A new specific succinate-glutamate metabolomic hallmark in SDHx-related paragangliomas.

Paragangliomas (PGLs) are frequently associated with germline mutations in genes involved in energy metabolism. The purpose of the present study was to assess whether the tumor metabolomic profile of patients with hereditary and apparently sporadic PGLs enables the distinction of different subtypes...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Alessio Imperiale, François-Marie Moussallieh, Frédéric Sebag, Laurent Brunaud, Anne Barlier, Karim Elbayed, Philippe Bachellier, Bernard Goichot, Karel Pacak, Izzie-Jacques Namer, David Taïeb
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Public Library of Science (PLoS) 2013-01-01
Series:PLoS ONE
Online Access:http://europepmc.org/articles/PMC3842321?pdf=render
id doaj-ef9d1b444d604e09898d2b475178983c
record_format Article
spelling doaj-ef9d1b444d604e09898d2b475178983c2020-11-24T21:50:43ZengPublic Library of Science (PLoS)PLoS ONE1932-62032013-01-01811e8053910.1371/journal.pone.0080539A new specific succinate-glutamate metabolomic hallmark in SDHx-related paragangliomas.Alessio ImperialeFrançois-Marie MoussalliehFrédéric SebagLaurent BrunaudAnne BarlierKarim ElbayedPhilippe BachellierBernard GoichotKarel PacakIzzie-Jacques NamerDavid TaïebParagangliomas (PGLs) are frequently associated with germline mutations in genes involved in energy metabolism. The purpose of the present study was to assess whether the tumor metabolomic profile of patients with hereditary and apparently sporadic PGLs enables the distinction of different subtypes of tumors. Twenty-eight unrelated patients with a histological diagnosis of PGLs were included in the present study. Twelve had germline mutations in SDHx genes (5 SDHB, 7 SDHD), 6 VHL, and 10 were apparently sporadic. Intact tumor samples from these patients (one per patient) were evaluated with (1)H high-resolution magic angle spinning (HRMAS) NMR spectroscopy. SDHx-related tumors were characterized by an increase in succinate levels in comparison to other tumor subtypes (p = 0.0001 vs VHL and p = 0.000003 vs apparently sporadic). Furthermore, we found significantly lower values of glutamate in SDHx-related tumors compared to other subtypes (p = 0.0007 vs VHL and p = 0.003 vs apparently sporadic). Moreover, SDHx-tumors also exhibited lower values of ATP/ADP/AMP (p = 0.01) compared to VHL. VHL tumors were found to have the highest values of glutathione (GSH) compared to other tumors. Based on 4 metabolites (succinate, glutamate, GSH, and ATP/ADP/AMP), tumors were accurately distinguished from the other ones on both 3- and 2-class PLS-DA models. The present study shows that HRMAS NMR spectroscopy is a very promising method for investigating the metabolomic profile of various PGLs. The present data suggest the existence of a specific succinate-glutamate hallmark of SDHx PGLs. The relevance of such a metabolomic hallmark is expected to be very useful in designing novel treatment options as well as improving the diagnosis and follow-up of these tumors, including metastatic ones.http://europepmc.org/articles/PMC3842321?pdf=render
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Alessio Imperiale
François-Marie Moussallieh
Frédéric Sebag
Laurent Brunaud
Anne Barlier
Karim Elbayed
Philippe Bachellier
Bernard Goichot
Karel Pacak
Izzie-Jacques Namer
David Taïeb
spellingShingle Alessio Imperiale
François-Marie Moussallieh
Frédéric Sebag
Laurent Brunaud
Anne Barlier
Karim Elbayed
Philippe Bachellier
Bernard Goichot
Karel Pacak
Izzie-Jacques Namer
David Taïeb
A new specific succinate-glutamate metabolomic hallmark in SDHx-related paragangliomas.
PLoS ONE
author_facet Alessio Imperiale
François-Marie Moussallieh
Frédéric Sebag
Laurent Brunaud
Anne Barlier
Karim Elbayed
Philippe Bachellier
Bernard Goichot
Karel Pacak
Izzie-Jacques Namer
David Taïeb
author_sort Alessio Imperiale
title A new specific succinate-glutamate metabolomic hallmark in SDHx-related paragangliomas.
title_short A new specific succinate-glutamate metabolomic hallmark in SDHx-related paragangliomas.
title_full A new specific succinate-glutamate metabolomic hallmark in SDHx-related paragangliomas.
title_fullStr A new specific succinate-glutamate metabolomic hallmark in SDHx-related paragangliomas.
title_full_unstemmed A new specific succinate-glutamate metabolomic hallmark in SDHx-related paragangliomas.
title_sort new specific succinate-glutamate metabolomic hallmark in sdhx-related paragangliomas.
publisher Public Library of Science (PLoS)
series PLoS ONE
issn 1932-6203
publishDate 2013-01-01
description Paragangliomas (PGLs) are frequently associated with germline mutations in genes involved in energy metabolism. The purpose of the present study was to assess whether the tumor metabolomic profile of patients with hereditary and apparently sporadic PGLs enables the distinction of different subtypes of tumors. Twenty-eight unrelated patients with a histological diagnosis of PGLs were included in the present study. Twelve had germline mutations in SDHx genes (5 SDHB, 7 SDHD), 6 VHL, and 10 were apparently sporadic. Intact tumor samples from these patients (one per patient) were evaluated with (1)H high-resolution magic angle spinning (HRMAS) NMR spectroscopy. SDHx-related tumors were characterized by an increase in succinate levels in comparison to other tumor subtypes (p = 0.0001 vs VHL and p = 0.000003 vs apparently sporadic). Furthermore, we found significantly lower values of glutamate in SDHx-related tumors compared to other subtypes (p = 0.0007 vs VHL and p = 0.003 vs apparently sporadic). Moreover, SDHx-tumors also exhibited lower values of ATP/ADP/AMP (p = 0.01) compared to VHL. VHL tumors were found to have the highest values of glutathione (GSH) compared to other tumors. Based on 4 metabolites (succinate, glutamate, GSH, and ATP/ADP/AMP), tumors were accurately distinguished from the other ones on both 3- and 2-class PLS-DA models. The present study shows that HRMAS NMR spectroscopy is a very promising method for investigating the metabolomic profile of various PGLs. The present data suggest the existence of a specific succinate-glutamate hallmark of SDHx PGLs. The relevance of such a metabolomic hallmark is expected to be very useful in designing novel treatment options as well as improving the diagnosis and follow-up of these tumors, including metastatic ones.
url http://europepmc.org/articles/PMC3842321?pdf=render
work_keys_str_mv AT alessioimperiale anewspecificsuccinateglutamatemetabolomichallmarkinsdhxrelatedparagangliomas
AT francoismariemoussallieh anewspecificsuccinateglutamatemetabolomichallmarkinsdhxrelatedparagangliomas
AT fredericsebag anewspecificsuccinateglutamatemetabolomichallmarkinsdhxrelatedparagangliomas
AT laurentbrunaud anewspecificsuccinateglutamatemetabolomichallmarkinsdhxrelatedparagangliomas
AT annebarlier anewspecificsuccinateglutamatemetabolomichallmarkinsdhxrelatedparagangliomas
AT karimelbayed anewspecificsuccinateglutamatemetabolomichallmarkinsdhxrelatedparagangliomas
AT philippebachellier anewspecificsuccinateglutamatemetabolomichallmarkinsdhxrelatedparagangliomas
AT bernardgoichot anewspecificsuccinateglutamatemetabolomichallmarkinsdhxrelatedparagangliomas
AT karelpacak anewspecificsuccinateglutamatemetabolomichallmarkinsdhxrelatedparagangliomas
AT izziejacquesnamer anewspecificsuccinateglutamatemetabolomichallmarkinsdhxrelatedparagangliomas
AT davidtaieb anewspecificsuccinateglutamatemetabolomichallmarkinsdhxrelatedparagangliomas
AT alessioimperiale newspecificsuccinateglutamatemetabolomichallmarkinsdhxrelatedparagangliomas
AT francoismariemoussallieh newspecificsuccinateglutamatemetabolomichallmarkinsdhxrelatedparagangliomas
AT fredericsebag newspecificsuccinateglutamatemetabolomichallmarkinsdhxrelatedparagangliomas
AT laurentbrunaud newspecificsuccinateglutamatemetabolomichallmarkinsdhxrelatedparagangliomas
AT annebarlier newspecificsuccinateglutamatemetabolomichallmarkinsdhxrelatedparagangliomas
AT karimelbayed newspecificsuccinateglutamatemetabolomichallmarkinsdhxrelatedparagangliomas
AT philippebachellier newspecificsuccinateglutamatemetabolomichallmarkinsdhxrelatedparagangliomas
AT bernardgoichot newspecificsuccinateglutamatemetabolomichallmarkinsdhxrelatedparagangliomas
AT karelpacak newspecificsuccinateglutamatemetabolomichallmarkinsdhxrelatedparagangliomas
AT izziejacquesnamer newspecificsuccinateglutamatemetabolomichallmarkinsdhxrelatedparagangliomas
AT davidtaieb newspecificsuccinateglutamatemetabolomichallmarkinsdhxrelatedparagangliomas
_version_ 1725882098382798848