A comparison of methods for sampling aquatic insects (Heteroptera and Coleoptera) of different body sizes, in different habitats using different baits

Although various methods exist for sampling aquatic Heteroptera and Coleoptera in standing water, there are very few comparisons of their performance in different types of habitat. In this study, we evaluated and compared the efficiency and selectivity of three sampling methods: hand netting, bottle...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Nataša TURIĆ, Martina TEMUNOVIĆ, Goran VIGNJEVIĆ, Jasenka ANTUNOVIĆ DUNIĆ, Enrih MERDIĆ
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Institute of Entomology, Biology Centre, Czech Academy of Science 2017-02-01
Series:European Journal of Entomology
Subjects:
Online Access:https://www.eje.cz/artkey/eje-201701-0017_A_comparison_of_methods_for_sampling_aquatic_insects_Heteroptera_and_Coleoptera_of_different_body_sizes_in_d.php
id doaj-bf201283406340aa9e5a2b58b9a5f7e5
record_format Article
spelling doaj-bf201283406340aa9e5a2b58b9a5f7e52021-04-16T20:35:50ZengInstitute of Entomology, Biology Centre, Czech Academy of ScienceEuropean Journal of Entomology1210-57591802-88292017-02-01114112313210.14411/eje.2017.017eje-201701-0017A comparison of methods for sampling aquatic insects (Heteroptera and Coleoptera) of different body sizes, in different habitats using different baitsNataša TURIĆ0Martina TEMUNOVIĆ1Goran VIGNJEVIĆ2Jasenka ANTUNOVIĆ DUNIĆ3Enrih MERDIĆ4University Josip Juraj Strossmayer in Osijek, Department of Biology, Cara Hadrijana 8/A, HR-31000 Osijek, Croatia; e-mails: nturic@biologija.unios.hr, gvignjevic@biologija.unios.hr, jantunovic@biologija.unios.hr, enrih@biologija.unios.hrUniversity of Zagreb, Department of Forest Genetics, Dendrology and Botany, Svetošimunska 25, HR-10000 Zagreb, Croatia; e-mail: martina.temunovic@gmail.comUniversity Josip Juraj Strossmayer in Osijek, Department of Biology, Cara Hadrijana 8/A, HR-31000 Osijek, Croatia; e-mails: nturic@biologija.unios.hr, gvignjevic@biologija.unios.hr, jantunovic@biologija.unios.hr, enrih@biologija.unios.hrUniversity Josip Juraj Strossmayer in Osijek, Department of Biology, Cara Hadrijana 8/A, HR-31000 Osijek, Croatia; e-mails: nturic@biologija.unios.hr, gvignjevic@biologija.unios.hr, jantunovic@biologija.unios.hr, enrih@biologija.unios.hrUniversity Josip Juraj Strossmayer in Osijek, Department of Biology, Cara Hadrijana 8/A, HR-31000 Osijek, Croatia; e-mails: nturic@biologija.unios.hr, gvignjevic@biologija.unios.hr, jantunovic@biologija.unios.hr, enrih@biologija.unios.hrAlthough various methods exist for sampling aquatic Heteroptera and Coleoptera in standing water, there are very few comparisons of their performance in different types of habitat. In this study, we evaluated and compared the efficiency and selectivity of three sampling methods: hand netting, bottle traps baited with canned tuna and bottle traps baited with canned cat food. The methods were compared over the period 2010-2012 in two different habitats (temporarily flooded areas and canals) in the Nature Park Kopački rit, a floodplain on the banks of the River Danube. The results show that the effectiveness of the method differed in the two habitats. Overall, hand netting was the most successful method, mainly in canals. Tuna fish bait was more efficient than the commonly used cat food, especially for large and highly mobile species of Dytiscidae. These findings indicate that knowing the type of habitat and the habitat preferences of aquatic insects and their activity it is possible to predict which of these methods are the best for estimating species richness.https://www.eje.cz/artkey/eje-201701-0017_A_comparison_of_methods_for_sampling_aquatic_insects_Heteroptera_and_Coleoptera_of_different_body_sizes_in_d.phpheteropteracoleopteraaquatic insectssamplingcomparisonbaitbody sizehabitat typespecies richness
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Nataša TURIĆ
Martina TEMUNOVIĆ
Goran VIGNJEVIĆ
Jasenka ANTUNOVIĆ DUNIĆ
Enrih MERDIĆ
spellingShingle Nataša TURIĆ
Martina TEMUNOVIĆ
Goran VIGNJEVIĆ
Jasenka ANTUNOVIĆ DUNIĆ
Enrih MERDIĆ
A comparison of methods for sampling aquatic insects (Heteroptera and Coleoptera) of different body sizes, in different habitats using different baits
European Journal of Entomology
heteroptera
coleoptera
aquatic insects
sampling
comparison
bait
body size
habitat type
species richness
author_facet Nataša TURIĆ
Martina TEMUNOVIĆ
Goran VIGNJEVIĆ
Jasenka ANTUNOVIĆ DUNIĆ
Enrih MERDIĆ
author_sort Nataša TURIĆ
title A comparison of methods for sampling aquatic insects (Heteroptera and Coleoptera) of different body sizes, in different habitats using different baits
title_short A comparison of methods for sampling aquatic insects (Heteroptera and Coleoptera) of different body sizes, in different habitats using different baits
title_full A comparison of methods for sampling aquatic insects (Heteroptera and Coleoptera) of different body sizes, in different habitats using different baits
title_fullStr A comparison of methods for sampling aquatic insects (Heteroptera and Coleoptera) of different body sizes, in different habitats using different baits
title_full_unstemmed A comparison of methods for sampling aquatic insects (Heteroptera and Coleoptera) of different body sizes, in different habitats using different baits
title_sort comparison of methods for sampling aquatic insects (heteroptera and coleoptera) of different body sizes, in different habitats using different baits
publisher Institute of Entomology, Biology Centre, Czech Academy of Science
series European Journal of Entomology
issn 1210-5759
1802-8829
publishDate 2017-02-01
description Although various methods exist for sampling aquatic Heteroptera and Coleoptera in standing water, there are very few comparisons of their performance in different types of habitat. In this study, we evaluated and compared the efficiency and selectivity of three sampling methods: hand netting, bottle traps baited with canned tuna and bottle traps baited with canned cat food. The methods were compared over the period 2010-2012 in two different habitats (temporarily flooded areas and canals) in the Nature Park Kopački rit, a floodplain on the banks of the River Danube. The results show that the effectiveness of the method differed in the two habitats. Overall, hand netting was the most successful method, mainly in canals. Tuna fish bait was more efficient than the commonly used cat food, especially for large and highly mobile species of Dytiscidae. These findings indicate that knowing the type of habitat and the habitat preferences of aquatic insects and their activity it is possible to predict which of these methods are the best for estimating species richness.
topic heteroptera
coleoptera
aquatic insects
sampling
comparison
bait
body size
habitat type
species richness
url https://www.eje.cz/artkey/eje-201701-0017_A_comparison_of_methods_for_sampling_aquatic_insects_Heteroptera_and_Coleoptera_of_different_body_sizes_in_d.php
work_keys_str_mv AT natasaturic acomparisonofmethodsforsamplingaquaticinsectsheteropteraandcoleopteraofdifferentbodysizesindifferenthabitatsusingdifferentbaits
AT martinatemunovic acomparisonofmethodsforsamplingaquaticinsectsheteropteraandcoleopteraofdifferentbodysizesindifferenthabitatsusingdifferentbaits
AT goranvignjevic acomparisonofmethodsforsamplingaquaticinsectsheteropteraandcoleopteraofdifferentbodysizesindifferenthabitatsusingdifferentbaits
AT jasenkaantunovicdunic acomparisonofmethodsforsamplingaquaticinsectsheteropteraandcoleopteraofdifferentbodysizesindifferenthabitatsusingdifferentbaits
AT enrihmerdic acomparisonofmethodsforsamplingaquaticinsectsheteropteraandcoleopteraofdifferentbodysizesindifferenthabitatsusingdifferentbaits
AT natasaturic comparisonofmethodsforsamplingaquaticinsectsheteropteraandcoleopteraofdifferentbodysizesindifferenthabitatsusingdifferentbaits
AT martinatemunovic comparisonofmethodsforsamplingaquaticinsectsheteropteraandcoleopteraofdifferentbodysizesindifferenthabitatsusingdifferentbaits
AT goranvignjevic comparisonofmethodsforsamplingaquaticinsectsheteropteraandcoleopteraofdifferentbodysizesindifferenthabitatsusingdifferentbaits
AT jasenkaantunovicdunic comparisonofmethodsforsamplingaquaticinsectsheteropteraandcoleopteraofdifferentbodysizesindifferenthabitatsusingdifferentbaits
AT enrihmerdic comparisonofmethodsforsamplingaquaticinsectsheteropteraandcoleopteraofdifferentbodysizesindifferenthabitatsusingdifferentbaits
_version_ 1721524499360251904