The Enright phenomenon. Stereoscopic distortion of perceived driving speed induced by monocular pupil dilation

• Main Authors: Andrew Carkeet, Joanne M. Wood, Kylie M. McNeill, Hamish J. McNeill, Joanna A. James, Leigh S. Holder
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Published: Elsevier 2017-10-01
• Series: Journal of Optometry
• Subjects: Driving; Enright; Pulfrich; Speed distortion; Monocular dilation
• Online Access: http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1888429616300553

Purpose: The Enright phenomenon describes the distortion in speed perception experienced by an observer looking sideways from a moving vehicle when viewing with interocular differences in retinal image brightness, usually induced by neutral density filters. We investigated whether the Enright phenomenon could be induced with monocular pupil dilation using tropicamide. Methods: We tested 17 visually normal young adults on a closed road driving circuit. Participants were asked to travel at Goal Speeds of 40 km/h and 60 km/h while looking sideways from the vehicle with: (i) both eyes with undilated pupils; (ii) both eyes with dilated pupils; (iii) with the leading eye only dilated; and (iv) the trailing eye only dilated. For each condition we recorded actual driving speed. Results: With the pupil of the leading eye dilated participants drove significantly faster (by an average of 3.8 km/h) than with both eyes dilated (p = 0.02); with the trailing eye dilated participants drove significantly slower (by an average of 3.2 km/h) than with both eyes dilated (p < 0.001). The speed, with the leading eye dilated, was faster by an average of 7 km/h than with the trailing eye dilated (p < 0.001). There was no significant difference between driving speeds when viewing with both eyes either dilated or undilated (p = 0.322). Conclusions: Our results are the first to show a measurable change in driving behaviour following monocular pupil dilation and support predictions based on the Enright phenomenon.