Forest Restoration Monitoring Protocol with a Low-Cost Remotely Piloted Aircraft: Lessons Learned from a Case Study in the Brazilian Atlantic Forest

Traditional forest restoration (FR) monitoring methods employ spreadsheets and photos taken at the ground level. Since remotely piloted aircraft (RPA) generate a panoramic high resolution and georeferenced view of the entire area of interest, this technology has high potential to improve the traditi...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Rafael Walter Albuquerque, Manuel Eduardo Ferreira, Søren Ingvor Olsen, Julio Ricardo Caetano Tymus, Cintia Palheta Balieiro, Hendrik Mansur, Ciro José Ribeiro Moura, João Vitor Silva Costa, Maurício Ruiz Castello Branco, Carlos Henrique Grohmann
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: MDPI AG 2021-06-01
Series:Remote Sensing
Subjects:
Online Access:https://www.mdpi.com/2072-4292/13/12/2401
id doaj-d28b5fbd286c42189b49785d44ffca93
record_format Article
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Rafael Walter Albuquerque
Manuel Eduardo Ferreira
Søren Ingvor Olsen
Julio Ricardo Caetano Tymus
Cintia Palheta Balieiro
Hendrik Mansur
Ciro José Ribeiro Moura
João Vitor Silva Costa
Maurício Ruiz Castello Branco
Carlos Henrique Grohmann
spellingShingle Rafael Walter Albuquerque
Manuel Eduardo Ferreira
Søren Ingvor Olsen
Julio Ricardo Caetano Tymus
Cintia Palheta Balieiro
Hendrik Mansur
Ciro José Ribeiro Moura
João Vitor Silva Costa
Maurício Ruiz Castello Branco
Carlos Henrique Grohmann
Forest Restoration Monitoring Protocol with a Low-Cost Remotely Piloted Aircraft: Lessons Learned from a Case Study in the Brazilian Atlantic Forest
Remote Sensing
Atlantic Forest
drones
SfM-MVS
structural parameters
unmanned aerial vehicle
author_facet Rafael Walter Albuquerque
Manuel Eduardo Ferreira
Søren Ingvor Olsen
Julio Ricardo Caetano Tymus
Cintia Palheta Balieiro
Hendrik Mansur
Ciro José Ribeiro Moura
João Vitor Silva Costa
Maurício Ruiz Castello Branco
Carlos Henrique Grohmann
author_sort Rafael Walter Albuquerque
title Forest Restoration Monitoring Protocol with a Low-Cost Remotely Piloted Aircraft: Lessons Learned from a Case Study in the Brazilian Atlantic Forest
title_short Forest Restoration Monitoring Protocol with a Low-Cost Remotely Piloted Aircraft: Lessons Learned from a Case Study in the Brazilian Atlantic Forest
title_full Forest Restoration Monitoring Protocol with a Low-Cost Remotely Piloted Aircraft: Lessons Learned from a Case Study in the Brazilian Atlantic Forest
title_fullStr Forest Restoration Monitoring Protocol with a Low-Cost Remotely Piloted Aircraft: Lessons Learned from a Case Study in the Brazilian Atlantic Forest
title_full_unstemmed Forest Restoration Monitoring Protocol with a Low-Cost Remotely Piloted Aircraft: Lessons Learned from a Case Study in the Brazilian Atlantic Forest
title_sort forest restoration monitoring protocol with a low-cost remotely piloted aircraft: lessons learned from a case study in the brazilian atlantic forest
publisher MDPI AG
series Remote Sensing
issn 2072-4292
publishDate 2021-06-01
description Traditional forest restoration (FR) monitoring methods employ spreadsheets and photos taken at the ground level. Since remotely piloted aircraft (RPA) generate a panoramic high resolution and georeferenced view of the entire area of interest, this technology has high potential to improve the traditional FR monitoring methods. This study evaluates how low-cost RPA data may contribute to FR monitoring of the Brazilian Atlantic Forest by the automatic remote measurement of Tree Density, Tree Height, Vegetation Cover (area covered by trees), and Grass Infestation. The point cloud data was processed to map the Tree Density, Tree Height, and Vegetation Cover parameters. The orthomosaic was used for a Random Forest classification that considered trees and grasses as a single land cover class. The Grass Infestation parameter was mapped by the difference between this land cover class (which considered trees and grasses) and the Vegetation Cover results (obtained by the point cloud data processing). Tree Density, Vegetation Cover, and Grass Infestation parameters presented F_scores of 0.92, 0.85, and 0.64, respectively. Tree Height accuracy was indicated by the Error Percentage considering the traditional fieldwork and the RPA results. The Error Percentage was equal to 0.13 and was considered accurate because it estimated a 13% shorter height for trees that averaged 1.93 m tall. Thus, this study showed that the FR structural parameters were accurately measured by the low-cost RPA, a technology that contributes to FR monitoring. Despite accurately measuring the structural parameters, this study reinforced the challenge of measuring the Biodiversity parameter via remote sensing because the classification of tree species was not possible. After all, the Brazilian Atlantic Forest is a biodiversity hotspot, and thus different species have similar spectral responses in the visible spectrum and similar geometric forms. Therefore, until improved automatic classification methods become available for tree species, traditional fieldwork remains necessary for a complete FR monitoring diagnostic.
topic Atlantic Forest
drones
SfM-MVS
structural parameters
unmanned aerial vehicle
url https://www.mdpi.com/2072-4292/13/12/2401
work_keys_str_mv AT rafaelwalteralbuquerque forestrestorationmonitoringprotocolwithalowcostremotelypilotedaircraftlessonslearnedfromacasestudyinthebrazilianatlanticforest
AT manueleduardoferreira forestrestorationmonitoringprotocolwithalowcostremotelypilotedaircraftlessonslearnedfromacasestudyinthebrazilianatlanticforest
AT søreningvorolsen forestrestorationmonitoringprotocolwithalowcostremotelypilotedaircraftlessonslearnedfromacasestudyinthebrazilianatlanticforest
AT julioricardocaetanotymus forestrestorationmonitoringprotocolwithalowcostremotelypilotedaircraftlessonslearnedfromacasestudyinthebrazilianatlanticforest
AT cintiapalhetabalieiro forestrestorationmonitoringprotocolwithalowcostremotelypilotedaircraftlessonslearnedfromacasestudyinthebrazilianatlanticforest
AT hendrikmansur forestrestorationmonitoringprotocolwithalowcostremotelypilotedaircraftlessonslearnedfromacasestudyinthebrazilianatlanticforest
AT cirojoseribeiromoura forestrestorationmonitoringprotocolwithalowcostremotelypilotedaircraftlessonslearnedfromacasestudyinthebrazilianatlanticforest
AT joaovitorsilvacosta forestrestorationmonitoringprotocolwithalowcostremotelypilotedaircraftlessonslearnedfromacasestudyinthebrazilianatlanticforest
AT mauricioruizcastellobranco forestrestorationmonitoringprotocolwithalowcostremotelypilotedaircraftlessonslearnedfromacasestudyinthebrazilianatlanticforest
AT carloshenriquegrohmann forestrestorationmonitoringprotocolwithalowcostremotelypilotedaircraftlessonslearnedfromacasestudyinthebrazilianatlanticforest
_version_ 1721348120009244672
spelling doaj-d28b5fbd286c42189b49785d44ffca932021-07-01T00:37:31ZengMDPI AGRemote Sensing2072-42922021-06-01132401240110.3390/rs13122401Forest Restoration Monitoring Protocol with a Low-Cost Remotely Piloted Aircraft: Lessons Learned from a Case Study in the Brazilian Atlantic ForestRafael Walter Albuquerque0Manuel Eduardo Ferreira1Søren Ingvor Olsen2Julio Ricardo Caetano Tymus3Cintia Palheta Balieiro4Hendrik Mansur5Ciro José Ribeiro Moura6João Vitor Silva Costa7Maurício Ruiz Castello Branco8Carlos Henrique Grohmann9Institute of Energy and Environment, University of São Paulo, Prof. Luciano Gualberto Avenue, 1289, Butanta 05508-010, SP, BrazilInstituto de Estudos Socioambientais—IESA, Laboratório de Processamento de Imagens e Geoprocessamento—LAPIG/Pro-Vant, Universidade Federal de Goiás—UFG, Campus II, Cx. Postal 131, Goiânia 74001-970, GO, BrazilDepartment of Computer Science (DIKU), University of Copenhagen, Universitetsparken 1, 2100 Ø Copenhagen, DenmarkThe Nature Conservancy Brasil—TNC, Av. Paulista, 2439/91, Bela Vista 01311-300, SP, BrazilThe Nature Conservancy Brasil—TNC, Av. Paulista, 2439/91, Bela Vista 01311-300, SP, BrazilThe Nature Conservancy Brasil—TNC, Av. Paulista, 2439/91, Bela Vista 01311-300, SP, BrazilPrograma de Engenharia Ambiental, Av. Athos da Silveira Ramos, 149, Ilha do Fundão, Centro de Tecnologia—Bloco A, 2º andar, Sala DAPG—Universidade Federal do Rio de Janeiro, Escola Politécnica 21941-909, RJ, BrazilInstituto de Estudos Socioambientais—IESA, Laboratório de Processamento de Imagens e Geoprocessamento—LAPIG/Pro-Vant, Universidade Federal de Goiás—UFG, Campus II, Cx. Postal 131, Goiânia 74001-970, GO, BrazilInstituto Terra de Preservação Ambiental—ITPA, Rua Francisco Alves, 53, Miguel Pereira 26900-000, RJ, BrazilInstitute of Energy and Environment, University of São Paulo, Prof. Luciano Gualberto Avenue, 1289, Butanta 05508-010, SP, BrazilTraditional forest restoration (FR) monitoring methods employ spreadsheets and photos taken at the ground level. Since remotely piloted aircraft (RPA) generate a panoramic high resolution and georeferenced view of the entire area of interest, this technology has high potential to improve the traditional FR monitoring methods. This study evaluates how low-cost RPA data may contribute to FR monitoring of the Brazilian Atlantic Forest by the automatic remote measurement of Tree Density, Tree Height, Vegetation Cover (area covered by trees), and Grass Infestation. The point cloud data was processed to map the Tree Density, Tree Height, and Vegetation Cover parameters. The orthomosaic was used for a Random Forest classification that considered trees and grasses as a single land cover class. The Grass Infestation parameter was mapped by the difference between this land cover class (which considered trees and grasses) and the Vegetation Cover results (obtained by the point cloud data processing). Tree Density, Vegetation Cover, and Grass Infestation parameters presented F_scores of 0.92, 0.85, and 0.64, respectively. Tree Height accuracy was indicated by the Error Percentage considering the traditional fieldwork and the RPA results. The Error Percentage was equal to 0.13 and was considered accurate because it estimated a 13% shorter height for trees that averaged 1.93 m tall. Thus, this study showed that the FR structural parameters were accurately measured by the low-cost RPA, a technology that contributes to FR monitoring. Despite accurately measuring the structural parameters, this study reinforced the challenge of measuring the Biodiversity parameter via remote sensing because the classification of tree species was not possible. After all, the Brazilian Atlantic Forest is a biodiversity hotspot, and thus different species have similar spectral responses in the visible spectrum and similar geometric forms. Therefore, until improved automatic classification methods become available for tree species, traditional fieldwork remains necessary for a complete FR monitoring diagnostic.https://www.mdpi.com/2072-4292/13/12/2401Atlantic ForestdronesSfM-MVSstructural parametersunmanned aerial vehicle