What Lenneberg Got Right: A Homological Program for the Study of Language Evolution

By 1967, it was clear to Eric Lenneberg that reconstructing the phylogenetic history of language should require the adoption of a non-functional (or Owenian) homology concept for grounding relevant comparisons. Fifty years later, most biolinguistic approaches have betrayed this project, for they rou...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Sergio Balari, Guillermo Lorenzo
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Biolinguistics 2017-12-01
Series:Biolinguistics
Subjects:
Online Access:https://biolinguistics.eu/index.php/biolinguistics/article/view/498
id doaj-e6a1fd91b88d4410849ae180f5fdb8da
record_format Article
spelling doaj-e6a1fd91b88d4410849ae180f5fdb8da2020-11-24T22:06:50ZengBiolinguisticsBiolinguistics1450-34172017-12-0111SI139170252What Lenneberg Got Right: A Homological Program for the Study of Language EvolutionSergio BalariGuillermo LorenzoBy 1967, it was clear to Eric Lenneberg that reconstructing the phylogenetic history of language should require the adoption of a non-functional (or Owenian) homology concept for grounding relevant comparisons. Fifty years later, most biolinguistic approaches have betrayed this project, for they routinely derive their conclusions regarding the unique/shared status of language on merely folk grounds — as dramatically illustrated in Hauser, Chomsky & Fitch vs. Pinker & Jackendoff’s debate, or based on functional considerations — as in Chomsky’s recent conceptualization of language as a unique tool for thought. Here we claim that Lenneberg’s project needs to be resumed and we articulate some suggestions about how to conduct it, taking advantage of recent findings and new conceptual insights concerning two crucial levels of analysis actually pinpointed by him — namely, anatomical/molecular structure and physiological function.https://biolinguistics.eu/index.php/biolinguistics/article/view/498homology thinkingcharacter conceptevolutionary noveltiescomputational mind
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Sergio Balari
Guillermo Lorenzo
spellingShingle Sergio Balari
Guillermo Lorenzo
What Lenneberg Got Right: A Homological Program for the Study of Language Evolution
Biolinguistics
homology thinking
character concept
evolutionary novelties
computational mind
author_facet Sergio Balari
Guillermo Lorenzo
author_sort Sergio Balari
title What Lenneberg Got Right: A Homological Program for the Study of Language Evolution
title_short What Lenneberg Got Right: A Homological Program for the Study of Language Evolution
title_full What Lenneberg Got Right: A Homological Program for the Study of Language Evolution
title_fullStr What Lenneberg Got Right: A Homological Program for the Study of Language Evolution
title_full_unstemmed What Lenneberg Got Right: A Homological Program for the Study of Language Evolution
title_sort what lenneberg got right: a homological program for the study of language evolution
publisher Biolinguistics
series Biolinguistics
issn 1450-3417
publishDate 2017-12-01
description By 1967, it was clear to Eric Lenneberg that reconstructing the phylogenetic history of language should require the adoption of a non-functional (or Owenian) homology concept for grounding relevant comparisons. Fifty years later, most biolinguistic approaches have betrayed this project, for they routinely derive their conclusions regarding the unique/shared status of language on merely folk grounds — as dramatically illustrated in Hauser, Chomsky & Fitch vs. Pinker & Jackendoff’s debate, or based on functional considerations — as in Chomsky’s recent conceptualization of language as a unique tool for thought. Here we claim that Lenneberg’s project needs to be resumed and we articulate some suggestions about how to conduct it, taking advantage of recent findings and new conceptual insights concerning two crucial levels of analysis actually pinpointed by him — namely, anatomical/molecular structure and physiological function.
topic homology thinking
character concept
evolutionary novelties
computational mind
url https://biolinguistics.eu/index.php/biolinguistics/article/view/498
work_keys_str_mv AT sergiobalari whatlenneberggotrightahomologicalprogramforthestudyoflanguageevolution
AT guillermolorenzo whatlenneberggotrightahomologicalprogramforthestudyoflanguageevolution
_version_ 1725821578618339328