Palatability of Goat’s versus Cow’s Milk: Insights from the Analysis of Eating Behavior and Gene Expression in the Appetite-Relevant Brain Circuit in Laboratory Animal Models

Goat’s (GM) and cow’s milk (CM) are dietary alternatives with select health benefits shown in human and animal studies. Surprisingly, no systematic analysis of palatability or preference for GM vs. CM has been performed to date. Here, we present a comprehensive investigation of s...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Anica Klockars, Erin L. Wood, Sarah N. Gartner, Laura K. McColl, Allen S. Levine, Elizabeth A. Carpenter, Colin G. Prosser, Pawel K. Olszewski
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: MDPI AG 2019-03-01
Series:Nutrients
Subjects:
Online Access:https://www.mdpi.com/2072-6643/11/4/720
id doaj-e847cffe160047b6ad7f0994c863a295
record_format Article
spelling doaj-e847cffe160047b6ad7f0994c863a2952020-11-25T00:27:55ZengMDPI AGNutrients2072-66432019-03-0111472010.3390/nu11040720nu11040720Palatability of Goat’s versus Cow’s Milk: Insights from the Analysis of Eating Behavior and Gene Expression in the Appetite-Relevant Brain Circuit in Laboratory Animal ModelsAnica Klockars0Erin L. Wood1Sarah N. Gartner2Laura K. McColl3Allen S. Levine4Elizabeth A. Carpenter5Colin G. Prosser6Pawel K. Olszewski7Faculty of Science and Engineering, University of Waikato, Hamilton 3240, New ZealandFaculty of Science and Engineering, University of Waikato, Hamilton 3240, New ZealandFaculty of Science and Engineering, University of Waikato, Hamilton 3240, New ZealandFaculty of Science and Engineering, University of Waikato, Hamilton 3240, New ZealandDepartment of Food Science and Nutrition, University of Minnesota, St. Paul, MN 55113, USADairy Goat Cooperative (NZ) Ltd., Hamilton 3206, New ZealandDairy Goat Cooperative (NZ) Ltd., Hamilton 3206, New ZealandFaculty of Science and Engineering, University of Waikato, Hamilton 3240, New ZealandGoat’s (GM) and cow’s milk (CM) are dietary alternatives with select health benefits shown in human and animal studies. Surprisingly, no systematic analysis of palatability or preference for GM vs. CM has been performed to date. Here, we present a comprehensive investigation of short-term intake and palatability profiles of GM and CM in laboratory mice and rats. We studied consumption in no-choice and choice scenarios, including meal microstructure, and by using isocaloric milks and milk-enriched solid diets. Feeding results are accompanied by qPCR data of relevant genes in the energy balance-related hypothalamus and brain stem, and in the nucleus accumbens, which regulates eating for palatability. We found that GM and CM are palatable to juvenile, adult, and aged rodents. Given a choice, animals prefer GM- to CM-based diets. Analysis of meal microstructure using licking patterns points to enhanced palatability of and, possibly, greater motivation toward GM over CM. Most profound changes in gene expression after GM vs. CM were associated with the brain systems driving consumption for reward. We conclude that, while both GM and CM are palatable, GM is preferred over CM by laboratory animals, and this preference is driven by central mechanisms controlling eating for pleasure.https://www.mdpi.com/2072-6643/11/4/720milkhypothalamusnucleus accumbensrewardappetitepalatability
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Anica Klockars
Erin L. Wood
Sarah N. Gartner
Laura K. McColl
Allen S. Levine
Elizabeth A. Carpenter
Colin G. Prosser
Pawel K. Olszewski
spellingShingle Anica Klockars
Erin L. Wood
Sarah N. Gartner
Laura K. McColl
Allen S. Levine
Elizabeth A. Carpenter
Colin G. Prosser
Pawel K. Olszewski
Palatability of Goat’s versus Cow’s Milk: Insights from the Analysis of Eating Behavior and Gene Expression in the Appetite-Relevant Brain Circuit in Laboratory Animal Models
Nutrients
milk
hypothalamus
nucleus accumbens
reward
appetite
palatability
author_facet Anica Klockars
Erin L. Wood
Sarah N. Gartner
Laura K. McColl
Allen S. Levine
Elizabeth A. Carpenter
Colin G. Prosser
Pawel K. Olszewski
author_sort Anica Klockars
title Palatability of Goat’s versus Cow’s Milk: Insights from the Analysis of Eating Behavior and Gene Expression in the Appetite-Relevant Brain Circuit in Laboratory Animal Models
title_short Palatability of Goat’s versus Cow’s Milk: Insights from the Analysis of Eating Behavior and Gene Expression in the Appetite-Relevant Brain Circuit in Laboratory Animal Models
title_full Palatability of Goat’s versus Cow’s Milk: Insights from the Analysis of Eating Behavior and Gene Expression in the Appetite-Relevant Brain Circuit in Laboratory Animal Models
title_fullStr Palatability of Goat’s versus Cow’s Milk: Insights from the Analysis of Eating Behavior and Gene Expression in the Appetite-Relevant Brain Circuit in Laboratory Animal Models
title_full_unstemmed Palatability of Goat’s versus Cow’s Milk: Insights from the Analysis of Eating Behavior and Gene Expression in the Appetite-Relevant Brain Circuit in Laboratory Animal Models
title_sort palatability of goat’s versus cow’s milk: insights from the analysis of eating behavior and gene expression in the appetite-relevant brain circuit in laboratory animal models
publisher MDPI AG
series Nutrients
issn 2072-6643
publishDate 2019-03-01
description Goat’s (GM) and cow’s milk (CM) are dietary alternatives with select health benefits shown in human and animal studies. Surprisingly, no systematic analysis of palatability or preference for GM vs. CM has been performed to date. Here, we present a comprehensive investigation of short-term intake and palatability profiles of GM and CM in laboratory mice and rats. We studied consumption in no-choice and choice scenarios, including meal microstructure, and by using isocaloric milks and milk-enriched solid diets. Feeding results are accompanied by qPCR data of relevant genes in the energy balance-related hypothalamus and brain stem, and in the nucleus accumbens, which regulates eating for palatability. We found that GM and CM are palatable to juvenile, adult, and aged rodents. Given a choice, animals prefer GM- to CM-based diets. Analysis of meal microstructure using licking patterns points to enhanced palatability of and, possibly, greater motivation toward GM over CM. Most profound changes in gene expression after GM vs. CM were associated with the brain systems driving consumption for reward. We conclude that, while both GM and CM are palatable, GM is preferred over CM by laboratory animals, and this preference is driven by central mechanisms controlling eating for pleasure.
topic milk
hypothalamus
nucleus accumbens
reward
appetite
palatability
url https://www.mdpi.com/2072-6643/11/4/720
work_keys_str_mv AT anicaklockars palatabilityofgoatsversuscowsmilkinsightsfromtheanalysisofeatingbehaviorandgeneexpressionintheappetiterelevantbraincircuitinlaboratoryanimalmodels
AT erinlwood palatabilityofgoatsversuscowsmilkinsightsfromtheanalysisofeatingbehaviorandgeneexpressionintheappetiterelevantbraincircuitinlaboratoryanimalmodels
AT sarahngartner palatabilityofgoatsversuscowsmilkinsightsfromtheanalysisofeatingbehaviorandgeneexpressionintheappetiterelevantbraincircuitinlaboratoryanimalmodels
AT laurakmccoll palatabilityofgoatsversuscowsmilkinsightsfromtheanalysisofeatingbehaviorandgeneexpressionintheappetiterelevantbraincircuitinlaboratoryanimalmodels
AT allenslevine palatabilityofgoatsversuscowsmilkinsightsfromtheanalysisofeatingbehaviorandgeneexpressionintheappetiterelevantbraincircuitinlaboratoryanimalmodels
AT elizabethacarpenter palatabilityofgoatsversuscowsmilkinsightsfromtheanalysisofeatingbehaviorandgeneexpressionintheappetiterelevantbraincircuitinlaboratoryanimalmodels
AT colingprosser palatabilityofgoatsversuscowsmilkinsightsfromtheanalysisofeatingbehaviorandgeneexpressionintheappetiterelevantbraincircuitinlaboratoryanimalmodels
AT pawelkolszewski palatabilityofgoatsversuscowsmilkinsightsfromtheanalysisofeatingbehaviorandgeneexpressionintheappetiterelevantbraincircuitinlaboratoryanimalmodels
_version_ 1725337705207824384