Modelling the Influence of Soil Properties on Crop Yields Using a Non-Linear NFIR Model and Laboratory Data

This paper introduces a new non-linear correlation analysis method based on a non-linear finite impulse response (NFIR) model to study and quantify the effects of ten soil properties on crop yield. Two versions of the NFIR model were implemented: NFIR-LN, accounting for both the linear and non-linea...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Rebecca L. Whetton, Yifan Zhao, Said Nawar, Abdul M. Mouazen
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: MDPI AG 2021-02-01
Series:Soil Systems
Subjects:
Online Access:https://www.mdpi.com/2571-8789/5/1/12
id doaj-ae3496f3cceb4ddd8d6526850b3a84fa
record_format Article
spelling doaj-ae3496f3cceb4ddd8d6526850b3a84fa2021-02-17T00:02:05ZengMDPI AGSoil Systems2571-87892021-02-015121210.3390/soilsystems5010012Modelling the Influence of Soil Properties on Crop Yields Using a Non-Linear NFIR Model and Laboratory DataRebecca L. Whetton0Yifan Zhao1Said Nawar2Abdul M. Mouazen3Biosystems Engineering, University College Dublin, Dublin, D04 V1W8, IrelandThrough-Life Engineering Services Institute, Cranfield University, Bedford MK43 0AL, UKSoil and Water Department, Faculty of Agriculture, Suez Canal University, Ismailia 41522, EgyptDepartment of Environment, Faculty of Bioscience Engineering, Ghent University, Coupure Links 653, 9000 Ghent, BelgiumThis paper introduces a new non-linear correlation analysis method based on a non-linear finite impulse response (NFIR) model to study and quantify the effects of ten soil properties on crop yield. Two versions of the NFIR model were implemented: NFIR-LN, accounting for both the linear and non-linear variability in the system, and NFIR-L, accounting for linear variability only. The performance of the NFIR models was compared with a non-linear random forest (RF) model, to predict oilseed rape (2013) and wheat (2014) yields in one field at Premslin, Germany. The ten soil properties were used as system inputs, whereas crop yield was the system output. Results demonstrated that the individual and total contribution of the soil properties on crop yield varied throughout the different cropping seasons, weather conditions, and crops. Both the NFIR-LN and RF models outperformed the NFIR-L model and explained up to 55.62% and 50.66% of the yield variation for years 2013 and 2014, respectively. The NFIR-LN and RF models performed equally during yield prediction, although the NFIR-LN model provided more consistent results through the two cropping seasons. Higher phosphorus and potassium contributions to the yield were calculated with the NFIR-LN model, suggesting this method outperforms the RF model.https://www.mdpi.com/2571-8789/5/1/12yield predictionyield limiting factorssoil fertilityrandom forestsystem identification
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Rebecca L. Whetton
Yifan Zhao
Said Nawar
Abdul M. Mouazen
spellingShingle Rebecca L. Whetton
Yifan Zhao
Said Nawar
Abdul M. Mouazen
Modelling the Influence of Soil Properties on Crop Yields Using a Non-Linear NFIR Model and Laboratory Data
Soil Systems
yield prediction
yield limiting factors
soil fertility
random forest
system identification
author_facet Rebecca L. Whetton
Yifan Zhao
Said Nawar
Abdul M. Mouazen
author_sort Rebecca L. Whetton
title Modelling the Influence of Soil Properties on Crop Yields Using a Non-Linear NFIR Model and Laboratory Data
title_short Modelling the Influence of Soil Properties on Crop Yields Using a Non-Linear NFIR Model and Laboratory Data
title_full Modelling the Influence of Soil Properties on Crop Yields Using a Non-Linear NFIR Model and Laboratory Data
title_fullStr Modelling the Influence of Soil Properties on Crop Yields Using a Non-Linear NFIR Model and Laboratory Data
title_full_unstemmed Modelling the Influence of Soil Properties on Crop Yields Using a Non-Linear NFIR Model and Laboratory Data
title_sort modelling the influence of soil properties on crop yields using a non-linear nfir model and laboratory data
publisher MDPI AG
series Soil Systems
issn 2571-8789
publishDate 2021-02-01
description This paper introduces a new non-linear correlation analysis method based on a non-linear finite impulse response (NFIR) model to study and quantify the effects of ten soil properties on crop yield. Two versions of the NFIR model were implemented: NFIR-LN, accounting for both the linear and non-linear variability in the system, and NFIR-L, accounting for linear variability only. The performance of the NFIR models was compared with a non-linear random forest (RF) model, to predict oilseed rape (2013) and wheat (2014) yields in one field at Premslin, Germany. The ten soil properties were used as system inputs, whereas crop yield was the system output. Results demonstrated that the individual and total contribution of the soil properties on crop yield varied throughout the different cropping seasons, weather conditions, and crops. Both the NFIR-LN and RF models outperformed the NFIR-L model and explained up to 55.62% and 50.66% of the yield variation for years 2013 and 2014, respectively. The NFIR-LN and RF models performed equally during yield prediction, although the NFIR-LN model provided more consistent results through the two cropping seasons. Higher phosphorus and potassium contributions to the yield were calculated with the NFIR-LN model, suggesting this method outperforms the RF model.
topic yield prediction
yield limiting factors
soil fertility
random forest
system identification
url https://www.mdpi.com/2571-8789/5/1/12
work_keys_str_mv AT rebeccalwhetton modellingtheinfluenceofsoilpropertiesoncropyieldsusinganonlinearnfirmodelandlaboratorydata
AT yifanzhao modellingtheinfluenceofsoilpropertiesoncropyieldsusinganonlinearnfirmodelandlaboratorydata
AT saidnawar modellingtheinfluenceofsoilpropertiesoncropyieldsusinganonlinearnfirmodelandlaboratorydata
AT abdulmmouazen modellingtheinfluenceofsoilpropertiesoncropyieldsusinganonlinearnfirmodelandlaboratorydata
_version_ 1724265932210044928