Comment on “Electromagnetic wave propagation in a superconducting parallel-plate waveguide filled with an indefinite medium” by Burhan Zamir, Rashid Ali, and Muzaffar Bashir [Results Phys, 13 2019, 102312]

We examine the calculations of ks2 of both transverse electric and transverse magnetic wave modes proposed by the paper “Electromagnetic wave propagation in a superconducting parallel-plate waveguide filled with an indefinite medium” by Burhan Zamir, Rashid Ali, and Muzaffar Bashir [Results Phys, 13...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors:	Le Phuong Hoang, Xuan Binh Cao
Format:	Article
Language:	English
Published:	Elsevier 2021-03-01
Series:	Results in Physics
Subjects:	Anisotropic indefinite medium Transverse electric waves Meissner boundary conditions
Online Access:	http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2211379721000796

id	doaj-dbfa06610e3d4593aaf9a17e798c2666
record_format	Article
spelling	doaj-dbfa06610e3d4593aaf9a17e798c26662021-03-07T04:29:08ZengElsevierResults in Physics2211-37972021-03-0122103900Comment on “Electromagnetic wave propagation in a superconducting parallel-plate waveguide filled with an indefinite medium” by Burhan Zamir, Rashid Ali, and Muzaffar Bashir [Results Phys, 13 2019, 102312]Le Phuong Hoang0Xuan Binh Cao1Square Lab, School School of Mechanical Engineering, Hanoi University of Science and Technology (HUST), Ha Noi 10000, Viet NamSquare Lab, School School of Mechanical Engineering, Hanoi University of Science and Technology (HUST), Ha Noi 10000, Viet Nam; School School of Mechanical Engineering, Hanoi University of Science and Technology (HUST), Ha Noi 10000, Viet Nam; Corresponding author.We examine the calculations of ks2 of both transverse electric and transverse magnetic wave modes proposed by the paper “Electromagnetic wave propagation in a superconducting parallel-plate waveguide filled with an indefinite medium” by Burhan Zamir, Rashid Ali, and Muzaffar Bashir [Results Phys, 13 2019, 102312] and demonstrate that the result of ks2 in case of transverse electric waves is wrong. The correct results are given.http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2211379721000796Anisotropic indefinite mediumTransverse electric wavesMeissner boundary conditions
collection	DOAJ
language	English
format	Article
sources	DOAJ
author	Le Phuong Hoang Xuan Binh Cao
spellingShingle	Le Phuong Hoang Xuan Binh Cao Comment on “Electromagnetic wave propagation in a superconducting parallel-plate waveguide filled with an indefinite medium” by Burhan Zamir, Rashid Ali, and Muzaffar Bashir [Results Phys, 13 2019, 102312] Results in Physics Anisotropic indefinite medium Transverse electric waves Meissner boundary conditions
author_facet	Le Phuong Hoang Xuan Binh Cao
author_sort	Le Phuong Hoang
title	Comment on “Electromagnetic wave propagation in a superconducting parallel-plate waveguide filled with an indefinite medium” by Burhan Zamir, Rashid Ali, and Muzaffar Bashir [Results Phys, 13 2019, 102312]
title_short	Comment on “Electromagnetic wave propagation in a superconducting parallel-plate waveguide filled with an indefinite medium” by Burhan Zamir, Rashid Ali, and Muzaffar Bashir [Results Phys, 13 2019, 102312]
title_full	Comment on “Electromagnetic wave propagation in a superconducting parallel-plate waveguide filled with an indefinite medium” by Burhan Zamir, Rashid Ali, and Muzaffar Bashir [Results Phys, 13 2019, 102312]
title_fullStr	Comment on “Electromagnetic wave propagation in a superconducting parallel-plate waveguide filled with an indefinite medium” by Burhan Zamir, Rashid Ali, and Muzaffar Bashir [Results Phys, 13 2019, 102312]
title_full_unstemmed	Comment on “Electromagnetic wave propagation in a superconducting parallel-plate waveguide filled with an indefinite medium” by Burhan Zamir, Rashid Ali, and Muzaffar Bashir [Results Phys, 13 2019, 102312]
title_sort	comment on “electromagnetic wave propagation in a superconducting parallel-plate waveguide filled with an indefinite medium” by burhan zamir, rashid ali, and muzaffar bashir [results phys, 13 2019, 102312]
publisher	Elsevier
series	Results in Physics
issn	2211-3797
publishDate	2021-03-01
description	We examine the calculations of ks2 of both transverse electric and transverse magnetic wave modes proposed by the paper “Electromagnetic wave propagation in a superconducting parallel-plate waveguide filled with an indefinite medium” by Burhan Zamir, Rashid Ali, and Muzaffar Bashir [Results Phys, 13 2019, 102312] and demonstrate that the result of ks2 in case of transverse electric waves is wrong. The correct results are given.
topic	Anisotropic indefinite medium Transverse electric waves Meissner boundary conditions
url	http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2211379721000796
work_keys_str_mv	AT lephuonghoang commentonelectromagneticwavepropagationinasuperconductingparallelplatewaveguidefilledwithanindefinitemediumbyburhanzamirrashidaliandmuzaffarbashirresultsphys132019102312 AT xuanbinhcao commentonelectromagneticwavepropagationinasuperconductingparallelplatewaveguidefilledwithanindefinitemediumbyburhanzamirrashidaliandmuzaffarbashirresultsphys132019102312
_version_	1724229455333818368

Comment on “Electromagnetic wave propagation in a superconducting parallel-plate waveguide filled with an indefinite medium” by Burhan Zamir, Rashid Ali, and Muzaffar Bashir [Results Phys, 13 2019, 102312]

Similar Items