A Pressure-Pad-Embedded Treadmill Yields Time-Dependent Errors in Estimating Ground Reaction Force during Walking

Accurate and reliable vertical ground reaction force (VGRF) measurement is essential in various biomechanical and clinical studies. Recently, pressure–pad-embedded treadmills have been widely used for VGRF measurement as a relatively less expensive option than the force platform-mounted treadmills....

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Prabhat Pathak, Jooeun Ahn
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: MDPI AG 2021-08-01
Series:Sensors
Subjects:
Online Access:https://www.mdpi.com/1424-8220/21/16/5511
id doaj-d5792d503e27465099d8feeb8b61ee49
record_format Article
spelling doaj-d5792d503e27465099d8feeb8b61ee492021-08-26T14:19:19ZengMDPI AGSensors1424-82202021-08-01215511551110.3390/s21165511A Pressure-Pad-Embedded Treadmill Yields Time-Dependent Errors in Estimating Ground Reaction Force during WalkingPrabhat Pathak0Jooeun Ahn1Department of Physical Education, Seoul National University, Seoul 08826, KoreaDepartment of Physical Education, Seoul National University, Seoul 08826, KoreaAccurate and reliable vertical ground reaction force (VGRF) measurement is essential in various biomechanical and clinical studies. Recently, pressure–pad-embedded treadmills have been widely used for VGRF measurement as a relatively less expensive option than the force platform-mounted treadmills. Prior studies have shown that the popular Zebris treadmill is reliable when used to measure peak VGRF for short walking sessions. However, comprehensive evaluation of human walking requires information of gait parameters over sufficient gait cycles. In this study, we quantify the long-term temporal changes in VGRF values measured by the Zebris treadmill. Twenty participants walked on the treadmill for 10 min twice, with 10 min rest between trials. We found an evident decline in the measured VGRF and impulse over time for both trials. The Zebris system also consistently yielded the lower VGRF values during the second trials. These results indicate that the Zebris treadmill is unreliable in measuring VGRF during walking, and a 10 min break is not enough for the embedded sensors to recover their sensitivity. We provided a way to resolve these time-dependent errors; using the impulse-momentum theorem and collected kinematics of the participants, we formulated a curve-fitting model encapsulating the growing VGRF estimation error.https://www.mdpi.com/1424-8220/21/16/5511vertical ground reaction force (VGRF)Zebris treadmillcapacitive sensorswalkingmeasurement reliabilityestimation errors
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Prabhat Pathak
Jooeun Ahn
spellingShingle Prabhat Pathak
Jooeun Ahn
A Pressure-Pad-Embedded Treadmill Yields Time-Dependent Errors in Estimating Ground Reaction Force during Walking
Sensors
vertical ground reaction force (VGRF)
Zebris treadmill
capacitive sensors
walking
measurement reliability
estimation errors
author_facet Prabhat Pathak
Jooeun Ahn
author_sort Prabhat Pathak
title A Pressure-Pad-Embedded Treadmill Yields Time-Dependent Errors in Estimating Ground Reaction Force during Walking
title_short A Pressure-Pad-Embedded Treadmill Yields Time-Dependent Errors in Estimating Ground Reaction Force during Walking
title_full A Pressure-Pad-Embedded Treadmill Yields Time-Dependent Errors in Estimating Ground Reaction Force during Walking
title_fullStr A Pressure-Pad-Embedded Treadmill Yields Time-Dependent Errors in Estimating Ground Reaction Force during Walking
title_full_unstemmed A Pressure-Pad-Embedded Treadmill Yields Time-Dependent Errors in Estimating Ground Reaction Force during Walking
title_sort pressure-pad-embedded treadmill yields time-dependent errors in estimating ground reaction force during walking
publisher MDPI AG
series Sensors
issn 1424-8220
publishDate 2021-08-01
description Accurate and reliable vertical ground reaction force (VGRF) measurement is essential in various biomechanical and clinical studies. Recently, pressure–pad-embedded treadmills have been widely used for VGRF measurement as a relatively less expensive option than the force platform-mounted treadmills. Prior studies have shown that the popular Zebris treadmill is reliable when used to measure peak VGRF for short walking sessions. However, comprehensive evaluation of human walking requires information of gait parameters over sufficient gait cycles. In this study, we quantify the long-term temporal changes in VGRF values measured by the Zebris treadmill. Twenty participants walked on the treadmill for 10 min twice, with 10 min rest between trials. We found an evident decline in the measured VGRF and impulse over time for both trials. The Zebris system also consistently yielded the lower VGRF values during the second trials. These results indicate that the Zebris treadmill is unreliable in measuring VGRF during walking, and a 10 min break is not enough for the embedded sensors to recover their sensitivity. We provided a way to resolve these time-dependent errors; using the impulse-momentum theorem and collected kinematics of the participants, we formulated a curve-fitting model encapsulating the growing VGRF estimation error.
topic vertical ground reaction force (VGRF)
Zebris treadmill
capacitive sensors
walking
measurement reliability
estimation errors
url https://www.mdpi.com/1424-8220/21/16/5511
work_keys_str_mv AT prabhatpathak apressurepadembeddedtreadmillyieldstimedependenterrorsinestimatinggroundreactionforceduringwalking
AT jooeunahn apressurepadembeddedtreadmillyieldstimedependenterrorsinestimatinggroundreactionforceduringwalking
AT prabhatpathak pressurepadembeddedtreadmillyieldstimedependenterrorsinestimatinggroundreactionforceduringwalking
AT jooeunahn pressurepadembeddedtreadmillyieldstimedependenterrorsinestimatinggroundreactionforceduringwalking
_version_ 1721190098358239232