Effects of non-driving related tasks on mental workload and take-over times during conditional automated driving

Abstract Background Automated driving will be of high value in the future. While in partial-automated driving the driver must always monitor the traffic situation, a paradigm shift is taking place in the case of conditional automated driving (Level 3 according to SAE). From this level of automation...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Andreas Lars Müller, Natacha Fernandes-Estrela, Ruben Hetfleisch, Lukas Zecha, Bettina Abendroth
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: SpringerOpen 2021-02-01
Series:European Transport Research Review
Subjects:
Online Access:https://doi.org/10.1186/s12544-021-00475-5
id doaj-efe33316d02a4c3596d86bdece72e883
record_format Article
spelling doaj-efe33316d02a4c3596d86bdece72e8832021-02-21T12:15:39ZengSpringerOpenEuropean Transport Research Review1867-07171866-88872021-02-0113111510.1186/s12544-021-00475-5Effects of non-driving related tasks on mental workload and take-over times during conditional automated drivingAndreas Lars Müller0Natacha Fernandes-Estrela1Ruben Hetfleisch2Lukas Zecha3Bettina Abendroth4Technical University of Darmstadt, Department of Mechanical Engineering, Institute of Ergonomics and Human FactorsTechnical University of Darmstadt, Department of Mechanical Engineering, Institute of Ergonomics and Human FactorsTechnical University of Darmstadt, Department of Mechanical Engineering, Institute of Ergonomics and Human FactorsTechnical University of Darmstadt, Department of Mechanical Engineering, Institute of Ergonomics and Human FactorsTechnical University of Darmstadt, Department of Mechanical Engineering, Institute of Ergonomics and Human FactorsAbstract Background Automated driving will be of high value in the future. While in partial-automated driving the driver must always monitor the traffic situation, a paradigm shift is taking place in the case of conditional automated driving (Level 3 according to SAE). From this level of automation onwards, the vehicle user is released from permanent vehicle control and environmental monitoring and is allowed to engage in Non-Driving Related Tasks (NDRT) in his or her newly gained spare time. These tasks can be performed until a take-over request informs the user to resume vehicle control. As the driver is still considered to be the fall-back level, this aspect of taking over control is considered especially critical. Methods While previous research projects have focused their studies on the factors influencing the take-over request, this paper focuses on the effects of NDRT on the user of the vehicle during conditional automated driving, especially on the human workload. NDRT (such as Reading, Listening, Watching a movie, Texting and Monitoring ride) were examined within a static driving simulator at the Institute of Ergonomics & Human Factors with 56 participants in an urban environment. These NDRT were tested for mental workload and the ability to take over in a critical situation. To determine the perceived workload, the subjective workload, psychophysiological activity as well as performance-based parameters of a secondary competing task performed by a were used. Results This study revealed that the selected NDRT vary significantly in their mental workload and that the workload correlates with the length of the time needed for take over control. NDRT which are associated with a high workload (such as Reading or Texting) also lead to longer reaction times.https://doi.org/10.1186/s12544-021-00475-5Automated drivingMental workloadTake-over timeDriving simulatorNon-driving related task
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Andreas Lars Müller
Natacha Fernandes-Estrela
Ruben Hetfleisch
Lukas Zecha
Bettina Abendroth
spellingShingle Andreas Lars Müller
Natacha Fernandes-Estrela
Ruben Hetfleisch
Lukas Zecha
Bettina Abendroth
Effects of non-driving related tasks on mental workload and take-over times during conditional automated driving
European Transport Research Review
Automated driving
Mental workload
Take-over time
Driving simulator
Non-driving related task
author_facet Andreas Lars Müller
Natacha Fernandes-Estrela
Ruben Hetfleisch
Lukas Zecha
Bettina Abendroth
author_sort Andreas Lars Müller
title Effects of non-driving related tasks on mental workload and take-over times during conditional automated driving
title_short Effects of non-driving related tasks on mental workload and take-over times during conditional automated driving
title_full Effects of non-driving related tasks on mental workload and take-over times during conditional automated driving
title_fullStr Effects of non-driving related tasks on mental workload and take-over times during conditional automated driving
title_full_unstemmed Effects of non-driving related tasks on mental workload and take-over times during conditional automated driving
title_sort effects of non-driving related tasks on mental workload and take-over times during conditional automated driving
publisher SpringerOpen
series European Transport Research Review
issn 1867-0717
1866-8887
publishDate 2021-02-01
description Abstract Background Automated driving will be of high value in the future. While in partial-automated driving the driver must always monitor the traffic situation, a paradigm shift is taking place in the case of conditional automated driving (Level 3 according to SAE). From this level of automation onwards, the vehicle user is released from permanent vehicle control and environmental monitoring and is allowed to engage in Non-Driving Related Tasks (NDRT) in his or her newly gained spare time. These tasks can be performed until a take-over request informs the user to resume vehicle control. As the driver is still considered to be the fall-back level, this aspect of taking over control is considered especially critical. Methods While previous research projects have focused their studies on the factors influencing the take-over request, this paper focuses on the effects of NDRT on the user of the vehicle during conditional automated driving, especially on the human workload. NDRT (such as Reading, Listening, Watching a movie, Texting and Monitoring ride) were examined within a static driving simulator at the Institute of Ergonomics & Human Factors with 56 participants in an urban environment. These NDRT were tested for mental workload and the ability to take over in a critical situation. To determine the perceived workload, the subjective workload, psychophysiological activity as well as performance-based parameters of a secondary competing task performed by a were used. Results This study revealed that the selected NDRT vary significantly in their mental workload and that the workload correlates with the length of the time needed for take over control. NDRT which are associated with a high workload (such as Reading or Texting) also lead to longer reaction times.
topic Automated driving
Mental workload
Take-over time
Driving simulator
Non-driving related task
url https://doi.org/10.1186/s12544-021-00475-5
work_keys_str_mv AT andreaslarsmuller effectsofnondrivingrelatedtasksonmentalworkloadandtakeovertimesduringconditionalautomateddriving
AT natachafernandesestrela effectsofnondrivingrelatedtasksonmentalworkloadandtakeovertimesduringconditionalautomateddriving
AT rubenhetfleisch effectsofnondrivingrelatedtasksonmentalworkloadandtakeovertimesduringconditionalautomateddriving
AT lukaszecha effectsofnondrivingrelatedtasksonmentalworkloadandtakeovertimesduringconditionalautomateddriving
AT bettinaabendroth effectsofnondrivingrelatedtasksonmentalworkloadandtakeovertimesduringconditionalautomateddriving
_version_ 1724258329487736832