Modalities of treatment for segmental tibia fracture

Background: Segmental tibia fractures (AO 42-C2) are defined by two or more distinct fracture lines isolating an interposed cortical segment which excludes butterfly fragmentation. Severe soft tissue defects are common due to their association with high energy trauma mechanisms of injury. Objectiv...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Prashant Patel, Ketan Kakani, Pratik Prajapati, Viral Prajapat, Sandeep Patil
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Amber Publication 2016-09-01
Series:Journal of Research in Medical and Dental Science
Subjects:
Online Access:https://www.jrmds.in/articles/modalities-of-treatment-for-segmental-tibia-fracture.pdf
id doaj-a71b8ca6a1ff4c61807547c542d7a72e
record_format Article
spelling doaj-a71b8ca6a1ff4c61807547c542d7a72e2020-11-24T21:04:51ZengAmber PublicationJournal of Research in Medical and Dental Science2347-25452347-23672016-09-0143233236Modalities of treatment for segmental tibia fracturePrashant Patel0Ketan Kakani1Pratik Prajapati2Viral Prajapat3 Sandeep Patil41Orthopedic department, Shri M.P.Shah Government medical college, Jamnagar. Gujarat, India1Orthopedic department, Shri M.P.Shah Government medical college, Jamnagar. Gujarat, India1Orthopedic department, Shri M.P.Shah Government medical college, Jamnagar. Gujarat, India1Orthopedic department, Shri M.P.Shah Government medical college, Jamnagar. Gujarat, India1Orthopedic department, Shri M.P.Shah Government medical college, Jamnagar. Gujarat, IndiaBackground: Segmental tibia fractures (AO 42-C2) are defined by two or more distinct fracture lines isolating an interposed cortical segment which excludes butterfly fragmentation. Severe soft tissue defects are common due to their association with high energy trauma mechanisms of injury. Objectives: This study is an attempt to observe the various outcome of operative management of segmental tibia fracture treated by various modalities like intramedullary nailing, plating and external fixator. The results have been studied in depth to determine which modality is better for management of this type of fracture. Material & Methods: This is a prospective study of 25 cases of segmental tibia fracture treated by intra medullary nailing or plating or external fixator with minimum 6 months of follow up. All cases are evaluated according to time of union, complications, range of motion and modified knee society score. Modified knee society Score on residual effects on clinical ground at final examination. Points are given for pain, function and range of motion in modified knee society score. Result: Mean knee ROM in intramedullary nailing group is 118, while in plating group is 113.33.Average time of union in intramedullary nailing group is 18.61weeks; while in plating group is 25.33 weeks. Result according to Modified knee society score was found to be excellent to good in 18(72%) patients.11(73%) patients treated by interlocking intramedullary nailing had excellent to good knee score. Conclusion: Interlocking intramedullary nailing is a excellent method of treatment for the segmental tibia fracture as it provides rotational stability, gives excellent to good result, lower rate of complications and good knee ROM.https://www.jrmds.in/articles/modalities-of-treatment-for-segmental-tibia-fracture.pdfSegmental tibia fractureModified knee society scoreIntramedullary nailing
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Prashant Patel
Ketan Kakani
Pratik Prajapati
Viral Prajapat
Sandeep Patil
spellingShingle Prashant Patel
Ketan Kakani
Pratik Prajapati
Viral Prajapat
Sandeep Patil
Modalities of treatment for segmental tibia fracture
Journal of Research in Medical and Dental Science
Segmental tibia fracture
Modified knee society score
Intramedullary nailing
author_facet Prashant Patel
Ketan Kakani
Pratik Prajapati
Viral Prajapat
Sandeep Patil
author_sort Prashant Patel
title Modalities of treatment for segmental tibia fracture
title_short Modalities of treatment for segmental tibia fracture
title_full Modalities of treatment for segmental tibia fracture
title_fullStr Modalities of treatment for segmental tibia fracture
title_full_unstemmed Modalities of treatment for segmental tibia fracture
title_sort modalities of treatment for segmental tibia fracture
publisher Amber Publication
series Journal of Research in Medical and Dental Science
issn 2347-2545
2347-2367
publishDate 2016-09-01
description Background: Segmental tibia fractures (AO 42-C2) are defined by two or more distinct fracture lines isolating an interposed cortical segment which excludes butterfly fragmentation. Severe soft tissue defects are common due to their association with high energy trauma mechanisms of injury. Objectives: This study is an attempt to observe the various outcome of operative management of segmental tibia fracture treated by various modalities like intramedullary nailing, plating and external fixator. The results have been studied in depth to determine which modality is better for management of this type of fracture. Material & Methods: This is a prospective study of 25 cases of segmental tibia fracture treated by intra medullary nailing or plating or external fixator with minimum 6 months of follow up. All cases are evaluated according to time of union, complications, range of motion and modified knee society score. Modified knee society Score on residual effects on clinical ground at final examination. Points are given for pain, function and range of motion in modified knee society score. Result: Mean knee ROM in intramedullary nailing group is 118, while in plating group is 113.33.Average time of union in intramedullary nailing group is 18.61weeks; while in plating group is 25.33 weeks. Result according to Modified knee society score was found to be excellent to good in 18(72%) patients.11(73%) patients treated by interlocking intramedullary nailing had excellent to good knee score. Conclusion: Interlocking intramedullary nailing is a excellent method of treatment for the segmental tibia fracture as it provides rotational stability, gives excellent to good result, lower rate of complications and good knee ROM.
topic Segmental tibia fracture
Modified knee society score
Intramedullary nailing
url https://www.jrmds.in/articles/modalities-of-treatment-for-segmental-tibia-fracture.pdf
work_keys_str_mv AT prashantpatel modalitiesoftreatmentforsegmentaltibiafracture
AT ketankakani modalitiesoftreatmentforsegmentaltibiafracture
AT pratikprajapati modalitiesoftreatmentforsegmentaltibiafracture
AT viralprajapat modalitiesoftreatmentforsegmentaltibiafracture
AT sandeeppatil modalitiesoftreatmentforsegmentaltibiafracture
_version_ 1716769642677010432