Analysis of Uncertainty and Repeatability of a Low-Cost 3D Laser Scanner

• Main Authors: Ángel M. Felicísimo, María-Eugenia Polo
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Published: MDPI AG 2012-07-01
• Series: Sensors
• Subjects: laser scanning; low-cost scanner; uncertainty; repeatability; NextEngine
• Online Access: http://www.mdpi.com/1424-8220/12/7/9046

Portable 3D laser scanners are a valuable tool for compiling elaborate digital collections of archaeological objects and analysing the shapes and dimensions of pieces. Although low-cost desktop 3D laser scanners have powerful capacities, it is important to know their limitations. This paper performs an analysis of the uncertainty and repeatability of the NextEngine<sup>TM</sup> portable low-cost 3D laser scanner by scanning an object 20 times in two different resolution modes—Macro and Wide. Some dimensions of the object were measured using a digital calliper, and these results were used as the “true” or control data. In comparing the true and the scanned data, we verified that the mean uncertainty in the Macro Mode is approximately half that of the Wide Mode, at ±0.81 mm and ±1.66 mm, respectively. These experimental results are significantly higher than the accuracy specifications provided by the manufacturer. An analysis of repeatability shows that the successive replicates do not match in the same position. The results are better in Macro Mode than in Wide Mode; it is observed that the repeatability factor is slightly larger than the corresponding mode accuracy, with ±0.84 <em>vs.</em> ±0.81 mm in Macro Mode and ±1.82 <em>vs.</em> ±1.66 mm in Wide Mode. We suggest several improvements, such as adding an external reference scale or providing a calibrated object to allow for a self-calibration operation of the scanner.