Communication speeds up but impairs the consensus decision in a dyadic colour estimation task

• Main Authors: Liutao Yu, Chundi Wang, Si Wu, Da-Hui Wang
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Published: The Royal Society 2020-07-01
• Series: Royal Society Open Science
• Subjects: consensus decision-making; dyadic colour estimation; dynamic communication
• Online Access: https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/pdf/10.1098/rsos.191974

Communication plays an important role in consensus decision-making which pervades our daily life. However, the exact role of communication in consensus formation is not clear. Here, to study the effects of communication on consensus formation, we designed a dyadic colour estimation task, where a pair of isolated participants repeatedly estimated the colours of discs until they reached a consensus or completed eight estimations, either with or without communication. We show that participants’ estimates gradually approach each other, reaching towards a consensus, and these are enhanced with communication. We also show that dyadic consensus estimation is on average better than individual estimation. Surprisingly, consensus estimation without communication generally outperforms that with communication, indicating that communication impairs the improvement of consensus estimation. However, without communication, it takes longer to reach a consensus. Moreover, participants who partially cooperate with each other tend to result in better overall consensus. Taken together, we have identified the effect of communication on the dynamics of consensus formation, and the results may have implications on group decision-making in general.