Whole genome sequencing of colonies derived from cannabis flowers and the impact of media selection on benchmarking total yeast and mold detection tools [version 2; peer review: 2 approved]

Background: Cannabis products are subjected to microbial testing for human pathogenic fungi and bacteria. These testing requirements often rely on non-specific colony forming unit (CFU/g) specifications without clarity on which medium, selection or growth times are required. We performed whole genom...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Kevin McKernan, Yvonne Helbert, Liam Kane, Nathan Houde, Lei Zhang, Stephen McLaughlin
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: F1000 Research Ltd 2021-08-01
Series:F1000Research
Online Access:https://f1000research.com/articles/10-624/v2
id doaj-ce3f49c8a8ff470e82fbc06bb4b5cdd7
record_format Article
spelling doaj-ce3f49c8a8ff470e82fbc06bb4b5cdd72021-08-31T16:17:38ZengF1000 Research LtdF1000Research2046-14022021-08-011010.12688/f1000research.53467.270512Whole genome sequencing of colonies derived from cannabis flowers and the impact of media selection on benchmarking total yeast and mold detection tools [version 2; peer review: 2 approved]Kevin McKernan0Yvonne Helbert1Liam Kane2Nathan Houde3Lei Zhang4Stephen McLaughlin5Research and Development, Medicinal Genomics, Beverly, Mass, 01915, USAResearch and Development, Medicinal Genomics, Beverly, Mass, 01915, USAResearch and Development, Medicinal Genomics, Beverly, Mass, 01915, USAResearch and Development, Medicinal Genomics, Beverly, Mass, 01915, USAResearch and Development, Medicinal Genomics, Beverly, Mass, 01915, USAResearch and Development, Medicinal Genomics, Beverly, Mass, 01915, USABackground: Cannabis products are subjected to microbial testing for human pathogenic fungi and bacteria. These testing requirements often rely on non-specific colony forming unit (CFU/g) specifications without clarity on which medium, selection or growth times are required. We performed whole genome sequencing to assess the specificity of colony forming units (CFU) derived from three different plating media: Potato Dextrose Agar (PDA), PDA with chloramphenicol and Dichloran Rose Bengal with chloramphenicol (DRBC). Methods: Colonies were isolated from each medium type and their whole genomes sequenced to identify the diversity of microbes present on each medium selection. Fungal Internal Transcribed Spacer (ITS3) and Bacterial 16S RNA(16S) quantitative polymerase chain reactions (qPCR) were performed, to correlate these CFUs with fungi- and bacterial- specific qPCR. Results: Each plating medium displayed a ten-fold difference in CFU counts. PDA with chloramphenicol showed the highest diversity and the highest concordance with whole genome sequencing. According to ITS3 and 16S qPCR confirmed with whole genome sequencing, DRBC under counted yeast and mold while PDA without chloramphenicol over counted CFUs due to bacterial growth without selection. Conclusions: Colony Forming Unit regulations lack specificity. Each medium produces significant differences in CFU counts. These are further dependent on subjective interpretation, failure to culture most microbes, and poor selection between bacteria and fungi. Given the most human pathogenic microbes found on cannabis are endophytes which culture fails to detect, molecular methods offer a solution to this long-standing quantification problem in the cannabis testing field.https://f1000research.com/articles/10-624/v2
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Kevin McKernan
Yvonne Helbert
Liam Kane
Nathan Houde
Lei Zhang
Stephen McLaughlin
spellingShingle Kevin McKernan
Yvonne Helbert
Liam Kane
Nathan Houde
Lei Zhang
Stephen McLaughlin
Whole genome sequencing of colonies derived from cannabis flowers and the impact of media selection on benchmarking total yeast and mold detection tools [version 2; peer review: 2 approved]
F1000Research
author_facet Kevin McKernan
Yvonne Helbert
Liam Kane
Nathan Houde
Lei Zhang
Stephen McLaughlin
author_sort Kevin McKernan
title Whole genome sequencing of colonies derived from cannabis flowers and the impact of media selection on benchmarking total yeast and mold detection tools [version 2; peer review: 2 approved]
title_short Whole genome sequencing of colonies derived from cannabis flowers and the impact of media selection on benchmarking total yeast and mold detection tools [version 2; peer review: 2 approved]
title_full Whole genome sequencing of colonies derived from cannabis flowers and the impact of media selection on benchmarking total yeast and mold detection tools [version 2; peer review: 2 approved]
title_fullStr Whole genome sequencing of colonies derived from cannabis flowers and the impact of media selection on benchmarking total yeast and mold detection tools [version 2; peer review: 2 approved]
title_full_unstemmed Whole genome sequencing of colonies derived from cannabis flowers and the impact of media selection on benchmarking total yeast and mold detection tools [version 2; peer review: 2 approved]
title_sort whole genome sequencing of colonies derived from cannabis flowers and the impact of media selection on benchmarking total yeast and mold detection tools [version 2; peer review: 2 approved]
publisher F1000 Research Ltd
series F1000Research
issn 2046-1402
publishDate 2021-08-01
description Background: Cannabis products are subjected to microbial testing for human pathogenic fungi and bacteria. These testing requirements often rely on non-specific colony forming unit (CFU/g) specifications without clarity on which medium, selection or growth times are required. We performed whole genome sequencing to assess the specificity of colony forming units (CFU) derived from three different plating media: Potato Dextrose Agar (PDA), PDA with chloramphenicol and Dichloran Rose Bengal with chloramphenicol (DRBC). Methods: Colonies were isolated from each medium type and their whole genomes sequenced to identify the diversity of microbes present on each medium selection. Fungal Internal Transcribed Spacer (ITS3) and Bacterial 16S RNA(16S) quantitative polymerase chain reactions (qPCR) were performed, to correlate these CFUs with fungi- and bacterial- specific qPCR. Results: Each plating medium displayed a ten-fold difference in CFU counts. PDA with chloramphenicol showed the highest diversity and the highest concordance with whole genome sequencing. According to ITS3 and 16S qPCR confirmed with whole genome sequencing, DRBC under counted yeast and mold while PDA without chloramphenicol over counted CFUs due to bacterial growth without selection. Conclusions: Colony Forming Unit regulations lack specificity. Each medium produces significant differences in CFU counts. These are further dependent on subjective interpretation, failure to culture most microbes, and poor selection between bacteria and fungi. Given the most human pathogenic microbes found on cannabis are endophytes which culture fails to detect, molecular methods offer a solution to this long-standing quantification problem in the cannabis testing field.
url https://f1000research.com/articles/10-624/v2
work_keys_str_mv AT kevinmckernan wholegenomesequencingofcoloniesderivedfromcannabisflowersandtheimpactofmediaselectiononbenchmarkingtotalyeastandmolddetectiontoolsversion2peerreview2approved
AT yvonnehelbert wholegenomesequencingofcoloniesderivedfromcannabisflowersandtheimpactofmediaselectiononbenchmarkingtotalyeastandmolddetectiontoolsversion2peerreview2approved
AT liamkane wholegenomesequencingofcoloniesderivedfromcannabisflowersandtheimpactofmediaselectiononbenchmarkingtotalyeastandmolddetectiontoolsversion2peerreview2approved
AT nathanhoude wholegenomesequencingofcoloniesderivedfromcannabisflowersandtheimpactofmediaselectiononbenchmarkingtotalyeastandmolddetectiontoolsversion2peerreview2approved
AT leizhang wholegenomesequencingofcoloniesderivedfromcannabisflowersandtheimpactofmediaselectiononbenchmarkingtotalyeastandmolddetectiontoolsversion2peerreview2approved
AT stephenmclaughlin wholegenomesequencingofcoloniesderivedfromcannabisflowersandtheimpactofmediaselectiononbenchmarkingtotalyeastandmolddetectiontoolsversion2peerreview2approved
_version_ 1721183298412085248