A comparison of dose distributions in gross tumor volume between boron neutron capture therapy alone and combined boron neutron capture therapy plus intensity modulation radiation therapy for head and neck cancer.

Nine patients with recurrent head and neck (H&N) cancer received boron neutron capture therapy (BNCT) in one fraction at the Tsing-Hua Open pool reactor (THOR) utilizing the THORplan treatment planning system (TPS). The aims of the present study were to evaluate the use of intensity modulated ra...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Jia-Cheng Lee, Keh-Shih Chuang, Yen-Wan Hsueh Liu, Tzung-Yi Lin, Yi-Chiao Teng, Ling-Wei Wang
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Public Library of Science (PLoS) 2019-01-01
Series:PLoS ONE
Online Access:https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0210626
id doaj-b04fcc17e91f4c33a1d8a07515cc938d
record_format Article
spelling doaj-b04fcc17e91f4c33a1d8a07515cc938d2021-03-03T20:45:43ZengPublic Library of Science (PLoS)PLoS ONE1932-62032019-01-01144e021062610.1371/journal.pone.0210626A comparison of dose distributions in gross tumor volume between boron neutron capture therapy alone and combined boron neutron capture therapy plus intensity modulation radiation therapy for head and neck cancer.Jia-Cheng LeeKeh-Shih ChuangYen-Wan Hsueh LiuTzung-Yi LinYi-Chiao TengLing-Wei WangNine patients with recurrent head and neck (H&N) cancer received boron neutron capture therapy (BNCT) in one fraction at the Tsing-Hua Open pool reactor (THOR) utilizing the THORplan treatment planning system (TPS). The aims of the present study were to evaluate the use of intensity modulated radiation therapy (IMRT) of 45 Gy in 20 fractions to compensate for the dose heterogeneity in gross tumor volume observed with single-fraction BNCT with mean prescription dose 19 Gy (w), and to evaluate planning quality indices of simulated BNCT+IMRT versus single-fraction BNCT alone. All IMRT plans were generated using the Eclipse TPS which employs the analytical anisotropic algorithm. The conformity index for the gross tumor volume (GTV) was better for the BNCT+IMRT plan than for the BNCT-alone plan (p = 0.003). In addition, the BNCT+IMRT plan provided significantly better homogeneity in the GTV (p = 0.03). The cold spots in inhomogeneous dose distribution in the BNCT plan may be a key factor for H&N cancer recurrence. Our results suggest that single-fraction BNCT combined with compensated multi-fraction IMRT improves treatment homogeneity and conformity than single-fraction BNCT alone, especially for tumor volumes >100 cm3, and possibly increases local tumor control.https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0210626
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Jia-Cheng Lee
Keh-Shih Chuang
Yen-Wan Hsueh Liu
Tzung-Yi Lin
Yi-Chiao Teng
Ling-Wei Wang
spellingShingle Jia-Cheng Lee
Keh-Shih Chuang
Yen-Wan Hsueh Liu
Tzung-Yi Lin
Yi-Chiao Teng
Ling-Wei Wang
A comparison of dose distributions in gross tumor volume between boron neutron capture therapy alone and combined boron neutron capture therapy plus intensity modulation radiation therapy for head and neck cancer.
PLoS ONE
author_facet Jia-Cheng Lee
Keh-Shih Chuang
Yen-Wan Hsueh Liu
Tzung-Yi Lin
Yi-Chiao Teng
Ling-Wei Wang
author_sort Jia-Cheng Lee
title A comparison of dose distributions in gross tumor volume between boron neutron capture therapy alone and combined boron neutron capture therapy plus intensity modulation radiation therapy for head and neck cancer.
title_short A comparison of dose distributions in gross tumor volume between boron neutron capture therapy alone and combined boron neutron capture therapy plus intensity modulation radiation therapy for head and neck cancer.
title_full A comparison of dose distributions in gross tumor volume between boron neutron capture therapy alone and combined boron neutron capture therapy plus intensity modulation radiation therapy for head and neck cancer.
title_fullStr A comparison of dose distributions in gross tumor volume between boron neutron capture therapy alone and combined boron neutron capture therapy plus intensity modulation radiation therapy for head and neck cancer.
title_full_unstemmed A comparison of dose distributions in gross tumor volume between boron neutron capture therapy alone and combined boron neutron capture therapy plus intensity modulation radiation therapy for head and neck cancer.
title_sort comparison of dose distributions in gross tumor volume between boron neutron capture therapy alone and combined boron neutron capture therapy plus intensity modulation radiation therapy for head and neck cancer.
publisher Public Library of Science (PLoS)
series PLoS ONE
issn 1932-6203
publishDate 2019-01-01
description Nine patients with recurrent head and neck (H&N) cancer received boron neutron capture therapy (BNCT) in one fraction at the Tsing-Hua Open pool reactor (THOR) utilizing the THORplan treatment planning system (TPS). The aims of the present study were to evaluate the use of intensity modulated radiation therapy (IMRT) of 45 Gy in 20 fractions to compensate for the dose heterogeneity in gross tumor volume observed with single-fraction BNCT with mean prescription dose 19 Gy (w), and to evaluate planning quality indices of simulated BNCT+IMRT versus single-fraction BNCT alone. All IMRT plans were generated using the Eclipse TPS which employs the analytical anisotropic algorithm. The conformity index for the gross tumor volume (GTV) was better for the BNCT+IMRT plan than for the BNCT-alone plan (p = 0.003). In addition, the BNCT+IMRT plan provided significantly better homogeneity in the GTV (p = 0.03). The cold spots in inhomogeneous dose distribution in the BNCT plan may be a key factor for H&N cancer recurrence. Our results suggest that single-fraction BNCT combined with compensated multi-fraction IMRT improves treatment homogeneity and conformity than single-fraction BNCT alone, especially for tumor volumes >100 cm3, and possibly increases local tumor control.
url https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0210626
work_keys_str_mv AT jiachenglee acomparisonofdosedistributionsingrosstumorvolumebetweenboronneutroncapturetherapyaloneandcombinedboronneutroncapturetherapyplusintensitymodulationradiationtherapyforheadandneckcancer
AT kehshihchuang acomparisonofdosedistributionsingrosstumorvolumebetweenboronneutroncapturetherapyaloneandcombinedboronneutroncapturetherapyplusintensitymodulationradiationtherapyforheadandneckcancer
AT yenwanhsuehliu acomparisonofdosedistributionsingrosstumorvolumebetweenboronneutroncapturetherapyaloneandcombinedboronneutroncapturetherapyplusintensitymodulationradiationtherapyforheadandneckcancer
AT tzungyilin acomparisonofdosedistributionsingrosstumorvolumebetweenboronneutroncapturetherapyaloneandcombinedboronneutroncapturetherapyplusintensitymodulationradiationtherapyforheadandneckcancer
AT yichiaoteng acomparisonofdosedistributionsingrosstumorvolumebetweenboronneutroncapturetherapyaloneandcombinedboronneutroncapturetherapyplusintensitymodulationradiationtherapyforheadandneckcancer
AT lingweiwang acomparisonofdosedistributionsingrosstumorvolumebetweenboronneutroncapturetherapyaloneandcombinedboronneutroncapturetherapyplusintensitymodulationradiationtherapyforheadandneckcancer
AT jiachenglee comparisonofdosedistributionsingrosstumorvolumebetweenboronneutroncapturetherapyaloneandcombinedboronneutroncapturetherapyplusintensitymodulationradiationtherapyforheadandneckcancer
AT kehshihchuang comparisonofdosedistributionsingrosstumorvolumebetweenboronneutroncapturetherapyaloneandcombinedboronneutroncapturetherapyplusintensitymodulationradiationtherapyforheadandneckcancer
AT yenwanhsuehliu comparisonofdosedistributionsingrosstumorvolumebetweenboronneutroncapturetherapyaloneandcombinedboronneutroncapturetherapyplusintensitymodulationradiationtherapyforheadandneckcancer
AT tzungyilin comparisonofdosedistributionsingrosstumorvolumebetweenboronneutroncapturetherapyaloneandcombinedboronneutroncapturetherapyplusintensitymodulationradiationtherapyforheadandneckcancer
AT yichiaoteng comparisonofdosedistributionsingrosstumorvolumebetweenboronneutroncapturetherapyaloneandcombinedboronneutroncapturetherapyplusintensitymodulationradiationtherapyforheadandneckcancer
AT lingweiwang comparisonofdosedistributionsingrosstumorvolumebetweenboronneutroncapturetherapyaloneandcombinedboronneutroncapturetherapyplusintensitymodulationradiationtherapyforheadandneckcancer
_version_ 1714820806169591808