The comparison of the effect of traditional and off-line electronic educational methods on the knowledge and attitude of the undergraduate dental students of Shiraz University of Medical Sciences

Introduction: E-learning as one of the new methods of learning makes it possible to achieve skills at higher levels without time and space constraints. The purpose of this research was to compare the effect of case-based learning in two ways of personal and off-line (forum) E-learning on the knowled...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Sara Karanjam, Farin Kiany Yazdi, Nahid Zarifsanaiey
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Shiraz University of Medical Sciences 2015-09-01
Series:Interdisciplinary Journal of Virtual Learning in Medical Sciences
Subjects:
Online Access:https://ijvlms.sums.ac.ir/article_46150_4adae0dbd8105e0a80d7bb1cb5344332.pdf
id doaj-ae9fd7096d5546438c8328794b1d3565
record_format Article
spelling doaj-ae9fd7096d5546438c8328794b1d35652021-04-18T04:17:54ZengShiraz University of Medical SciencesInterdisciplinary Journal of Virtual Learning in Medical Sciences2476-72632476-72712015-09-0163203046150The comparison of the effect of traditional and off-line electronic educational methods on the knowledge and attitude of the undergraduate dental students of Shiraz University of Medical SciencesSara Karanjam0Farin Kiany Yazdi1Nahid Zarifsanaiey2M.Sc. Medical, Education Shiraz University of Medical Sciences, Shiraz, IranAssistant professor of periodontology department of Periodontics, School of Dentistry, Shiraz University of Medical Sciences, Shiraz, IranAssociate Professor and Head of Department of eLearning planning in Medical Sciences Center of excellence for electronic learning Shiraz University of medical sciences Shiraz, Iran.Introduction: E-learning as one of the new methods of learning makes it possible to achieve skills at higher levels without time and space constraints. The purpose of this research was to compare the effect of case-based learning in two ways of personal and off-line (forum) E-learning on the knowledge and attitudes of undergraduate medical students of Shiraz University of Medical Sciences.Methods: This is a semi-experimental research, which was conducted on 44 dental students in the academic year of 2014. Sampling was a block randomizing. Both groups were given written exams before and after teaching in order to evaluate the participants’ awareness and knowledge of the content, the satisfaction level and attitudes of both groups were questioned by the application of an exam following the Likert scale format of 1-5. In this study, a paired samples t-test was used for comparing students’ pretest and posttest scores in each group, and an independent samples t-test was run for comparing the changes in scores, students’ attitudes, and satisfaction in both groups. In case of derivation from the normal distribution hypothesis, non-parametric equivalents were used in these tests. The acceptable significant level was α=0.05.Results: The mean score of primary awareness in both groups of personal and E-learning was statistically the same (p=0.647). A significant increase was observed in the awareness level of people after the application of learning (p < 0.001). The awareness of people in personal and E-learning groups before learning (median=2) was significantly increased compared to that after learning (personal: median=5 and electronic: median=6). The increase of awareness in personal and E-learning groups was statistically the same (p=0.216). Generally, the increase of awareness level was similar in women and men (p=0.822). There was not a significant relationship between people’s attitude with the learning method and age of the participants. Conclusion: Given that the learning and attitudes of students in off-line (forum) E-learning and personal learning was the same, and regarding the effectiveness of E-learning in time reduction and saving of costs and educational facilities, this new method can be used as a part of learning activities in medical learning program.https://ijvlms.sums.ac.ir/article_46150_4adae0dbd8105e0a80d7bb1cb5344332.pdfcase based learningpersonal learningoff-line (forum) e-learningknowledgeattitudes
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Sara Karanjam
Farin Kiany Yazdi
Nahid Zarifsanaiey
spellingShingle Sara Karanjam
Farin Kiany Yazdi
Nahid Zarifsanaiey
The comparison of the effect of traditional and off-line electronic educational methods on the knowledge and attitude of the undergraduate dental students of Shiraz University of Medical Sciences
Interdisciplinary Journal of Virtual Learning in Medical Sciences
case based learning
personal learning
off-line (forum) e-learning
knowledge
attitudes
author_facet Sara Karanjam
Farin Kiany Yazdi
Nahid Zarifsanaiey
author_sort Sara Karanjam
title The comparison of the effect of traditional and off-line electronic educational methods on the knowledge and attitude of the undergraduate dental students of Shiraz University of Medical Sciences
title_short The comparison of the effect of traditional and off-line electronic educational methods on the knowledge and attitude of the undergraduate dental students of Shiraz University of Medical Sciences
title_full The comparison of the effect of traditional and off-line electronic educational methods on the knowledge and attitude of the undergraduate dental students of Shiraz University of Medical Sciences
title_fullStr The comparison of the effect of traditional and off-line electronic educational methods on the knowledge and attitude of the undergraduate dental students of Shiraz University of Medical Sciences
title_full_unstemmed The comparison of the effect of traditional and off-line electronic educational methods on the knowledge and attitude of the undergraduate dental students of Shiraz University of Medical Sciences
title_sort comparison of the effect of traditional and off-line electronic educational methods on the knowledge and attitude of the undergraduate dental students of shiraz university of medical sciences
publisher Shiraz University of Medical Sciences
series Interdisciplinary Journal of Virtual Learning in Medical Sciences
issn 2476-7263
2476-7271
publishDate 2015-09-01
description Introduction: E-learning as one of the new methods of learning makes it possible to achieve skills at higher levels without time and space constraints. The purpose of this research was to compare the effect of case-based learning in two ways of personal and off-line (forum) E-learning on the knowledge and attitudes of undergraduate medical students of Shiraz University of Medical Sciences.Methods: This is a semi-experimental research, which was conducted on 44 dental students in the academic year of 2014. Sampling was a block randomizing. Both groups were given written exams before and after teaching in order to evaluate the participants’ awareness and knowledge of the content, the satisfaction level and attitudes of both groups were questioned by the application of an exam following the Likert scale format of 1-5. In this study, a paired samples t-test was used for comparing students’ pretest and posttest scores in each group, and an independent samples t-test was run for comparing the changes in scores, students’ attitudes, and satisfaction in both groups. In case of derivation from the normal distribution hypothesis, non-parametric equivalents were used in these tests. The acceptable significant level was α=0.05.Results: The mean score of primary awareness in both groups of personal and E-learning was statistically the same (p=0.647). A significant increase was observed in the awareness level of people after the application of learning (p < 0.001). The awareness of people in personal and E-learning groups before learning (median=2) was significantly increased compared to that after learning (personal: median=5 and electronic: median=6). The increase of awareness in personal and E-learning groups was statistically the same (p=0.216). Generally, the increase of awareness level was similar in women and men (p=0.822). There was not a significant relationship between people’s attitude with the learning method and age of the participants. Conclusion: Given that the learning and attitudes of students in off-line (forum) E-learning and personal learning was the same, and regarding the effectiveness of E-learning in time reduction and saving of costs and educational facilities, this new method can be used as a part of learning activities in medical learning program.
topic case based learning
personal learning
off-line (forum) e-learning
knowledge
attitudes
url https://ijvlms.sums.ac.ir/article_46150_4adae0dbd8105e0a80d7bb1cb5344332.pdf
work_keys_str_mv AT sarakaranjam thecomparisonoftheeffectoftraditionalandofflineelectroniceducationalmethodsontheknowledgeandattitudeoftheundergraduatedentalstudentsofshirazuniversityofmedicalsciences
AT farinkianyyazdi thecomparisonoftheeffectoftraditionalandofflineelectroniceducationalmethodsontheknowledgeandattitudeoftheundergraduatedentalstudentsofshirazuniversityofmedicalsciences
AT nahidzarifsanaiey thecomparisonoftheeffectoftraditionalandofflineelectroniceducationalmethodsontheknowledgeandattitudeoftheundergraduatedentalstudentsofshirazuniversityofmedicalsciences
AT sarakaranjam comparisonoftheeffectoftraditionalandofflineelectroniceducationalmethodsontheknowledgeandattitudeoftheundergraduatedentalstudentsofshirazuniversityofmedicalsciences
AT farinkianyyazdi comparisonoftheeffectoftraditionalandofflineelectroniceducationalmethodsontheknowledgeandattitudeoftheundergraduatedentalstudentsofshirazuniversityofmedicalsciences
AT nahidzarifsanaiey comparisonoftheeffectoftraditionalandofflineelectroniceducationalmethodsontheknowledgeandattitudeoftheundergraduatedentalstudentsofshirazuniversityofmedicalsciences
_version_ 1721523535387557888