Composted Municipal Green Waste Enhances Tree Success in Opencast Coal Land Reclamation in Wales

The United Kingdom has a problem in the disposal of municipal green waste (MGW). This is unsuitable for landfill, but when properly composted may be beneficial to tree growth. A formal controlled trial of the 11-year growth (height, diameter at breast height [DBH]) and survival of 3 tree species was...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Martin Haigh, Mansi Desai, Mike Cullis, Margaret D’Aucourt, Ben Sansom, Gill Wilding, Elanor Alun, Sergio Garate, Liz Hatton, Marianne Kilmartin, Wilhemina Panhuis, Rhian Jenkins
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: SAGE Publishing 2019-09-01
Series:Air, Soil and Water Research
Online Access:https://doi.org/10.1177/1178622119877837
id doaj-b699f70420824cc9a144c8bcfba10c80
record_format Article
spelling doaj-b699f70420824cc9a144c8bcfba10c802020-11-25T03:36:21ZengSAGE PublishingAir, Soil and Water Research1178-62212019-09-011210.1177/1178622119877837Composted Municipal Green Waste Enhances Tree Success in Opencast Coal Land Reclamation in WalesMartin Haigh0Mansi Desai1Mike Cullis2Margaret D’Aucourt3Ben Sansom4Gill Wilding5Elanor Alun6Sergio Garate7Liz Hatton8Marianne Kilmartin9Wilhemina Panhuis10Rhian Jenkins11Cradlefornature.org, Witney, UKDepartment of Social Sciences, Oxford Brookes University, Oxford, UKSchool of Architecture, Built and Natural Environments, University of Wales Trinity Saint David, Swansea, UKCradlefornature.org, Witney, UKArctium Ltd., Haywards Heath, UKCradlefornature.org, Witney, UKSchool of Architecture, Built and Natural Environments, University of Wales Trinity Saint David, Swansea, UKSchool of Architecture, Built and Natural Environments, University of Wales Trinity Saint David, Swansea, UKCradlefornature.org, Witney, UKCradlefornature.org, Witney, UKCradlefornature.org, Witney, UKSchool of Architecture, Built and Natural Environments, University of Wales Trinity Saint David, Swansea, UKThe United Kingdom has a problem in the disposal of municipal green waste (MGW). This is unsuitable for landfill, but when properly composted may be beneficial to tree growth. A formal controlled trial of the 11-year growth (height, diameter at breast height [DBH]) and survival of 3 tree species was evaluated on degraded former opencast coal land on the margins of UNESCO’s Blaenavon Industrial Landscape World Heritage site in South East Wales. Forest reclamation is considered a viable cost-effective approach to reclamation but success may be compromised by infertile and seriously compacted substrates, the depleted bio-geoecological system, and a lack of funding. In this trial, trees were (or were not) supplied, on planting, with 0.75 kg per stem of composted MGW – here a mixture of 40% domestic food waste and 60% garden waste. Results show that the application of MGW made no significant difference to either tree height or DBH. Survival rates were highest for Common Alder ( Alnus glutinosa (L.) Gaertn.) followed by Silver Birch ( Betula pendula , Roth) and European Larch ( Larix decidua Mill.). However, Silver Birch and Larch treated with MGW compost had significantly greater survival rates, whereas Alder had significantly lower survival rates, compared with trees planted without MGW treatment.https://doi.org/10.1177/1178622119877837
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Martin Haigh
Mansi Desai
Mike Cullis
Margaret D’Aucourt
Ben Sansom
Gill Wilding
Elanor Alun
Sergio Garate
Liz Hatton
Marianne Kilmartin
Wilhemina Panhuis
Rhian Jenkins
spellingShingle Martin Haigh
Mansi Desai
Mike Cullis
Margaret D’Aucourt
Ben Sansom
Gill Wilding
Elanor Alun
Sergio Garate
Liz Hatton
Marianne Kilmartin
Wilhemina Panhuis
Rhian Jenkins
Composted Municipal Green Waste Enhances Tree Success in Opencast Coal Land Reclamation in Wales
Air, Soil and Water Research
author_facet Martin Haigh
Mansi Desai
Mike Cullis
Margaret D’Aucourt
Ben Sansom
Gill Wilding
Elanor Alun
Sergio Garate
Liz Hatton
Marianne Kilmartin
Wilhemina Panhuis
Rhian Jenkins
author_sort Martin Haigh
title Composted Municipal Green Waste Enhances Tree Success in Opencast Coal Land Reclamation in Wales
title_short Composted Municipal Green Waste Enhances Tree Success in Opencast Coal Land Reclamation in Wales
title_full Composted Municipal Green Waste Enhances Tree Success in Opencast Coal Land Reclamation in Wales
title_fullStr Composted Municipal Green Waste Enhances Tree Success in Opencast Coal Land Reclamation in Wales
title_full_unstemmed Composted Municipal Green Waste Enhances Tree Success in Opencast Coal Land Reclamation in Wales
title_sort composted municipal green waste enhances tree success in opencast coal land reclamation in wales
publisher SAGE Publishing
series Air, Soil and Water Research
issn 1178-6221
publishDate 2019-09-01
description The United Kingdom has a problem in the disposal of municipal green waste (MGW). This is unsuitable for landfill, but when properly composted may be beneficial to tree growth. A formal controlled trial of the 11-year growth (height, diameter at breast height [DBH]) and survival of 3 tree species was evaluated on degraded former opencast coal land on the margins of UNESCO’s Blaenavon Industrial Landscape World Heritage site in South East Wales. Forest reclamation is considered a viable cost-effective approach to reclamation but success may be compromised by infertile and seriously compacted substrates, the depleted bio-geoecological system, and a lack of funding. In this trial, trees were (or were not) supplied, on planting, with 0.75 kg per stem of composted MGW – here a mixture of 40% domestic food waste and 60% garden waste. Results show that the application of MGW made no significant difference to either tree height or DBH. Survival rates were highest for Common Alder ( Alnus glutinosa (L.) Gaertn.) followed by Silver Birch ( Betula pendula , Roth) and European Larch ( Larix decidua Mill.). However, Silver Birch and Larch treated with MGW compost had significantly greater survival rates, whereas Alder had significantly lower survival rates, compared with trees planted without MGW treatment.
url https://doi.org/10.1177/1178622119877837
work_keys_str_mv AT martinhaigh compostedmunicipalgreenwasteenhancestreesuccessinopencastcoallandreclamationinwales
AT mansidesai compostedmunicipalgreenwasteenhancestreesuccessinopencastcoallandreclamationinwales
AT mikecullis compostedmunicipalgreenwasteenhancestreesuccessinopencastcoallandreclamationinwales
AT margaretdaucourt compostedmunicipalgreenwasteenhancestreesuccessinopencastcoallandreclamationinwales
AT bensansom compostedmunicipalgreenwasteenhancestreesuccessinopencastcoallandreclamationinwales
AT gillwilding compostedmunicipalgreenwasteenhancestreesuccessinopencastcoallandreclamationinwales
AT elanoralun compostedmunicipalgreenwasteenhancestreesuccessinopencastcoallandreclamationinwales
AT sergiogarate compostedmunicipalgreenwasteenhancestreesuccessinopencastcoallandreclamationinwales
AT lizhatton compostedmunicipalgreenwasteenhancestreesuccessinopencastcoallandreclamationinwales
AT mariannekilmartin compostedmunicipalgreenwasteenhancestreesuccessinopencastcoallandreclamationinwales
AT wilheminapanhuis compostedmunicipalgreenwasteenhancestreesuccessinopencastcoallandreclamationinwales
AT rhianjenkins compostedmunicipalgreenwasteenhancestreesuccessinopencastcoallandreclamationinwales
_version_ 1724550406276644864