Factors affecting the results of analgesic therapy. Results of the Russian multicentre study of NOTE (NSAID: Open-label Trial of Efficacy)

Non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) are most popular medications for the treatment of pain in common musculoskeletal diseases such as osteoarthritis (OA) and non-specific low back pain (LBP). However, the factors affecting the effectiveness of these drugs have not been determined fully. A...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: A E Karateev, E Yu Pogozheva, E A Filatova, V N Amirjanova, A M Lila, O V Antipova, A R Babaeva, A V Volkorezova, A F Davydova, V G Davtyan, E V Zonova, O N Ivanova, N N Kalinina, N I Kiseleva, L A Knyazeva, A I Kulikov, O B Nesmeyanova, V I Mazurov, L V Masneva, L V Menshikova, I V Obuhova, E N Otteva, T S Salnikova, I N Shchendrygin, S P Yakupova
Format: Article
Language:Russian
Published: "Consilium Medicum" Publishing house 2018-06-01
Series:Терапевтический архив
Subjects:
Online Access:https://ter-arkhiv.ru/0040-3660/article/viewFile/32781/pdf
id doaj-e4a273b8b13b4eb68d62beba2d567eb5
record_format Article
collection DOAJ
language Russian
format Article
sources DOAJ
author A E Karateev
E Yu Pogozheva
E A Filatova
V N Amirjanova
A M Lila
O V Antipova
A R Babaeva
A V Volkorezova
A F Davydova
V G Davtyan
E V Zonova
O N Ivanova
N N Kalinina
N I Kiseleva
L A Knyazeva
A I Kulikov
O B Nesmeyanova
V I Mazurov
L V Masneva
L V Menshikova
I V Obuhova
E N Otteva
T S Salnikova
I N Shchendrygin
S P Yakupova
spellingShingle A E Karateev
E Yu Pogozheva
E A Filatova
V N Amirjanova
A M Lila
O V Antipova
A R Babaeva
A V Volkorezova
A F Davydova
V G Davtyan
E V Zonova
O N Ivanova
N N Kalinina
N I Kiseleva
L A Knyazeva
A I Kulikov
O B Nesmeyanova
V I Mazurov
L V Masneva
L V Menshikova
I V Obuhova
E N Otteva
T S Salnikova
I N Shchendrygin
S P Yakupova
Factors affecting the results of analgesic therapy. Results of the Russian multicentre study of NOTE (NSAID: Open-label Trial of Efficacy)
Терапевтический архив
non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs
efficacy
osteoarthritis
non-specific low back pain
aceclofenac
airtal
author_facet A E Karateev
E Yu Pogozheva
E A Filatova
V N Amirjanova
A M Lila
O V Antipova
A R Babaeva
A V Volkorezova
A F Davydova
V G Davtyan
E V Zonova
O N Ivanova
N N Kalinina
N I Kiseleva
L A Knyazeva
A I Kulikov
O B Nesmeyanova
V I Mazurov
L V Masneva
L V Menshikova
I V Obuhova
E N Otteva
T S Salnikova
I N Shchendrygin
S P Yakupova
author_sort A E Karateev
title Factors affecting the results of analgesic therapy. Results of the Russian multicentre study of NOTE (NSAID: Open-label Trial of Efficacy)
title_short Factors affecting the results of analgesic therapy. Results of the Russian multicentre study of NOTE (NSAID: Open-label Trial of Efficacy)
title_full Factors affecting the results of analgesic therapy. Results of the Russian multicentre study of NOTE (NSAID: Open-label Trial of Efficacy)
title_fullStr Factors affecting the results of analgesic therapy. Results of the Russian multicentre study of NOTE (NSAID: Open-label Trial of Efficacy)
title_full_unstemmed Factors affecting the results of analgesic therapy. Results of the Russian multicentre study of NOTE (NSAID: Open-label Trial of Efficacy)
title_sort factors affecting the results of analgesic therapy. results of the russian multicentre study of note (nsaid: open-label trial of efficacy)
publisher "Consilium Medicum" Publishing house
series Терапевтический архив
issn 0040-3660
2309-5342
publishDate 2018-06-01
description Non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) are most popular medications for the treatment of pain in common musculoskeletal diseases such as osteoarthritis (OA) and non-specific low back pain (LBP). However, the factors affecting the effectiveness of these drugs have not been determined fully. Aim: to identify factors affecting the effectiveness of NSAIDs in patients with OA and LBP. Materials and methods. An observational study was conducted to evaluate the effectiveness of a 2-week course of NSAIDs in OA and LBP in real clinical practice. The study group consisted of 3604 patients with OA and LBP (60.6% women and 39.4% men, mean age 55.0±13.4 years). According to the study design, aceclofenac (Airtal) and other NSAIDs used in the ratio 1:1. The main criterion of effectiveness was the frequency of complete pain relief after 2 weeks of therapy. In addition, the decrease of pain and general health were determined on a 10-point numerical rating scale (NRS). We compared the frequency of complete pain relief in patients who had and did not have the studied factors. The value of the studied factors was determined using OR (95% CI). Results and discussion. Most patients received aceclofenac (54.9%), as well as diclofenac (2.0%), ketoprofen (1.9%), lornoxicam (2.2%), meloxicam (13.7%), naproxen (2.1%), nimesulide (5.8%), celecoxib (5.9%), ethicoxib (7.1%) and other NSAIDs (4.4%); 56.2% of patients received muscle relaxants, mainly tolperisone (74.7%), vitamin B (10.4%), and proton pump inhibitors (42.8%). Complete pain relief was achieved in 54.8% of patients. The pain decrease and general health improvement were (for NRS) 63.9±13.4% and 61.7±14.8%, respectively. The efficacy of aceclofenac was slightly higher than in the whole group: complete pain relief was in 59.9% of patients. Adverse events in aceclofenac use were observed in 2.3% of patients, other NSAIDs-from 2.4 to 14.1%. The frequency of complete pain relief was higher in men: OR 1,239 (95% CI 1.08-1.418; p=0.002), who had the first episode of pain - OR 3.341 (95% CI 2.873-3.875; p=0.000), a good" response " to NSAIDs in history - OR 1.656 (95% CI 1.385-1.980; p=0.000) and received NSAIDs in combination with muscle relaxants - OR 1.218 (95% CI 1.067-1.390; p=0.004). The effect of therapy is lower in patients 65 years and older-OR 0,378 (95% CI 0.324-0.442; p=0,000), with body mass index >30 kg/m² - OR 0.619 (95% CI 0.529-0.723; p=0.000), with severe pain (≥7 points NRS) - OR 0.662 (95% CI 0.580-0.756; p=0.002), with pain at rest, - OR 0.515 (95% CI 0.450-0,589; p=0.000), pain at night - OR 0.581 (95% CI 0.501-0.672; p=0.000) and the presence of stiffness - OR 0.501 (95% CI 0.438-0,573; p=0.000). Treatment results are significantly worse in the cases of combination of LBP and joint pain, as well as pain in the trochanter major and pes anserinus area (p
topic non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs
efficacy
osteoarthritis
non-specific low back pain
aceclofenac
airtal
url https://ter-arkhiv.ru/0040-3660/article/viewFile/32781/pdf
work_keys_str_mv AT aekarateev factorsaffectingtheresultsofanalgesictherapyresultsoftherussianmulticentrestudyofnotensaidopenlabeltrialofefficacy
AT eyupogozheva factorsaffectingtheresultsofanalgesictherapyresultsoftherussianmulticentrestudyofnotensaidopenlabeltrialofefficacy
AT eafilatova factorsaffectingtheresultsofanalgesictherapyresultsoftherussianmulticentrestudyofnotensaidopenlabeltrialofefficacy
AT vnamirjanova factorsaffectingtheresultsofanalgesictherapyresultsoftherussianmulticentrestudyofnotensaidopenlabeltrialofefficacy
AT amlila factorsaffectingtheresultsofanalgesictherapyresultsoftherussianmulticentrestudyofnotensaidopenlabeltrialofefficacy
AT ovantipova factorsaffectingtheresultsofanalgesictherapyresultsoftherussianmulticentrestudyofnotensaidopenlabeltrialofefficacy
AT arbabaeva factorsaffectingtheresultsofanalgesictherapyresultsoftherussianmulticentrestudyofnotensaidopenlabeltrialofefficacy
AT avvolkorezova factorsaffectingtheresultsofanalgesictherapyresultsoftherussianmulticentrestudyofnotensaidopenlabeltrialofefficacy
AT afdavydova factorsaffectingtheresultsofanalgesictherapyresultsoftherussianmulticentrestudyofnotensaidopenlabeltrialofefficacy
AT vgdavtyan factorsaffectingtheresultsofanalgesictherapyresultsoftherussianmulticentrestudyofnotensaidopenlabeltrialofefficacy
AT evzonova factorsaffectingtheresultsofanalgesictherapyresultsoftherussianmulticentrestudyofnotensaidopenlabeltrialofefficacy
AT onivanova factorsaffectingtheresultsofanalgesictherapyresultsoftherussianmulticentrestudyofnotensaidopenlabeltrialofefficacy
AT nnkalinina factorsaffectingtheresultsofanalgesictherapyresultsoftherussianmulticentrestudyofnotensaidopenlabeltrialofefficacy
AT nikiseleva factorsaffectingtheresultsofanalgesictherapyresultsoftherussianmulticentrestudyofnotensaidopenlabeltrialofefficacy
AT laknyazeva factorsaffectingtheresultsofanalgesictherapyresultsoftherussianmulticentrestudyofnotensaidopenlabeltrialofefficacy
AT aikulikov factorsaffectingtheresultsofanalgesictherapyresultsoftherussianmulticentrestudyofnotensaidopenlabeltrialofefficacy
AT obnesmeyanova factorsaffectingtheresultsofanalgesictherapyresultsoftherussianmulticentrestudyofnotensaidopenlabeltrialofefficacy
AT vimazurov factorsaffectingtheresultsofanalgesictherapyresultsoftherussianmulticentrestudyofnotensaidopenlabeltrialofefficacy
AT lvmasneva factorsaffectingtheresultsofanalgesictherapyresultsoftherussianmulticentrestudyofnotensaidopenlabeltrialofefficacy
AT lvmenshikova factorsaffectingtheresultsofanalgesictherapyresultsoftherussianmulticentrestudyofnotensaidopenlabeltrialofefficacy
AT ivobuhova factorsaffectingtheresultsofanalgesictherapyresultsoftherussianmulticentrestudyofnotensaidopenlabeltrialofefficacy
AT enotteva factorsaffectingtheresultsofanalgesictherapyresultsoftherussianmulticentrestudyofnotensaidopenlabeltrialofefficacy
AT tssalnikova factorsaffectingtheresultsofanalgesictherapyresultsoftherussianmulticentrestudyofnotensaidopenlabeltrialofefficacy
AT inshchendrygin factorsaffectingtheresultsofanalgesictherapyresultsoftherussianmulticentrestudyofnotensaidopenlabeltrialofefficacy
AT spyakupova factorsaffectingtheresultsofanalgesictherapyresultsoftherussianmulticentrestudyofnotensaidopenlabeltrialofefficacy
_version_ 1724678882341158912
spelling doaj-e4a273b8b13b4eb68d62beba2d567eb52020-11-25T03:05:23Zrus"Consilium Medicum" Publishing houseТерапевтический архив0040-36602309-53422018-06-01906657310.26442/terarkh201890665-7329533Factors affecting the results of analgesic therapy. Results of the Russian multicentre study of NOTE (NSAID: Open-label Trial of Efficacy)A E Karateev0E Yu Pogozheva1E A Filatova2V N Amirjanova3A M Lila4O V Antipova5A R Babaeva6A V Volkorezova7A F Davydova8V G Davtyan9E V Zonova10O N Ivanova11N N Kalinina12N I Kiseleva13L A Knyazeva14A I Kulikov15O B Nesmeyanova16V I Mazurov17L V Masneva18L V Menshikova19I V Obuhova20E N Otteva21T S Salnikova22I N Shchendrygin23S P Yakupova24V.A. Nasonova Research Institute of RheumatologyV.A. Nasonova Research Institute of RheumatologyV.A. Nasonova Research Institute of RheumatologyV.A. Nasonova Research Institute of RheumatologyV.A. Nasonova Research Institute of RheumatologyAutonomous Healthcare Institution "Irkutsk Clinical Hospital №1"Volgograd State Medical UniversityOrel Regional Clinical HospitalS.V.Ochapovskiy Regional Clinical Hospital №1, Ministry of Health of Krasnodar RegionClinic of medical expertise, LLCNovosibirsk State Medical UniversityVoronezh Regional Clinical Hospital №1Budgetary State Institution "Regional Hospital"Murmansk Regional Clinical Hospital named after P.A. BayandinKursk State Medical UniversityRostov Regional Clinical Hospital №2Chelyabinsk Regional Clinical HospitalNorth-Western State Medical University named after I.I. MechnikovBelgorod Regional Clinical HospitalIrkutsk State Medical Academy for Postgraduate EducationArkhangelsk Regional Clinical HospitalProfessor S.I. Sergeev Regional Clinical Hospital №1Tula Regional Clinical HospitalThe State Budget Health Care Institution of Stavropol Territory «Stavropol Regional Clinical Center of Specialized Types of Medical Care»Kazan State Medical UniversityNon-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) are most popular medications for the treatment of pain in common musculoskeletal diseases such as osteoarthritis (OA) and non-specific low back pain (LBP). However, the factors affecting the effectiveness of these drugs have not been determined fully. Aim: to identify factors affecting the effectiveness of NSAIDs in patients with OA and LBP. Materials and methods. An observational study was conducted to evaluate the effectiveness of a 2-week course of NSAIDs in OA and LBP in real clinical practice. The study group consisted of 3604 patients with OA and LBP (60.6% women and 39.4% men, mean age 55.0±13.4 years). According to the study design, aceclofenac (Airtal) and other NSAIDs used in the ratio 1:1. The main criterion of effectiveness was the frequency of complete pain relief after 2 weeks of therapy. In addition, the decrease of pain and general health were determined on a 10-point numerical rating scale (NRS). We compared the frequency of complete pain relief in patients who had and did not have the studied factors. The value of the studied factors was determined using OR (95% CI). Results and discussion. Most patients received aceclofenac (54.9%), as well as diclofenac (2.0%), ketoprofen (1.9%), lornoxicam (2.2%), meloxicam (13.7%), naproxen (2.1%), nimesulide (5.8%), celecoxib (5.9%), ethicoxib (7.1%) and other NSAIDs (4.4%); 56.2% of patients received muscle relaxants, mainly tolperisone (74.7%), vitamin B (10.4%), and proton pump inhibitors (42.8%). Complete pain relief was achieved in 54.8% of patients. The pain decrease and general health improvement were (for NRS) 63.9±13.4% and 61.7±14.8%, respectively. The efficacy of aceclofenac was slightly higher than in the whole group: complete pain relief was in 59.9% of patients. Adverse events in aceclofenac use were observed in 2.3% of patients, other NSAIDs-from 2.4 to 14.1%. The frequency of complete pain relief was higher in men: OR 1,239 (95% CI 1.08-1.418; p=0.002), who had the first episode of pain - OR 3.341 (95% CI 2.873-3.875; p=0.000), a good" response " to NSAIDs in history - OR 1.656 (95% CI 1.385-1.980; p=0.000) and received NSAIDs in combination with muscle relaxants - OR 1.218 (95% CI 1.067-1.390; p=0.004). The effect of therapy is lower in patients 65 years and older-OR 0,378 (95% CI 0.324-0.442; p=0,000), with body mass index >30 kg/m² - OR 0.619 (95% CI 0.529-0.723; p=0.000), with severe pain (≥7 points NRS) - OR 0.662 (95% CI 0.580-0.756; p=0.002), with pain at rest, - OR 0.515 (95% CI 0.450-0,589; p=0.000), pain at night - OR 0.581 (95% CI 0.501-0.672; p=0.000) and the presence of stiffness - OR 0.501 (95% CI 0.438-0,573; p=0.000). Treatment results are significantly worse in the cases of combination of LBP and joint pain, as well as pain in the trochanter major and pes anserinus area (phttps://ter-arkhiv.ru/0040-3660/article/viewFile/32781/pdfnon-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugsefficacyosteoarthritisnon-specific low back painaceclofenacairtal