Characterization of Heterotopic Ossification Using Radiographic Imaging: Evidence for a Paradigm Shift.

Heterotopic ossification (HO) is the growth of extra-skeletal bone which occurs following trauma, burns, and in patients with genetic bone morphogenetic protein (BMP) receptor mutations. The clinical and laboratory evaluation of HO is dependent on radiographic imaging to identify and characterize th...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: R Cameron Brownley, Shailesh Agarwal, Shawn Loder, Oluwatobi Eboda, John Li, Joshua Peterson, Charles Hwang, Christopher Breuler, Vesa Kaartinen, Bin Zhou, Yuji Mishina, Benjamin Levi
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Public Library of Science (PLoS) 2015-01-01
Series:PLoS ONE
Online Access:http://europepmc.org/articles/PMC4636348?pdf=render
id doaj-e56090bf01734f22a634e276ac60b6a5
record_format Article
spelling doaj-e56090bf01734f22a634e276ac60b6a52020-11-25T00:23:25ZengPublic Library of Science (PLoS)PLoS ONE1932-62032015-01-011011e014143210.1371/journal.pone.0141432Characterization of Heterotopic Ossification Using Radiographic Imaging: Evidence for a Paradigm Shift.R Cameron BrownleyShailesh AgarwalShawn LoderOluwatobi EbodaJohn LiJoshua PetersonCharles HwangChristopher BreulerVesa KaartinenBin ZhouYuji MishinaBenjamin LeviHeterotopic ossification (HO) is the growth of extra-skeletal bone which occurs following trauma, burns, and in patients with genetic bone morphogenetic protein (BMP) receptor mutations. The clinical and laboratory evaluation of HO is dependent on radiographic imaging to identify and characterize these lesions. Here we show that despite its inadequacies, plain film radiography and single modality microCT continue to serve as a primary method of HO imaging in nearly 30% of published in vivo literature. Furthermore, we demonstrate that detailed microCT analysis is superior to plain film and single modality microCT radiography specifically in the evaluation of HO formed through three representative models due to its ability to 1) define structural relationships between growing extra-skeletal bone and normal, anatomic bone, 2) provide accurate quantification and growth rate based on volume of the space-occupying lesion, thereby facilitating assessments of therapeutic intervention, 3) identify HO at earlier times allowing for evaluation of early intervention, and 4) characterization of metrics of bone physiology including porosity, tissue mineral density, and cortical and trabecular volume. Examination of our trauma model using microCT demonstrated two separate areas of HO based on anatomic location and relationship with surrounding, normal bone structures. Additionally, microCT allows HO growth rate to be evaluated to characterize HO progression. Taken together, these data demonstrate the need for a paradigm shift in the evaluation of HO towards microCT as a standard tool for imaging.http://europepmc.org/articles/PMC4636348?pdf=render
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author R Cameron Brownley
Shailesh Agarwal
Shawn Loder
Oluwatobi Eboda
John Li
Joshua Peterson
Charles Hwang
Christopher Breuler
Vesa Kaartinen
Bin Zhou
Yuji Mishina
Benjamin Levi
spellingShingle R Cameron Brownley
Shailesh Agarwal
Shawn Loder
Oluwatobi Eboda
John Li
Joshua Peterson
Charles Hwang
Christopher Breuler
Vesa Kaartinen
Bin Zhou
Yuji Mishina
Benjamin Levi
Characterization of Heterotopic Ossification Using Radiographic Imaging: Evidence for a Paradigm Shift.
PLoS ONE
author_facet R Cameron Brownley
Shailesh Agarwal
Shawn Loder
Oluwatobi Eboda
John Li
Joshua Peterson
Charles Hwang
Christopher Breuler
Vesa Kaartinen
Bin Zhou
Yuji Mishina
Benjamin Levi
author_sort R Cameron Brownley
title Characterization of Heterotopic Ossification Using Radiographic Imaging: Evidence for a Paradigm Shift.
title_short Characterization of Heterotopic Ossification Using Radiographic Imaging: Evidence for a Paradigm Shift.
title_full Characterization of Heterotopic Ossification Using Radiographic Imaging: Evidence for a Paradigm Shift.
title_fullStr Characterization of Heterotopic Ossification Using Radiographic Imaging: Evidence for a Paradigm Shift.
title_full_unstemmed Characterization of Heterotopic Ossification Using Radiographic Imaging: Evidence for a Paradigm Shift.
title_sort characterization of heterotopic ossification using radiographic imaging: evidence for a paradigm shift.
publisher Public Library of Science (PLoS)
series PLoS ONE
issn 1932-6203
publishDate 2015-01-01
description Heterotopic ossification (HO) is the growth of extra-skeletal bone which occurs following trauma, burns, and in patients with genetic bone morphogenetic protein (BMP) receptor mutations. The clinical and laboratory evaluation of HO is dependent on radiographic imaging to identify and characterize these lesions. Here we show that despite its inadequacies, plain film radiography and single modality microCT continue to serve as a primary method of HO imaging in nearly 30% of published in vivo literature. Furthermore, we demonstrate that detailed microCT analysis is superior to plain film and single modality microCT radiography specifically in the evaluation of HO formed through three representative models due to its ability to 1) define structural relationships between growing extra-skeletal bone and normal, anatomic bone, 2) provide accurate quantification and growth rate based on volume of the space-occupying lesion, thereby facilitating assessments of therapeutic intervention, 3) identify HO at earlier times allowing for evaluation of early intervention, and 4) characterization of metrics of bone physiology including porosity, tissue mineral density, and cortical and trabecular volume. Examination of our trauma model using microCT demonstrated two separate areas of HO based on anatomic location and relationship with surrounding, normal bone structures. Additionally, microCT allows HO growth rate to be evaluated to characterize HO progression. Taken together, these data demonstrate the need for a paradigm shift in the evaluation of HO towards microCT as a standard tool for imaging.
url http://europepmc.org/articles/PMC4636348?pdf=render
work_keys_str_mv AT rcameronbrownley characterizationofheterotopicossificationusingradiographicimagingevidenceforaparadigmshift
AT shaileshagarwal characterizationofheterotopicossificationusingradiographicimagingevidenceforaparadigmshift
AT shawnloder characterizationofheterotopicossificationusingradiographicimagingevidenceforaparadigmshift
AT oluwatobieboda characterizationofheterotopicossificationusingradiographicimagingevidenceforaparadigmshift
AT johnli characterizationofheterotopicossificationusingradiographicimagingevidenceforaparadigmshift
AT joshuapeterson characterizationofheterotopicossificationusingradiographicimagingevidenceforaparadigmshift
AT charleshwang characterizationofheterotopicossificationusingradiographicimagingevidenceforaparadigmshift
AT christopherbreuler characterizationofheterotopicossificationusingradiographicimagingevidenceforaparadigmshift
AT vesakaartinen characterizationofheterotopicossificationusingradiographicimagingevidenceforaparadigmshift
AT binzhou characterizationofheterotopicossificationusingradiographicimagingevidenceforaparadigmshift
AT yujimishina characterizationofheterotopicossificationusingradiographicimagingevidenceforaparadigmshift
AT benjaminlevi characterizationofheterotopicossificationusingradiographicimagingevidenceforaparadigmshift
_version_ 1725357209016074240