Identifying barriers to patient acceptance of active surveillance: content analysis of online patient communications.

Qualitative research aimed at identifying patient acceptance of active surveillance (AS) has been identified as a public health research priority. The primary objective of this study was to determine if analysis of a large-sample of anonymous internet conversations (ICs) could be utilized to identif...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Mark V Mishra, Michele Bennett, Armon Vincent, Olivia T Lee, Costas D Lallas, Edouard J Trabulsi, Leonard G Gomella, Adam P Dicker, Timothy N Showalter
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Public Library of Science (PLoS) 2013-01-01
Series:PLoS ONE
Online Access:http://europepmc.org/articles/PMC3770634?pdf=render
id doaj-e55631ed42984208a46b75d3a913e116
record_format Article
spelling doaj-e55631ed42984208a46b75d3a913e1162020-11-25T02:06:25ZengPublic Library of Science (PLoS)PLoS ONE1932-62032013-01-0189e6856310.1371/journal.pone.0068563Identifying barriers to patient acceptance of active surveillance: content analysis of online patient communications.Mark V MishraMichele BennettArmon VincentOlivia T LeeCostas D LallasEdouard J TrabulsiLeonard G GomellaAdam P DickerTimothy N ShowalterQualitative research aimed at identifying patient acceptance of active surveillance (AS) has been identified as a public health research priority. The primary objective of this study was to determine if analysis of a large-sample of anonymous internet conversations (ICs) could be utilized to identify unmet public needs regarding AS.English-language ICs regarding prostate cancer (PC) treatment with AS from 2002-12 were identified using a novel internet search methodology. Web spiders were developed to mine, aggregate, and analyze content from the world-wide-web for ICs centered on AS. Collection of ICs was not restricted to any specific geographic region of origin. NLP was used to evaluate content and perform a sentiment analysis. Conversations were scored as positive, negative, or neutral. A sentiment index (SI) was subsequently calculated according to the following formula to compare temporal trends in public sentiment towards AS: [(# Positive IC/#Total IC)-(#Negative IC/#Total IC) x 100].A total of 464 ICs were identified. Sentiment increased from -13 to +2 over the study period. The increase sentiment has been driven by increased patient emphasis on quality-of-life factors and endorsement of AS by national medical organizations. Unmet needs identified in these ICs include: a gap between quantitative data regarding long-term outcomes with AS vs. conventional treatments, desire for treatment information from an unbiased specialist, and absence of public role models managed with AS.This study demonstrates the potential utility of online patient communications to provide insight into patient preferences and decision-making. Based on our findings, we recommend that multidisciplinary clinics consider including an unbiased specialist to present treatment options and that future decision tools for AS include quantitative data regarding outcomes after AS.http://europepmc.org/articles/PMC3770634?pdf=render
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Mark V Mishra
Michele Bennett
Armon Vincent
Olivia T Lee
Costas D Lallas
Edouard J Trabulsi
Leonard G Gomella
Adam P Dicker
Timothy N Showalter
spellingShingle Mark V Mishra
Michele Bennett
Armon Vincent
Olivia T Lee
Costas D Lallas
Edouard J Trabulsi
Leonard G Gomella
Adam P Dicker
Timothy N Showalter
Identifying barriers to patient acceptance of active surveillance: content analysis of online patient communications.
PLoS ONE
author_facet Mark V Mishra
Michele Bennett
Armon Vincent
Olivia T Lee
Costas D Lallas
Edouard J Trabulsi
Leonard G Gomella
Adam P Dicker
Timothy N Showalter
author_sort Mark V Mishra
title Identifying barriers to patient acceptance of active surveillance: content analysis of online patient communications.
title_short Identifying barriers to patient acceptance of active surveillance: content analysis of online patient communications.
title_full Identifying barriers to patient acceptance of active surveillance: content analysis of online patient communications.
title_fullStr Identifying barriers to patient acceptance of active surveillance: content analysis of online patient communications.
title_full_unstemmed Identifying barriers to patient acceptance of active surveillance: content analysis of online patient communications.
title_sort identifying barriers to patient acceptance of active surveillance: content analysis of online patient communications.
publisher Public Library of Science (PLoS)
series PLoS ONE
issn 1932-6203
publishDate 2013-01-01
description Qualitative research aimed at identifying patient acceptance of active surveillance (AS) has been identified as a public health research priority. The primary objective of this study was to determine if analysis of a large-sample of anonymous internet conversations (ICs) could be utilized to identify unmet public needs regarding AS.English-language ICs regarding prostate cancer (PC) treatment with AS from 2002-12 were identified using a novel internet search methodology. Web spiders were developed to mine, aggregate, and analyze content from the world-wide-web for ICs centered on AS. Collection of ICs was not restricted to any specific geographic region of origin. NLP was used to evaluate content and perform a sentiment analysis. Conversations were scored as positive, negative, or neutral. A sentiment index (SI) was subsequently calculated according to the following formula to compare temporal trends in public sentiment towards AS: [(# Positive IC/#Total IC)-(#Negative IC/#Total IC) x 100].A total of 464 ICs were identified. Sentiment increased from -13 to +2 over the study period. The increase sentiment has been driven by increased patient emphasis on quality-of-life factors and endorsement of AS by national medical organizations. Unmet needs identified in these ICs include: a gap between quantitative data regarding long-term outcomes with AS vs. conventional treatments, desire for treatment information from an unbiased specialist, and absence of public role models managed with AS.This study demonstrates the potential utility of online patient communications to provide insight into patient preferences and decision-making. Based on our findings, we recommend that multidisciplinary clinics consider including an unbiased specialist to present treatment options and that future decision tools for AS include quantitative data regarding outcomes after AS.
url http://europepmc.org/articles/PMC3770634?pdf=render
work_keys_str_mv AT markvmishra identifyingbarrierstopatientacceptanceofactivesurveillancecontentanalysisofonlinepatientcommunications
AT michelebennett identifyingbarrierstopatientacceptanceofactivesurveillancecontentanalysisofonlinepatientcommunications
AT armonvincent identifyingbarrierstopatientacceptanceofactivesurveillancecontentanalysisofonlinepatientcommunications
AT oliviatlee identifyingbarrierstopatientacceptanceofactivesurveillancecontentanalysisofonlinepatientcommunications
AT costasdlallas identifyingbarrierstopatientacceptanceofactivesurveillancecontentanalysisofonlinepatientcommunications
AT edouardjtrabulsi identifyingbarrierstopatientacceptanceofactivesurveillancecontentanalysisofonlinepatientcommunications
AT leonardggomella identifyingbarrierstopatientacceptanceofactivesurveillancecontentanalysisofonlinepatientcommunications
AT adampdicker identifyingbarrierstopatientacceptanceofactivesurveillancecontentanalysisofonlinepatientcommunications
AT timothynshowalter identifyingbarrierstopatientacceptanceofactivesurveillancecontentanalysisofonlinepatientcommunications
_version_ 1724934020513398784