A Simple Similarity Index for the Comparison of Remotely Sensed Time Series with Scarce Simultaneous Acquisitions

Emergence of new state-of-the-art technologies has enabled an unprecedented amount of high spatial resolution satellite data having great potential for exploitation of extracted time series for a vast range of applications. Despite the high temporal resolution of time series, the number of real obse...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Dominique Fasbender, Blanka Vajsová, Csaba Wirnhardt, Slavko Lemajic
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: MDPI AG 2019-06-01
Series:Remote Sensing
Subjects:
CAP
Online Access:https://www.mdpi.com/2072-4292/11/13/1527
id doaj-bd446562877741fcb4ba8f7569750f22
record_format Article
spelling doaj-bd446562877741fcb4ba8f7569750f222020-11-25T00:22:23ZengMDPI AGRemote Sensing2072-42922019-06-011113152710.3390/rs11131527rs11131527A Simple Similarity Index for the Comparison of Remotely Sensed Time Series with Scarce Simultaneous AcquisitionsDominique Fasbender0Blanka Vajsová1Csaba Wirnhardt2Slavko Lemajic3European Commission, Joint Research Centre (JRC), Via E. Fermi 2749, I-21027 Ispra, ItalyPiksel S.r.l., Via Ernesto Breda 176, 20126 Milan, ItalyEuropean Commission, Joint Research Centre (JRC), Via E. Fermi 2749, I-21027 Ispra, ItalySlavko Lemajic, Obkirchergasse 5/14, 1190 Vienna, AustriaEmergence of new state-of-the-art technologies has enabled an unprecedented amount of high spatial resolution satellite data having great potential for exploitation of extracted time series for a vast range of applications. Despite the high temporal resolution of time series, the number of real observations of optical data that can be utilized is reduced due to meteorological conditions (such as cloud or haze) prevailing at the time of acquisition. This fact has an effect on the density of the retrieved time series and subsequently on a number of coincidental observations when comparing the similarity of time series from two different data sources for which the simultaneous acquisition date is already scarce. Classical tools for assessing the similarity of such time series can prove to be difficult or even impossible because of a lack of simultaneous observations. In this paper, we propose a simple method in order to circumvent this scarcity issue. In the first step, we rely on an interpolation in order to produce artificial time series on the union of the original acquisition dates. Then, we extend the theory of the correlation coefficient (CC) estimator to these interpolated time series. After validation on synthetic data, this simple approach proved to be extremely efficient on a real case study where Sentinel-2 and PlanetScope NDVI time series on parcels in The Netherlands are compared. Indeed, compared to other methods, it reduced the number of undecided cases while also improving the power of the statistical test on the similarity between both types of time series and the precision of the estimated CC.https://www.mdpi.com/2072-4292/11/13/1527scarce time seriesagricultureenvironmentmonitoringCAPPlanetScopeSentinel-2JEODPPEarth Observationinterpolation
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Dominique Fasbender
Blanka Vajsová
Csaba Wirnhardt
Slavko Lemajic
spellingShingle Dominique Fasbender
Blanka Vajsová
Csaba Wirnhardt
Slavko Lemajic
A Simple Similarity Index for the Comparison of Remotely Sensed Time Series with Scarce Simultaneous Acquisitions
Remote Sensing
scarce time series
agriculture
environment
monitoring
CAP
PlanetScope
Sentinel-2
JEODPP
Earth Observation
interpolation
author_facet Dominique Fasbender
Blanka Vajsová
Csaba Wirnhardt
Slavko Lemajic
author_sort Dominique Fasbender
title A Simple Similarity Index for the Comparison of Remotely Sensed Time Series with Scarce Simultaneous Acquisitions
title_short A Simple Similarity Index for the Comparison of Remotely Sensed Time Series with Scarce Simultaneous Acquisitions
title_full A Simple Similarity Index for the Comparison of Remotely Sensed Time Series with Scarce Simultaneous Acquisitions
title_fullStr A Simple Similarity Index for the Comparison of Remotely Sensed Time Series with Scarce Simultaneous Acquisitions
title_full_unstemmed A Simple Similarity Index for the Comparison of Remotely Sensed Time Series with Scarce Simultaneous Acquisitions
title_sort simple similarity index for the comparison of remotely sensed time series with scarce simultaneous acquisitions
publisher MDPI AG
series Remote Sensing
issn 2072-4292
publishDate 2019-06-01
description Emergence of new state-of-the-art technologies has enabled an unprecedented amount of high spatial resolution satellite data having great potential for exploitation of extracted time series for a vast range of applications. Despite the high temporal resolution of time series, the number of real observations of optical data that can be utilized is reduced due to meteorological conditions (such as cloud or haze) prevailing at the time of acquisition. This fact has an effect on the density of the retrieved time series and subsequently on a number of coincidental observations when comparing the similarity of time series from two different data sources for which the simultaneous acquisition date is already scarce. Classical tools for assessing the similarity of such time series can prove to be difficult or even impossible because of a lack of simultaneous observations. In this paper, we propose a simple method in order to circumvent this scarcity issue. In the first step, we rely on an interpolation in order to produce artificial time series on the union of the original acquisition dates. Then, we extend the theory of the correlation coefficient (CC) estimator to these interpolated time series. After validation on synthetic data, this simple approach proved to be extremely efficient on a real case study where Sentinel-2 and PlanetScope NDVI time series on parcels in The Netherlands are compared. Indeed, compared to other methods, it reduced the number of undecided cases while also improving the power of the statistical test on the similarity between both types of time series and the precision of the estimated CC.
topic scarce time series
agriculture
environment
monitoring
CAP
PlanetScope
Sentinel-2
JEODPP
Earth Observation
interpolation
url https://www.mdpi.com/2072-4292/11/13/1527
work_keys_str_mv AT dominiquefasbender asimplesimilarityindexforthecomparisonofremotelysensedtimeserieswithscarcesimultaneousacquisitions
AT blankavajsova asimplesimilarityindexforthecomparisonofremotelysensedtimeserieswithscarcesimultaneousacquisitions
AT csabawirnhardt asimplesimilarityindexforthecomparisonofremotelysensedtimeserieswithscarcesimultaneousacquisitions
AT slavkolemajic asimplesimilarityindexforthecomparisonofremotelysensedtimeserieswithscarcesimultaneousacquisitions
AT dominiquefasbender simplesimilarityindexforthecomparisonofremotelysensedtimeserieswithscarcesimultaneousacquisitions
AT blankavajsova simplesimilarityindexforthecomparisonofremotelysensedtimeserieswithscarcesimultaneousacquisitions
AT csabawirnhardt simplesimilarityindexforthecomparisonofremotelysensedtimeserieswithscarcesimultaneousacquisitions
AT slavkolemajic simplesimilarityindexforthecomparisonofremotelysensedtimeserieswithscarcesimultaneousacquisitions
_version_ 1725360063748505600