Throughput and Economics of DSRC-Based Internet of Vehicles

Vehicular mesh networks could be an important new way to provide Internet access in urban areas using dedicated short range communications (DSRC). In some circumstances, DSRC technology is more cost-effective than expanding the capacity of cellular networks. We determine what those circumstances are...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Alexandre K. Ligo, Jon M. Peha, Pedro Ferreira, Joao Barros
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: IEEE 2018-01-01
Series:IEEE Access
Subjects:
Online Access:https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/8241368/
id doaj-c9a13a8fac2b40dabc090e02956f75e2
record_format Article
spelling doaj-c9a13a8fac2b40dabc090e02956f75e22021-03-29T20:38:43ZengIEEEIEEE Access2169-35362018-01-0167276729010.1109/ACCESS.2017.27854998241368Throughput and Economics of DSRC-Based Internet of VehiclesAlexandre K. Ligo0https://orcid.org/0000-0002-8373-8283Jon M. Peha1Pedro Ferreira2Joao Barros3Department of Engineering and Public Policy, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA, USADepartment of Engineering and Public Policy, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA, USADepartment of Engineering and Public Policy, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA, USAFaculdade de Engenharia, Universidade do Porto, Porto, PortugalVehicular mesh networks could be an important new way to provide Internet access in urban areas using dedicated short range communications (DSRC). In some circumstances, DSRC technology is more cost-effective than expanding the capacity of cellular networks. We determine what those circumstances are by combining our simulation model with data collected from an actual vehicular network that is operating in Portugal. We use the model to estimate how much Internet traffic can be offloaded to vehicular networks that would otherwise be carried by cellular networks, under a variety of conditions. We use offloaded traffic to estimate the benefits of cost savings of reduced cellular infrastructure due to offload, and the cost of the DSRC vehicular network to carry that traffic. Then, we determine when benefit exceeds cost. We find that the benefits from the Internet traffic alone are not enough to justify a universal mandate to deploy DSRC in all vehicles, i.e., the benefits of Internet access alone are less than total costs. However, the majority of DSRC-related costs must be incurred anyway if safety is to be enhanced. Thus, soon after a mandate to put DSRC in new vehicles becomes effective, the benefits of Internet access through vehicular networks in densely populated areas would be significantly greater than the remaining costs, which are the costs of roadside infrastructure that can serve as a gateway to the Internet. Moreover, the benefit of Internet access would exceed DSRC infrastructure cost in regions with lower and lower population densities over time.https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/8241368/Benefit-cost analysisdedicated short range communicationsDSRCmobile data offloadmobile Internetsocial welfare
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Alexandre K. Ligo
Jon M. Peha
Pedro Ferreira
Joao Barros
spellingShingle Alexandre K. Ligo
Jon M. Peha
Pedro Ferreira
Joao Barros
Throughput and Economics of DSRC-Based Internet of Vehicles
IEEE Access
Benefit-cost analysis
dedicated short range communications
DSRC
mobile data offload
mobile Internet
social welfare
author_facet Alexandre K. Ligo
Jon M. Peha
Pedro Ferreira
Joao Barros
author_sort Alexandre K. Ligo
title Throughput and Economics of DSRC-Based Internet of Vehicles
title_short Throughput and Economics of DSRC-Based Internet of Vehicles
title_full Throughput and Economics of DSRC-Based Internet of Vehicles
title_fullStr Throughput and Economics of DSRC-Based Internet of Vehicles
title_full_unstemmed Throughput and Economics of DSRC-Based Internet of Vehicles
title_sort throughput and economics of dsrc-based internet of vehicles
publisher IEEE
series IEEE Access
issn 2169-3536
publishDate 2018-01-01
description Vehicular mesh networks could be an important new way to provide Internet access in urban areas using dedicated short range communications (DSRC). In some circumstances, DSRC technology is more cost-effective than expanding the capacity of cellular networks. We determine what those circumstances are by combining our simulation model with data collected from an actual vehicular network that is operating in Portugal. We use the model to estimate how much Internet traffic can be offloaded to vehicular networks that would otherwise be carried by cellular networks, under a variety of conditions. We use offloaded traffic to estimate the benefits of cost savings of reduced cellular infrastructure due to offload, and the cost of the DSRC vehicular network to carry that traffic. Then, we determine when benefit exceeds cost. We find that the benefits from the Internet traffic alone are not enough to justify a universal mandate to deploy DSRC in all vehicles, i.e., the benefits of Internet access alone are less than total costs. However, the majority of DSRC-related costs must be incurred anyway if safety is to be enhanced. Thus, soon after a mandate to put DSRC in new vehicles becomes effective, the benefits of Internet access through vehicular networks in densely populated areas would be significantly greater than the remaining costs, which are the costs of roadside infrastructure that can serve as a gateway to the Internet. Moreover, the benefit of Internet access would exceed DSRC infrastructure cost in regions with lower and lower population densities over time.
topic Benefit-cost analysis
dedicated short range communications
DSRC
mobile data offload
mobile Internet
social welfare
url https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/8241368/
work_keys_str_mv AT alexandrekligo throughputandeconomicsofdsrcbasedinternetofvehicles
AT jonmpeha throughputandeconomicsofdsrcbasedinternetofvehicles
AT pedroferreira throughputandeconomicsofdsrcbasedinternetofvehicles
AT joaobarros throughputandeconomicsofdsrcbasedinternetofvehicles
_version_ 1724194466611331072