Conceptual Approach for Positioning of Fish Guidance Structures Using CFD and Expert Knowledge

The longitudinal connectivity of many rivers is interrupted by man-made barriers preventing the up- and downstream migration of fishes. For example, dams, weirs, and hydropower plants (HPP) are insuperable obstructions for upstream migration if no special measures like fish passes are put into effec...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Linus Feigenwinter, David F. Vetsch, Stephan Kammerer, Carl Robert Kriewitz, Robert M. Boes
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: MDPI AG 2019-03-01
Series:Sustainability
Subjects:
Online Access:http://www.mdpi.com/2071-1050/11/6/1646
id doaj-aac591b00d664865b9c6918c17b1f7a2
record_format Article
spelling doaj-aac591b00d664865b9c6918c17b1f7a22020-11-25T00:32:44ZengMDPI AGSustainability2071-10502019-03-01116164610.3390/su11061646su11061646Conceptual Approach for Positioning of Fish Guidance Structures Using CFD and Expert KnowledgeLinus Feigenwinter0David F. Vetsch1Stephan Kammerer2Carl Robert Kriewitz3Robert M. Boes4Laboratory of Hydraulics, Hydrology and Glaciology, ETH Zurich, 8093 Zurich, SwitzerlandLaboratory of Hydraulics, Hydrology and Glaciology, ETH Zurich, 8093 Zurich, SwitzerlandLaboratory of Hydraulics, Hydrology and Glaciology, ETH Zurich, 8093 Zurich, SwitzerlandBKW Energie AG, BKW Engineering Viktoriaplatz 2, 3013 Bern, SwitzerlandLaboratory of Hydraulics, Hydrology and Glaciology, ETH Zurich, 8093 Zurich, SwitzerlandThe longitudinal connectivity of many rivers is interrupted by man-made barriers preventing the up- and downstream migration of fishes. For example, dams, weirs, and hydropower plants (HPP) are insuperable obstructions for upstream migration if no special measures like fish passes are put into effect. While upstream fishways have been implemented successfully and are still being optimized, the focus of current research is more and more on effective fish protection and guiding devices for downstream migration. According to current knowledge fish guidance structures (FGS) have a high potential in supporting the downstream migration by leading fishes to a bypass as an alternative to turbine passage. This work presents a structured and straightforward approach for the evaluation of potential locations of FGS combining traditional dimensioning principles with computational fluid dynamics (CFD) and novel findings from etho-hydraulic research. The approach is based on three key aspects: fish fauna, structural conditions, and hydraulic conditions, and includes three assessment criteria, which are used in an iterative process to define potential FGS locations. The hydraulic conditions can be investigated by means of hydrodynamic 3D simulations and evaluated at cross sections of potential FGS positions. Considering fundamentals of fish biology and ethology allows for rating of the flow conditions and thus for a suitability assessment of various locations. The advantage of the proposed procedure is the possibility to assess FGS configurations without implementing the FGS in the numerical model, thus limiting the computational expense. Furthermore, the implementation of various operation conditions is straightforward. The conceptual approach is illustrated and discussed by means of a case study.http://www.mdpi.com/2071-1050/11/6/1646fishwaydownstream migrationfish guidance structurenumerical 3D modelOpenFOAM
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Linus Feigenwinter
David F. Vetsch
Stephan Kammerer
Carl Robert Kriewitz
Robert M. Boes
spellingShingle Linus Feigenwinter
David F. Vetsch
Stephan Kammerer
Carl Robert Kriewitz
Robert M. Boes
Conceptual Approach for Positioning of Fish Guidance Structures Using CFD and Expert Knowledge
Sustainability
fishway
downstream migration
fish guidance structure
numerical 3D model
OpenFOAM
author_facet Linus Feigenwinter
David F. Vetsch
Stephan Kammerer
Carl Robert Kriewitz
Robert M. Boes
author_sort Linus Feigenwinter
title Conceptual Approach for Positioning of Fish Guidance Structures Using CFD and Expert Knowledge
title_short Conceptual Approach for Positioning of Fish Guidance Structures Using CFD and Expert Knowledge
title_full Conceptual Approach for Positioning of Fish Guidance Structures Using CFD and Expert Knowledge
title_fullStr Conceptual Approach for Positioning of Fish Guidance Structures Using CFD and Expert Knowledge
title_full_unstemmed Conceptual Approach for Positioning of Fish Guidance Structures Using CFD and Expert Knowledge
title_sort conceptual approach for positioning of fish guidance structures using cfd and expert knowledge
publisher MDPI AG
series Sustainability
issn 2071-1050
publishDate 2019-03-01
description The longitudinal connectivity of many rivers is interrupted by man-made barriers preventing the up- and downstream migration of fishes. For example, dams, weirs, and hydropower plants (HPP) are insuperable obstructions for upstream migration if no special measures like fish passes are put into effect. While upstream fishways have been implemented successfully and are still being optimized, the focus of current research is more and more on effective fish protection and guiding devices for downstream migration. According to current knowledge fish guidance structures (FGS) have a high potential in supporting the downstream migration by leading fishes to a bypass as an alternative to turbine passage. This work presents a structured and straightforward approach for the evaluation of potential locations of FGS combining traditional dimensioning principles with computational fluid dynamics (CFD) and novel findings from etho-hydraulic research. The approach is based on three key aspects: fish fauna, structural conditions, and hydraulic conditions, and includes three assessment criteria, which are used in an iterative process to define potential FGS locations. The hydraulic conditions can be investigated by means of hydrodynamic 3D simulations and evaluated at cross sections of potential FGS positions. Considering fundamentals of fish biology and ethology allows for rating of the flow conditions and thus for a suitability assessment of various locations. The advantage of the proposed procedure is the possibility to assess FGS configurations without implementing the FGS in the numerical model, thus limiting the computational expense. Furthermore, the implementation of various operation conditions is straightforward. The conceptual approach is illustrated and discussed by means of a case study.
topic fishway
downstream migration
fish guidance structure
numerical 3D model
OpenFOAM
url http://www.mdpi.com/2071-1050/11/6/1646
work_keys_str_mv AT linusfeigenwinter conceptualapproachforpositioningoffishguidancestructuresusingcfdandexpertknowledge
AT davidfvetsch conceptualapproachforpositioningoffishguidancestructuresusingcfdandexpertknowledge
AT stephankammerer conceptualapproachforpositioningoffishguidancestructuresusingcfdandexpertknowledge
AT carlrobertkriewitz conceptualapproachforpositioningoffishguidancestructuresusingcfdandexpertknowledge
AT robertmboes conceptualapproachforpositioningoffishguidancestructuresusingcfdandexpertknowledge
_version_ 1725319384788893696