Assembly Line ICU: what the Long Shops taught us about managing surge capacity for COVID-19
Objectives To safely expand and adapt the normal workings of a large critical care unit in response to the COVID-19 pandemic.Methods In April 2020, UK health systems were challenged to expand critical care capacity rapidly during the first wave of the COVID-19 pandemic so that they could accommodate...
Main Authors: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Format: | Article |
Language: | English |
Published: |
BMJ Publishing Group
2020-12-01
|
Series: | BMJ Open Quality |
Online Access: | https://bmjopenquality.bmj.com/content/9/4/e001117.full |
id |
doaj-bd4a441a918b41eb9be093d7e6503b6f |
---|---|
record_format |
Article |
collection |
DOAJ |
language |
English |
format |
Article |
sources |
DOAJ |
author |
Dhruv Parekh Julian Bion Peter Isherwood Neil Abeysinghe John Kelly Mansoor Bangash Jaimin Patel David Riddington Tomasz Torlinski Nicholas Talbot Tonny Veenith Catherine Snelson Tony Whitehouse Carla Richardson Callum Oakley Craig Pascoe Daivd Balthazor Davinia Bennett Nandan Gautam John Isaac Tracie Matthews Nick Murphy Tessa Oelofse Jeremy Willson Fiona Wyton Abby Ford Alejandro Barrios Andy Johnston Anwar Shah Bill Tunnicliffe Brian Pouchet David Hume Deborah Turfrey Gregory Packer Harjot Singh Ian Ewington Kaye England Laura Tasker Mav Manji Mike Knowles Mohammed Arshad Nilesh Parekh Phillip El-Dalil Randeep Mullhi Ravi Chauhan Ravi Hebballi Richard Browne Sam Denham Sandeep Walia Shraddha Goyal Steffen Kroll Sue Sinclair Tom Clutton-Brock William Tosh Zahid Khan |
spellingShingle |
Dhruv Parekh Julian Bion Peter Isherwood Neil Abeysinghe John Kelly Mansoor Bangash Jaimin Patel David Riddington Tomasz Torlinski Nicholas Talbot Tonny Veenith Catherine Snelson Tony Whitehouse Carla Richardson Callum Oakley Craig Pascoe Daivd Balthazor Davinia Bennett Nandan Gautam John Isaac Tracie Matthews Nick Murphy Tessa Oelofse Jeremy Willson Fiona Wyton Abby Ford Alejandro Barrios Andy Johnston Anwar Shah Bill Tunnicliffe Brian Pouchet David Hume Deborah Turfrey Gregory Packer Harjot Singh Ian Ewington Kaye England Laura Tasker Mav Manji Mike Knowles Mohammed Arshad Nilesh Parekh Phillip El-Dalil Randeep Mullhi Ravi Chauhan Ravi Hebballi Richard Browne Sam Denham Sandeep Walia Shraddha Goyal Steffen Kroll Sue Sinclair Tom Clutton-Brock William Tosh Zahid Khan Assembly Line ICU: what the Long Shops taught us about managing surge capacity for COVID-19 BMJ Open Quality |
author_facet |
Dhruv Parekh Julian Bion Peter Isherwood Neil Abeysinghe John Kelly Mansoor Bangash Jaimin Patel David Riddington Tomasz Torlinski Nicholas Talbot Tonny Veenith Catherine Snelson Tony Whitehouse Carla Richardson Callum Oakley Craig Pascoe Daivd Balthazor Davinia Bennett Nandan Gautam John Isaac Tracie Matthews Nick Murphy Tessa Oelofse Jeremy Willson Fiona Wyton Abby Ford Alejandro Barrios Andy Johnston Anwar Shah Bill Tunnicliffe Brian Pouchet David Hume Deborah Turfrey Gregory Packer Harjot Singh Ian Ewington Kaye England Laura Tasker Mav Manji Mike Knowles Mohammed Arshad Nilesh Parekh Phillip El-Dalil Randeep Mullhi Ravi Chauhan Ravi Hebballi Richard Browne Sam Denham Sandeep Walia Shraddha Goyal Steffen Kroll Sue Sinclair Tom Clutton-Brock William Tosh Zahid Khan |
title |
Assembly Line ICU: what the Long Shops taught us about managing surge capacity for COVID-19 |
title_short |
Assembly Line ICU: what the Long Shops taught us about managing surge capacity for COVID-19 |
title_full |
Assembly Line ICU: what the Long Shops taught us about managing surge capacity for COVID-19 |
title_fullStr |
Assembly Line ICU: what the Long Shops taught us about managing surge capacity for COVID-19 |
title_full_unstemmed |
Assembly Line ICU: what the Long Shops taught us about managing surge capacity for COVID-19 |
title_sort |
assembly line icu: what the long shops taught us about managing surge capacity for covid-19 |
publisher |
BMJ Publishing Group |
series |
BMJ Open Quality |
issn |
2399-6641 |
publishDate |
2020-12-01 |
description |
Objectives To safely expand and adapt the normal workings of a large critical care unit in response to the COVID-19 pandemic.Methods In April 2020, UK health systems were challenged to expand critical care capacity rapidly during the first wave of the COVID-19 pandemic so that they could accommodate patients with respiratory and multiple organ failure. Here, we describe the preparation and adaptive responses of a large critical care unit to the oncoming burden of disease. Our changes were similar to the revolution in manufacturing brought about by ‘Long Shops’ of 1853 when Richard Garrett and Sons of Leiston started mass manufacture of traction engines. This innovation broke the whole process into smaller parts and increased productivity. When applied to COVID-19 preparations, an assembly line approach had the advantage that our ICU became easily scalable to manage an influx of additional staff as well as the increase in admissions. Healthcare professionals could be replaced in case of absence and training focused on a smaller number of tasks.Results Compared with the equivalent period in 2019, the ICU provided 30.9% more patient days (2599 to 3402), 1845 of which were ventilated days (compared with 694 in 2019, 165.8% increase) while time from first referral to ICU admission reduced from 193.8±123.8 min (±SD) to 110.7±76.75 min (±SD). Throughout, ICU maintained adequate capacity and also accepted patients from neighbouring hospitals. This was done by managing an additional 205 doctors (70% increase), 168 nurses who had previously worked in ICU and another 261 nurses deployed from other parts of the hospital (82% increase).Our large tertiary hospital ensured a dedicated non-COVID ICU was staffed and equipped to take regional emergency referrals so that those patients requiring specialist surgery and treatment were treated throughout the COVID-19 pandemic.Conclusions We report how the challenge of managing a huge influx of patients and redeployed staff was met by deconstructing ICU care into its constituent parts. Although reported from the largest colocated ICU in the UK, we believe that this offers solutions to ICUs of all sizes and may provide a generalisable model for critical care pandemic surge planning. |
url |
https://bmjopenquality.bmj.com/content/9/4/e001117.full |
work_keys_str_mv |
AT assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT dhruvparekh assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT julianbion assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT peterisherwood assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT neilabeysinghe assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT johnkelly assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT mansoorbangash assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT jaiminpatel assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT davidriddington assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT tomasztorlinski assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT nicholastalbot assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT tonnyveenith assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT catherinesnelson assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT tonywhitehouse assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT carlarichardson assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT callumoakley assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT craigpascoe assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT daivdbalthazor assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT daviniabennett assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT nandangautam assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT johnisaac assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT traciematthews assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT nickmurphy assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT tessaoelofse assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT jeremywillson assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT fionawyton assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT abbyford assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT alejandrobarrios assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT andyjohnston assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT anwarshah assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT billtunnicliffe assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT brianpouchet assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT davidhume assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT deborahturfrey assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT gregorypacker assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT harjotsingh assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT ianewington assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT kayeengland assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT lauratasker assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT mavmanji assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT mikeknowles assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT mohammedarshad assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT nileshparekh assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT phillipeldalil assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT randeepmullhi assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT ravichauhan assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT ravihebballi assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT richardbrowne assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT samdenham assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT sandeepwalia assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT shraddhagoyal assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT steffenkroll assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT suesinclair assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT tomcluttonbrock assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT williamtosh assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 AT zahidkhan assemblylineicuwhatthelongshopstaughtusaboutmanagingsurgecapacityforcovid19 |
_version_ |
1724315369325199360 |
spelling |
doaj-bd4a441a918b41eb9be093d7e6503b6f2021-02-01T14:00:25ZengBMJ Publishing GroupBMJ Open Quality2399-66412020-12-019410.1136/bmjoq-2020-001117Assembly Line ICU: what the Long Shops taught us about managing surge capacity for COVID-19 0Dhruv Parekh1Julian BionPeter Isherwood2Neil AbeysingheJohn KellyMansoor Bangash3Jaimin Patel4David RiddingtonTomasz TorlinskiNicholas TalbotTonny Veenith5Catherine Snelson6Tony Whitehouse7Carla Richardson8Callum Oakley9Craig Pascoe10Daivd Balthazor11Davinia Bennett12Nandan Gautam13John Isaac14Tracie Matthews15Nick Murphy16Tessa Oelofse17Jeremy Willson18Fiona Wyton19Abby FordAlejandro BarriosAndy JohnstonAnwar ShahBill TunnicliffeBrian PouchetDavid HumeDeborah TurfreyGregory PackerHarjot SinghIan EwingtonKaye EnglandLaura TaskerMav ManjiMike KnowlesMohammed ArshadNilesh ParekhPhillip El-DalilRandeep MullhiRavi ChauhanRavi HebballiRichard BrowneSam DenhamSandeep WaliaShraddha GoyalSteffen KrollSue SinclairTom Clutton-BrockWilliam ToshZahid KhanSingapore Eye Research Institute, Singapore National Eye Center, SingaporeBirmingham Acute Care Research Group, Institute of Inflammation and Ageing, University of Birmingham, Birmingham, UKDepartment of Critical Care and Anaesthesia, Queen Elizabeth Hospital Birmingham, Birmingham, UKBirmingham Acute Care Research Group, Institute of Inflammation and Ageing, University of Birmingham, Birmingham, UKDepartment of Critical Care and Anaesthesia, Queen Elizabeth Hospital Birmingham, Birmingham, UKDepartment of Critical Care and Anaesthesia, Queen Elizabeth Hospital Birmingham, Birmingham, UKDepartment of Critical Care and Anaesthesia, Queen Elizabeth Hospital Birmingham, Birmingham, UKDepartment of Critical Care and Anaesthesia, Queen Elizabeth Hospital Birmingham, Birmingham, UKDepartment of Critical Care and Anaesthesia, Queen Elizabeth Hospital Birmingham, Birmingham, UKDepartment of Critical Care and Anaesthesia, Queen Elizabeth Hospital Birmingham, Birmingham, UKDepartment of Critical Care and Anaesthesia, Queen Elizabeth Hospital Birmingham, Birmingham, UKDepartment of Critical Care and Anaesthesia, Queen Elizabeth Hospital Birmingham, Birmingham, UKDepartment of Critical Care and Anaesthesia, Queen Elizabeth Hospital Birmingham, Birmingham, UKDepartment of Critical Care and Anaesthesia, Queen Elizabeth Hospital Birmingham, Birmingham, UKDepartment of Critical Care and Anaesthesia, Queen Elizabeth Hospital Birmingham, Birmingham, UKDepartment of Critical Care and Anaesthesia, Queen Elizabeth Hospital Birmingham, Birmingham, UKDepartment of Critical Care and Anaesthesia, Queen Elizabeth Hospital Birmingham, Birmingham, UKDepartment of Critical Care and Anaesthesia, Queen Elizabeth Hospital Birmingham, Birmingham, UKDepartment of Critical Care and Anaesthesia, Queen Elizabeth Hospital Birmingham, Birmingham, UKDepartment of Critical Care and Anaesthesia, Queen Elizabeth Hospital Birmingham, Birmingham, UKObjectives To safely expand and adapt the normal workings of a large critical care unit in response to the COVID-19 pandemic.Methods In April 2020, UK health systems were challenged to expand critical care capacity rapidly during the first wave of the COVID-19 pandemic so that they could accommodate patients with respiratory and multiple organ failure. Here, we describe the preparation and adaptive responses of a large critical care unit to the oncoming burden of disease. Our changes were similar to the revolution in manufacturing brought about by ‘Long Shops’ of 1853 when Richard Garrett and Sons of Leiston started mass manufacture of traction engines. This innovation broke the whole process into smaller parts and increased productivity. When applied to COVID-19 preparations, an assembly line approach had the advantage that our ICU became easily scalable to manage an influx of additional staff as well as the increase in admissions. Healthcare professionals could be replaced in case of absence and training focused on a smaller number of tasks.Results Compared with the equivalent period in 2019, the ICU provided 30.9% more patient days (2599 to 3402), 1845 of which were ventilated days (compared with 694 in 2019, 165.8% increase) while time from first referral to ICU admission reduced from 193.8±123.8 min (±SD) to 110.7±76.75 min (±SD). Throughout, ICU maintained adequate capacity and also accepted patients from neighbouring hospitals. This was done by managing an additional 205 doctors (70% increase), 168 nurses who had previously worked in ICU and another 261 nurses deployed from other parts of the hospital (82% increase).Our large tertiary hospital ensured a dedicated non-COVID ICU was staffed and equipped to take regional emergency referrals so that those patients requiring specialist surgery and treatment were treated throughout the COVID-19 pandemic.Conclusions We report how the challenge of managing a huge influx of patients and redeployed staff was met by deconstructing ICU care into its constituent parts. Although reported from the largest colocated ICU in the UK, we believe that this offers solutions to ICUs of all sizes and may provide a generalisable model for critical care pandemic surge planning.https://bmjopenquality.bmj.com/content/9/4/e001117.full |