Measuring Electromagnetic Fields in Rotating Frames of Reference

We review the problem of transforming electromagnetic fields between inertial and rotating reference frames. We compare the method of straightforward tensor coordinate transformations adopted by Schiff in his well-known paper of 1939 with the method of Orthogonal Tetrads (OT) that was applied to thi...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Clive C. Speake, Antonello Ortolan
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: MDPI AG 2020-02-01
Series:Universe
Subjects:
Online Access:https://www.mdpi.com/2218-1997/6/2/31
id doaj-f4b01a878a43449eab2589284edd8046
record_format Article
spelling doaj-f4b01a878a43449eab2589284edd80462020-11-25T02:38:23ZengMDPI AGUniverse2218-19972020-02-01623110.3390/universe6020031universe6020031Measuring Electromagnetic Fields in Rotating Frames of ReferenceClive C. Speake0Antonello Ortolan1School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Birmingham, Edgbaston, Birmingham B15 2TT, UKLaboratori Nazionale di Legnaro, INFN, Vialle dell’Universita 2, 3520 Legnaro, Padova, ItalyWe review the problem of transforming electromagnetic fields between inertial and rotating reference frames. We compare the method of straightforward tensor coordinate transformations adopted by Schiff in his well-known paper of 1939 with the method of Orthogonal Tetrads (OT) that was applied to this problem in 1964 by Irvine. Although both methods are mathematically rigorous, the transformed fields have different forms depending on the method adopted. We emphasize that the OT method is expected to predict the fields that would actually be measured by an observer in a rotating frame of reference. We briefly discuss existing experimental evidence that supports the OT approach, but point out that there appears to be little awareness in the physics community of this problem or its resolution. We use both methods to transform the electrostatic and magnetic fields generated by rotating charged spherical shells from an inertial into a co-rotating system. We also briefly describe how such an arrangement of shells could be used to measure rotation relative to the fixed stars.https://www.mdpi.com/2218-1997/6/2/31special relativityelectromagnetismrotating frame
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Clive C. Speake
Antonello Ortolan
spellingShingle Clive C. Speake
Antonello Ortolan
Measuring Electromagnetic Fields in Rotating Frames of Reference
Universe
special relativity
electromagnetism
rotating frame
author_facet Clive C. Speake
Antonello Ortolan
author_sort Clive C. Speake
title Measuring Electromagnetic Fields in Rotating Frames of Reference
title_short Measuring Electromagnetic Fields in Rotating Frames of Reference
title_full Measuring Electromagnetic Fields in Rotating Frames of Reference
title_fullStr Measuring Electromagnetic Fields in Rotating Frames of Reference
title_full_unstemmed Measuring Electromagnetic Fields in Rotating Frames of Reference
title_sort measuring electromagnetic fields in rotating frames of reference
publisher MDPI AG
series Universe
issn 2218-1997
publishDate 2020-02-01
description We review the problem of transforming electromagnetic fields between inertial and rotating reference frames. We compare the method of straightforward tensor coordinate transformations adopted by Schiff in his well-known paper of 1939 with the method of Orthogonal Tetrads (OT) that was applied to this problem in 1964 by Irvine. Although both methods are mathematically rigorous, the transformed fields have different forms depending on the method adopted. We emphasize that the OT method is expected to predict the fields that would actually be measured by an observer in a rotating frame of reference. We briefly discuss existing experimental evidence that supports the OT approach, but point out that there appears to be little awareness in the physics community of this problem or its resolution. We use both methods to transform the electrostatic and magnetic fields generated by rotating charged spherical shells from an inertial into a co-rotating system. We also briefly describe how such an arrangement of shells could be used to measure rotation relative to the fixed stars.
topic special relativity
electromagnetism
rotating frame
url https://www.mdpi.com/2218-1997/6/2/31
work_keys_str_mv AT clivecspeake measuringelectromagneticfieldsinrotatingframesofreference
AT antonelloortolan measuringelectromagneticfieldsinrotatingframesofreference
_version_ 1724791259855323136