Jacques Derrida: The Double Liminality of a Philosophical Marrano

• Main Author: Emilie Kutash
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Published: MDPI AG 2019-01-01
• Series: Religions
• Subjects: Derrida; philosophical Marrano; liminal; archive; Hebrew; Greek; Monolingualism
• Online Access: https://www.mdpi.com/2077-1444/10/2/68

There is an analogy between two types of liminality: the geographic or cultural ‘outside’ space of the Marrano Jew, alienated from his/her original religion and the one he or she has been forced to adopt, and, a philosophical position that is outside of both Athens and Jerusalem. Derrida finds and re-finds ‘h’ors- texte’, an ‘internal desert’, a ‘secret’ outside place: alien to both the western philosophical tradition and the Hebraic archive. In this liminal space he questions the otherness of the French language to which he was acculturated, and, in a turn to a less discursive modality, autobiography, finds, in the words of Helene Cixous, “the Jew-who-doesn’t know-that-he-is”. Derrida’s galut (exile) is neither Hebrew nor Greek. It is a private place outside of all discourse, which he claims, is inevitably ethnocentric. In inhabiting this outside space, he exercises the prerogative of a Marrano, equipped to critique the French language of his acculturation and the western philosophy of the scholars. French and Hebrew are irreconcilable binaries, western philosophy and his Hebrew legacy is as well. These issues will be discussed in this paper with reference to <i>Monolingualism of the Other</i> and <i>Archive Fever</i> as they augment some of his earlier work, <i>Writing and Difference</i> and <i>Speech and Phenomena</i>.