A Practicable Measurement Strategy for Compliance Checking Number Concentrations of Airborne Nano- and Microscale Fibers

Despite compelling reports on asbestos-like pathogenicity, regulatory bodies have been hesitant to implement fiber number-based exposure limits for biodurable nanoscale fibers. One reason has been the lack of a practicable strategy for assessing airborne fiber number concentrations. Here, a method i...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Asmus Meyer-Plath, Daphne Bäger, Nico Dziurowitz, Doris Perseke, Barbara Katrin Simonow, Carmen Thim, Daniela Wenzlaff, Sabine Plitzko
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: MDPI AG 2020-11-01
Series:Atmosphere
Subjects:
Online Access:https://www.mdpi.com/2073-4433/11/11/1254
id doaj-df1da2ec916a4143bc1c7c4a56a57f68
record_format Article
spelling doaj-df1da2ec916a4143bc1c7c4a56a57f682020-11-25T04:01:02ZengMDPI AGAtmosphere2073-44332020-11-01111254125410.3390/atmos11111254A Practicable Measurement Strategy for Compliance Checking Number Concentrations of Airborne Nano- and Microscale FibersAsmus Meyer-Plath0Daphne Bäger1Nico Dziurowitz2Doris Perseke3Barbara Katrin Simonow4Carmen Thim5Daniela Wenzlaff6Sabine Plitzko7Bundesanstalt für Arbeitsschutz und Arbeitsmedizin (BAuA), Nöldnerstr. 40-42, 10317 Berlin, GermanyBundesanstalt für Arbeitsschutz und Arbeitsmedizin (BAuA), Nöldnerstr. 40-42, 10317 Berlin, GermanyBundesanstalt für Arbeitsschutz und Arbeitsmedizin (BAuA), Nöldnerstr. 40-42, 10317 Berlin, GermanyBundesanstalt für Arbeitsschutz und Arbeitsmedizin (BAuA), Nöldnerstr. 40-42, 10317 Berlin, GermanyBundesanstalt für Arbeitsschutz und Arbeitsmedizin (BAuA), Nöldnerstr. 40-42, 10317 Berlin, GermanyBundesanstalt für Arbeitsschutz und Arbeitsmedizin (BAuA), Nöldnerstr. 40-42, 10317 Berlin, GermanyBundesanstalt für Arbeitsschutz und Arbeitsmedizin (BAuA), Nöldnerstr. 40-42, 10317 Berlin, GermanyBundesanstalt für Arbeitsschutz und Arbeitsmedizin (BAuA), Nöldnerstr. 40-42, 10317 Berlin, GermanyDespite compelling reports on asbestos-like pathogenicity, regulatory bodies have been hesitant to implement fiber number-based exposure limits for biodurable nanoscale fibers. One reason has been the lack of a practicable strategy for assessing airborne fiber number concentrations. Here, a method is proposed, detailed and tested for compliance checking concentrations of airborne nano- and microscale fibers. It relies on Poisson statistical significance testing of the observed versus a predicted number of fibers on filters that have sampled a known volume of aerosol. The prediction is based on the exposure concentration to test. Analogous to the established counting rules for WHO-fibers, which use a phase contrast microscopy-related visibility criterion of , the new method also introduces a cut-off diameter, now at , which is motivated by toxicological findings on multi-walled carbon nanotubes. This cut-off already reduces the workload by a factor of compared to that necessary for imaging, detecting and counting nanofibers down to in diameter. Together with waiving any attempt to absolutely quantify fiber concentrations, a compliance check at the limit-of-detection results in an analytical workload that renders our new approach practicable. The proposed method was applied to compliance checking in 14 very different workplaces that handled or machined nanofiber-containing materials. It achieved detecting violations of the German benchmark exposure level of nanofibers per cubic meter.https://www.mdpi.com/2073-4433/11/11/1254nanofiberaerosolworkplace exposure assessmentfiber number concentration limitoccupational health and safety
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Asmus Meyer-Plath
Daphne Bäger
Nico Dziurowitz
Doris Perseke
Barbara Katrin Simonow
Carmen Thim
Daniela Wenzlaff
Sabine Plitzko
spellingShingle Asmus Meyer-Plath
Daphne Bäger
Nico Dziurowitz
Doris Perseke
Barbara Katrin Simonow
Carmen Thim
Daniela Wenzlaff
Sabine Plitzko
A Practicable Measurement Strategy for Compliance Checking Number Concentrations of Airborne Nano- and Microscale Fibers
Atmosphere
nanofiber
aerosol
workplace exposure assessment
fiber number concentration limit
occupational health and safety
author_facet Asmus Meyer-Plath
Daphne Bäger
Nico Dziurowitz
Doris Perseke
Barbara Katrin Simonow
Carmen Thim
Daniela Wenzlaff
Sabine Plitzko
author_sort Asmus Meyer-Plath
title A Practicable Measurement Strategy for Compliance Checking Number Concentrations of Airborne Nano- and Microscale Fibers
title_short A Practicable Measurement Strategy for Compliance Checking Number Concentrations of Airborne Nano- and Microscale Fibers
title_full A Practicable Measurement Strategy for Compliance Checking Number Concentrations of Airborne Nano- and Microscale Fibers
title_fullStr A Practicable Measurement Strategy for Compliance Checking Number Concentrations of Airborne Nano- and Microscale Fibers
title_full_unstemmed A Practicable Measurement Strategy for Compliance Checking Number Concentrations of Airborne Nano- and Microscale Fibers
title_sort practicable measurement strategy for compliance checking number concentrations of airborne nano- and microscale fibers
publisher MDPI AG
series Atmosphere
issn 2073-4433
publishDate 2020-11-01
description Despite compelling reports on asbestos-like pathogenicity, regulatory bodies have been hesitant to implement fiber number-based exposure limits for biodurable nanoscale fibers. One reason has been the lack of a practicable strategy for assessing airborne fiber number concentrations. Here, a method is proposed, detailed and tested for compliance checking concentrations of airborne nano- and microscale fibers. It relies on Poisson statistical significance testing of the observed versus a predicted number of fibers on filters that have sampled a known volume of aerosol. The prediction is based on the exposure concentration to test. Analogous to the established counting rules for WHO-fibers, which use a phase contrast microscopy-related visibility criterion of , the new method also introduces a cut-off diameter, now at , which is motivated by toxicological findings on multi-walled carbon nanotubes. This cut-off already reduces the workload by a factor of compared to that necessary for imaging, detecting and counting nanofibers down to in diameter. Together with waiving any attempt to absolutely quantify fiber concentrations, a compliance check at the limit-of-detection results in an analytical workload that renders our new approach practicable. The proposed method was applied to compliance checking in 14 very different workplaces that handled or machined nanofiber-containing materials. It achieved detecting violations of the German benchmark exposure level of nanofibers per cubic meter.
topic nanofiber
aerosol
workplace exposure assessment
fiber number concentration limit
occupational health and safety
url https://www.mdpi.com/2073-4433/11/11/1254
work_keys_str_mv AT asmusmeyerplath apracticablemeasurementstrategyforcompliancecheckingnumberconcentrationsofairbornenanoandmicroscalefibers
AT daphnebager apracticablemeasurementstrategyforcompliancecheckingnumberconcentrationsofairbornenanoandmicroscalefibers
AT nicodziurowitz apracticablemeasurementstrategyforcompliancecheckingnumberconcentrationsofairbornenanoandmicroscalefibers
AT dorisperseke apracticablemeasurementstrategyforcompliancecheckingnumberconcentrationsofairbornenanoandmicroscalefibers
AT barbarakatrinsimonow apracticablemeasurementstrategyforcompliancecheckingnumberconcentrationsofairbornenanoandmicroscalefibers
AT carmenthim apracticablemeasurementstrategyforcompliancecheckingnumberconcentrationsofairbornenanoandmicroscalefibers
AT danielawenzlaff apracticablemeasurementstrategyforcompliancecheckingnumberconcentrationsofairbornenanoandmicroscalefibers
AT sabineplitzko apracticablemeasurementstrategyforcompliancecheckingnumberconcentrationsofairbornenanoandmicroscalefibers
AT asmusmeyerplath practicablemeasurementstrategyforcompliancecheckingnumberconcentrationsofairbornenanoandmicroscalefibers
AT daphnebager practicablemeasurementstrategyforcompliancecheckingnumberconcentrationsofairbornenanoandmicroscalefibers
AT nicodziurowitz practicablemeasurementstrategyforcompliancecheckingnumberconcentrationsofairbornenanoandmicroscalefibers
AT dorisperseke practicablemeasurementstrategyforcompliancecheckingnumberconcentrationsofairbornenanoandmicroscalefibers
AT barbarakatrinsimonow practicablemeasurementstrategyforcompliancecheckingnumberconcentrationsofairbornenanoandmicroscalefibers
AT carmenthim practicablemeasurementstrategyforcompliancecheckingnumberconcentrationsofairbornenanoandmicroscalefibers
AT danielawenzlaff practicablemeasurementstrategyforcompliancecheckingnumberconcentrationsofairbornenanoandmicroscalefibers
AT sabineplitzko practicablemeasurementstrategyforcompliancecheckingnumberconcentrationsofairbornenanoandmicroscalefibers
_version_ 1724447966903664640