Small-Area Estimation with Zero-Inflated Data – a Simulation Study

• Main Authors: Krieg Sabine, Boonstra Harm Jan, Smeets Marc
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Published: Sciendo 2016-12-01
• Series: Journal of Official Statistics
• Subjects: generalized linear mixed model; eblup; mcmc; logit; dutch household budget survey
• Online Access: https://doi.org/10.1515/jos-2016-0051

Many target variables in official statistics follow a semicontinuous distribution with a mixture of zeros and continuously distributed positive values. Such variables are called zero inflated. When reliable estimates for subpopulations with small sample sizes are required, model-based small-area estimators can be used, which improve the accuracy of the estimates by borrowing information from other subpopulations. In this article, three small-area estimators are investigated. The first estimator is the EBLUP, which can be considered the most common small-area estimator and is based on a linear mixed model that assumes normal distributions. Therefore, the EBLUP is model misspecified in the case of zero-inflated variables. The other two small-area estimators are based on a model that takes zero inflation explicitly into account. Both the Bayesian and the frequentist approach are considered. These small-area estimators are compared with each other and with design-based estimation in a simulation study with zero-inflated target variables. Both a simulation with artificial data and a simulation with real data from the Dutch Household Budget Survey are carried out. It is found that the small-area estimators improve the accuracy compared to the design-based estimator. The amount of improvement strongly depends on the properties of the population and the subpopulations of interest.