Norm conflicts as governance challenges for Seed Commons: Comparing cases from Germany and the Philippines

• Main Author: Julia Tschersich
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Published: Elsevier 2021-03-01
• Series: Earth System Governance
• Subjects: Seed commons; Regime complex; Norm interplay; Biodiversity governance; Intellectual property rights; Access and benefit sharing
• Online Access: http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S258981162100001X

A Seed Commons approach can help to highlight the common struggle of diverse seed initiatives in the Global North and South in light of the dominant pathway of enclosure and commodification of seeds that threatens food sovereignty and cultivated plant-genetic diversity. In this paper, the Seed Commons framework is applied to show how the conflicting norms and rules of the international regime complex surrounding seeds shape the scope of action for Seed Commons in Germany and the Philippines. The analysis shows that the patent and variety protection regimes have strongly influenced the design of national seed marketing and threaten to outlaw practices of Seed Commons. Despite limited practical impact for Seed Commons initiatives (so far), the norms of the Nagoya Protocol and the Seed Treaty have contributed to exceptions in national seed marketing law that provide essential scope of action for Seed Commons initiatives in Europe and the Philippines.