitney nonparametric test. The results confirmed the compatibility of the measures, allowing us tocompute an ‘alignment factor’ (AF), equal to 1.41, which was further validated by a different series of experiments. We conclude that the performed measurements by the two laboratories are comparable, and also equalized through the introduction of an alignment factor.https://www.mdpi.com/2079-9721/9/2/35digital polymerase chain reactiondigital PCRdPCRchronic myeloid leukemiaCMLminimal residual disease
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Carmen Fava
Simona Bernardi
Enrico Marco Gottardi
Roberta Lorenzatti
Laura Galeotti
Francesco Ceccherini
Francesco Cordoni
Filomena Daraio
Emilia Giugliano
Aleksandar Jovanovski
Jessica Petiti
Marta Varotto
Davide Barberio
Giovanna Rege-Cambrin
Paola Berchialla
Veronica Sciannameo
Michele Malagola
Giuseppe Saglio
Domenico Russo
spellingShingle Carmen Fava
Simona Bernardi
Enrico Marco Gottardi
Roberta Lorenzatti
Laura Galeotti
Francesco Ceccherini
Francesco Cordoni
Filomena Daraio
Emilia Giugliano
Aleksandar Jovanovski
Jessica Petiti
Marta Varotto
Davide Barberio
Giovanna Rege-Cambrin
Paola Berchialla
Veronica Sciannameo
Michele Malagola
Giuseppe Saglio
Domenico Russo
Alignment of Qx100/Qx200 Droplet Digital (Bio-Rad) and QuantStudio 3D (Thermofisher) Digital PCR for Quantification of BCR-ABL1 in Ph+ Chronic Myeloid Leukemia
Diseases
digital polymerase chain reaction
digital PCR
dPCR
chronic myeloid leukemia
CML
minimal residual disease
author_facet Carmen Fava
Simona Bernardi
Enrico Marco Gottardi
Roberta Lorenzatti
Laura Galeotti
Francesco Ceccherini
Francesco Cordoni
Filomena Daraio
Emilia Giugliano
Aleksandar Jovanovski
Jessica Petiti
Marta Varotto
Davide Barberio
Giovanna Rege-Cambrin
Paola Berchialla
Veronica Sciannameo
Michele Malagola
Giuseppe Saglio
Domenico Russo
author_sort Carmen Fava
title Alignment of Qx100/Qx200 Droplet Digital (Bio-Rad) and QuantStudio 3D (Thermofisher) Digital PCR for Quantification of BCR-ABL1 in Ph+ Chronic Myeloid Leukemia
title_short Alignment of Qx100/Qx200 Droplet Digital (Bio-Rad) and QuantStudio 3D (Thermofisher) Digital PCR for Quantification of BCR-ABL1 in Ph+ Chronic Myeloid Leukemia
title_full Alignment of Qx100/Qx200 Droplet Digital (Bio-Rad) and QuantStudio 3D (Thermofisher) Digital PCR for Quantification of BCR-ABL1 in Ph+ Chronic Myeloid Leukemia
title_fullStr Alignment of Qx100/Qx200 Droplet Digital (Bio-Rad) and QuantStudio 3D (Thermofisher) Digital PCR for Quantification of BCR-ABL1 in Ph+ Chronic Myeloid Leukemia
title_full_unstemmed Alignment of Qx100/Qx200 Droplet Digital (Bio-Rad) and QuantStudio 3D (Thermofisher) Digital PCR for Quantification of BCR-ABL1 in Ph+ Chronic Myeloid Leukemia
title_sort alignment of qx100/qx200 droplet digital (bio-rad) and quantstudio 3d (thermofisher) digital pcr for quantification of bcr-abl1 in ph+ chronic myeloid leukemia
publisher MDPI AG
series Diseases
issn 2079-9721
publishDate 2021-05-01
description In recent years, the digital polymerase chain reaction has received increasing interest as it has emerged as a tool to provide more sensitive and accurate detection of minimal residual disease. In order to start the process of data alignment, we assessed the consistency of the BCR-ABL1 quantification results of the analysis of 16 RNA samples at different levels of disease. The results were obtained by two different laboratories that relied on The Qx100/Qx200 Droplet Digital PCR System (Bio-Rad) and Quant Studio 3D dPCR System (Thermofisher) platforms. We assessed the compatibility between the estimated values by linear regression, Bland–Altman bias-plot, and Mann–Whitney nonparametric test. The results confirmed the compatibility of the measures, allowing us tocompute an ‘alignment factor’ (AF), equal to 1.41, which was further validated by a different series of experiments. We conclude that the performed measurements by the two laboratories are comparable, and also equalized through the introduction of an alignment factor.
topic digital polymerase chain reaction
digital PCR
dPCR
chronic myeloid leukemia
CML
minimal residual disease
url https://www.mdpi.com/2079-9721/9/2/35
work_keys_str_mv AT carmenfava alignmentofqx100qx200dropletdigitalbioradandquantstudio3dthermofisherdigitalpcrforquantificationofbcrabl1inphchronicmyeloidleukemia
AT simonabernardi alignmentofqx100qx200dropletdigitalbioradandquantstudio3dthermofisherdigitalpcrforquantificationofbcrabl1inphchronicmyeloidleukemia
AT enricomarcogottardi alignmentofqx100qx200dropletdigitalbioradandquantstudio3dthermofisherdigitalpcrforquantificationofbcrabl1inphchronicmyeloidleukemia
AT robertalorenzatti alignmentofqx100qx200dropletdigitalbioradandquantstudio3dthermofisherdigitalpcrforquantificationofbcrabl1inphchronicmyeloidleukemia
AT lauragaleotti alignmentofqx100qx200dropletdigitalbioradandquantstudio3dthermofisherdigitalpcrforquantificationofbcrabl1inphchronicmyeloidleukemia
AT francescoceccherini alignmentofqx100qx200dropletdigitalbioradandquantstudio3dthermofisherdigitalpcrforquantificationofbcrabl1inphchronicmyeloidleukemia
AT francescocordoni alignmentofqx100qx200dropletdigitalbioradandquantstudio3dthermofisherdigitalpcrforquantificationofbcrabl1inphchronicmyeloidleukemia
AT filomenadaraio alignmentofqx100qx200dropletdigitalbioradandquantstudio3dthermofisherdigitalpcrforquantificationofbcrabl1inphchronicmyeloidleukemia
AT emiliagiugliano alignmentofqx100qx200dropletdigitalbioradandquantstudio3dthermofisherdigitalpcrforquantificationofbcrabl1inphchronicmyeloidleukemia
AT aleksandarjovanovski alignmentofqx100qx200dropletdigitalbioradandquantstudio3dthermofisherdigitalpcrforquantificationofbcrabl1inphchronicmyeloidleukemia
AT jessicapetiti alignmentofqx100qx200dropletdigitalbioradandquantstudio3dthermofisherdigitalpcrforquantificationofbcrabl1inphchronicmyeloidleukemia
AT martavarotto alignmentofqx100qx200dropletdigitalbioradandquantstudio3dthermofisherdigitalpcrforquantificationofbcrabl1inphchronicmyeloidleukemia
AT davidebarberio alignmentofqx100qx200dropletdigitalbioradandquantstudio3dthermofisherdigitalpcrforquantificationofbcrabl1inphchronicmyeloidleukemia
AT giovannaregecambrin alignmentofqx100qx200dropletdigitalbioradandquantstudio3dthermofisherdigitalpcrforquantificationofbcrabl1inphchronicmyeloidleukemia
AT paolaberchialla alignmentofqx100qx200dropletdigitalbioradandquantstudio3dthermofisherdigitalpcrforquantificationofbcrabl1inphchronicmyeloidleukemia
AT veronicasciannameo alignmentofqx100qx200dropletdigitalbioradandquantstudio3dthermofisherdigitalpcrforquantificationofbcrabl1inphchronicmyeloidleukemia
AT michelemalagola alignmentofqx100qx200dropletdigitalbioradandquantstudio3dthermofisherdigitalpcrforquantificationofbcrabl1inphchronicmyeloidleukemia
AT giuseppesaglio alignmentofqx100qx200dropletdigitalbioradandquantstudio3dthermofisherdigitalpcrforquantificationofbcrabl1inphchronicmyeloidleukemia
AT domenicorusso alignmentofqx100qx200dropletdigitalbioradandquantstudio3dthermofisherdigitalpcrforquantificationofbcrabl1inphchronicmyeloidleukemia
_version_ 1721418130173984768