Allocation des droits à bâtir et recours contentieux : quels registres d’argumentation portés par les riverains ?

• Main Authors: Lisa Yahi, Daria Guiomard, Romain Melot, Yann Gérard
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Published: Métropoles 2021-01-01
• Series: Métropoles
• Subjects: litigation; planning; resident; urbanisation; argument
• Online Access: http://journals.openedition.org/metropoles/7387

Empirical data on planning disputes commonly adjudicated by the courts remain quite poor in the literature in social sciences. Based on a statistical study of a sample of some 300 cases in a local administrative court in the South of France, the inquiry underlines the need to consider local rulings that organize building rights beyond simple zoning concerns. Our study proposes an in-depth analysis of the lines of argument used by litigants. We distinguished between cases filed by the local State administration (acting as a guardian of legality) and those filed by residents in the neighborhood of contested developments.