Minimally invasive strabismus surgery versus paralimbal approach: A randomized, parallel design study is minimally invasive strabismus surgery worth the effort?
Introduction : Minimal access surgery is common in all fields of medicine. We compared a new minimally invasive strabismus surgery (MISS) approach with a standard paralimbal strabismus surgery (SPSS) approach in terms of post-operative course. Materials and Methods: This parallel design study was do...
Main Authors: | , , |
---|---|
Format: | Article |
Language: | English |
Published: |
Wolters Kluwer Medknow Publications
2014-01-01
|
Series: | Indian Journal of Ophthalmology |
Subjects: | |
Online Access: | http://www.ijo.in/article.asp?issn=0301-4738;year=2014;volume=62;issue=4;spage=508;epage=511;aulast=Sharma |
id |
doaj-a49ca0fc800d4630a67455f1cc470687 |
---|---|
record_format |
Article |
spelling |
doaj-a49ca0fc800d4630a67455f1cc4706872020-11-25T00:24:59ZengWolters Kluwer Medknow PublicationsIndian Journal of Ophthalmology0301-47381998-36892014-01-0162450851110.4103/0301-4738.118448Minimally invasive strabismus surgery versus paralimbal approach: A randomized, parallel design study is minimally invasive strabismus surgery worth the effort?Richa SharmaAbadan K AmitavaSadat AO BaniIntroduction : Minimal access surgery is common in all fields of medicine. We compared a new minimally invasive strabismus surgery (MISS) approach with a standard paralimbal strabismus surgery (SPSS) approach in terms of post-operative course. Materials and Methods: This parallel design study was done on 28 eyes of 14 patients, in which one eye was randomized to MISS and the other to SPSS. MISS was performed by giving two conjunctival incisions parallel to the horizontal rectus muscles; performing recession or resection below the conjunctival strip so obtained. We compared post-operative redness, congestion, chemosis, foreign body sensation (FBS), and drop intolerance (DI) on a graded scale of 0 to 3 on post-operative day 1, at 2-3 weeks, and 6 weeks. In addition, all scores were added to obtain a total inflammatory score (TIS). Statistical Analysis: Inflammatory scores were analyzed using Wilcoxon′s signed rank test. Results: On the first post-operative day, only FBS (P = 0.01) and TIS (P = 0.04) showed significant difference favoring MISS. At 2-3 weeks, redness (P = 0.04), congestion (P = 0.04), FBS (P = 0.02), and TIS (P = 0.04) were significantly less in MISS eye. At 6 weeks, only redness (P = 0.04) and TIS (P = 0.05) were significantly less. Conclusion: MISS is more comfortable in the immediate post-operative period and provides better cosmesis in the intermediate period.http://www.ijo.in/article.asp?issn=0301-4738;year=2014;volume=62;issue=4;spage=508;epage=511;aulast=SharmaMean deviationnon-proliferative diabetic retinopathyshort fluctuationsshort wave automated perimetrystandard automated perimetryAntimicrobial effectconventional silicone oilendophthalmitis agentsheavy silicone oilKeratoconusmodified deep anterior lamellar keratoplastysteep corneal curvatureBevacizumabbranch retinal vein occlusionintravitrealmacular edematriamcinoloneBlindnessdisability evaluationquality of lifevisual acuityMitomycin Cpterygium recurrencepterygium surgerysubconjunctival bevacizumab injectionImaging in glaucomaoptical coherence tomographypediatricretinal nerve fiber layerAutogenous tissue graftinglacrimal drainage systemlacrimal fossabypass surgeryCorneaexcimer lasergrowth factorsmyopiaphotorefractive keratectomyTriamcinolone acetonidehuman trabecular meshwork cellsin vitroHyperopic implantable collamer lensmyopic implantable collamer lensoptical qualitywavefront aberrationsDacryocystorhinostomynasolacrimal duct obstructionsilicone tubeAgeanterior chamber depthbody heightprimary angle closure glaucomasexChildreneye injury vitrectomy studyeye injurytraumavitrectomyCorneal biomechanicscorneal hysteresiscorneal resistance factorintraocular pressurekeratoplastyocular response analyserAspherical intraocular lensquality of visionspherical aberrationsBenignexcisionlids and caruncleno recurrenceocular FH Bevacizumabinflammationsterile endophthalmitisCarotid artery diseaseocular ischemic syndromeretinal emboliBlindnesscataractIndialow visionpopulationAwarenessglaucomaknowledgeNorth IndiaAphakiacapsular supportinadequateintraocular lens implantationiris fixationExtra macular BRVOhyperhomocysteinemiamultiple BRVOMedial canthusrecurrentretiform hemangioendotheliomaOptic atrophyosteopetrosisLacrimal abscessdacryocystitiscardiobacterium hominisEthambutollinezolidoptic neuropathyBlunt traumahorseshoe-shaped macular tearspectral-domain optical coherence tomographyCaesarian sectioncombined occlusionnon-ocular surgeryperioperative visual lossChoroidal thicknessenhanced depth imaginghigh-altitude retinopathyoptical coherence tomographyCosmesisincisionminimalstrabismussurgery |
collection |
DOAJ |
language |
English |
format |
Article |
sources |
DOAJ |
author |
Richa Sharma Abadan K Amitava Sadat AO Bani |
spellingShingle |
Richa Sharma Abadan K Amitava Sadat AO Bani Minimally invasive strabismus surgery versus paralimbal approach: A randomized, parallel design study is minimally invasive strabismus surgery worth the effort? Indian Journal of Ophthalmology Mean deviation non-proliferative diabetic retinopathy short fluctuations short wave automated perimetry standard automated perimetry Antimicrobial effect conventional silicone oil endophthalmitis agents heavy silicone oil Keratoconus modified deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty steep corneal curvature Bevacizumab branch retinal vein occlusion intravitreal macular edema triamcinolone Blindness disability evaluation quality of life visual acuity Mitomycin C pterygium recurrence pterygium surgery subconjunctival bevacizumab injection Imaging in glaucoma optical coherence tomography pediatric retinal nerve fiber layer Autogenous tissue grafting lacrimal drainage system lacrimal fossa bypass surgery Cornea excimer laser growth factors myopia photorefractive keratectomy Triamcinolone acetonide human trabecular meshwork cells in vitro Hyperopic implantable collamer lens myopic implantable collamer lens optical quality wavefront aberrations Dacryocystorhinostomy nasolacrimal duct obstruction silicone tube Age anterior chamber depth body height primary angle closure glaucoma sex Children eye injury vitrectomy study eye injury trauma vitrectomy Corneal biomechanics corneal hysteresis corneal resistance factor intraocular pressure keratoplasty ocular response analyser Aspherical intraocular lens quality of vision spherical aberrations Benign excision lids and caruncle no recurrence ocular FH Bevacizumab inflammation sterile endophthalmitis Carotid artery disease ocular ischemic syndrome retinal emboli Blindness cataract India low vision population Awareness glaucoma knowledge North India Aphakia capsular support inadequate intraocular lens implantation iris fixation Extra macular BRVO hyperhomocysteinemia multiple BRVO Medial canthus recurrent retiform hemangioendothelioma Optic atrophy osteopetrosis Lacrimal abscess dacryocystitis cardiobacterium hominis Ethambutol linezolid optic neuropathy Blunt trauma horseshoe-shaped macular tear spectral-domain optical coherence tomography Caesarian section combined occlusion non-ocular surgery perioperative visual loss Choroidal thickness enhanced depth imaging high-altitude retinopathy optical coherence tomography Cosmesis incision minimal strabismus surgery |
author_facet |
Richa Sharma Abadan K Amitava Sadat AO Bani |
author_sort |
Richa Sharma |
title |
Minimally invasive strabismus surgery versus paralimbal approach: A randomized, parallel design study is minimally invasive strabismus surgery worth the effort? |
title_short |
Minimally invasive strabismus surgery versus paralimbal approach: A randomized, parallel design study is minimally invasive strabismus surgery worth the effort? |
title_full |
Minimally invasive strabismus surgery versus paralimbal approach: A randomized, parallel design study is minimally invasive strabismus surgery worth the effort? |
title_fullStr |
Minimally invasive strabismus surgery versus paralimbal approach: A randomized, parallel design study is minimally invasive strabismus surgery worth the effort? |
title_full_unstemmed |
Minimally invasive strabismus surgery versus paralimbal approach: A randomized, parallel design study is minimally invasive strabismus surgery worth the effort? |
title_sort |
minimally invasive strabismus surgery versus paralimbal approach: a randomized, parallel design study is minimally invasive strabismus surgery worth the effort? |
publisher |
Wolters Kluwer Medknow Publications |
series |
Indian Journal of Ophthalmology |
issn |
0301-4738 1998-3689 |
publishDate |
2014-01-01 |
description |
Introduction : Minimal access surgery is common in all fields of medicine. We compared a new minimally invasive strabismus surgery (MISS) approach with a standard paralimbal strabismus surgery (SPSS) approach in terms of post-operative course. Materials and Methods: This parallel design study was done on 28 eyes of 14 patients, in which one eye was randomized to MISS and the other to SPSS. MISS was performed by giving two conjunctival incisions parallel to the horizontal rectus muscles; performing recession or resection below the conjunctival strip so obtained. We compared post-operative redness, congestion, chemosis, foreign body sensation (FBS), and drop intolerance (DI) on a graded scale of 0 to 3 on post-operative day 1, at 2-3 weeks, and 6 weeks. In addition, all scores were added to obtain a total inflammatory score (TIS). Statistical Analysis: Inflammatory scores were analyzed using Wilcoxon′s signed rank test. Results: On the first post-operative day, only FBS (P = 0.01) and TIS (P = 0.04) showed significant difference favoring MISS. At 2-3 weeks, redness (P = 0.04), congestion (P = 0.04), FBS (P = 0.02), and TIS (P = 0.04) were significantly less in MISS eye. At 6 weeks, only redness (P = 0.04) and TIS (P = 0.05) were significantly less. Conclusion: MISS is more comfortable in the immediate post-operative period and provides better cosmesis in the intermediate period. |
topic |
Mean deviation non-proliferative diabetic retinopathy short fluctuations short wave automated perimetry standard automated perimetry Antimicrobial effect conventional silicone oil endophthalmitis agents heavy silicone oil Keratoconus modified deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty steep corneal curvature Bevacizumab branch retinal vein occlusion intravitreal macular edema triamcinolone Blindness disability evaluation quality of life visual acuity Mitomycin C pterygium recurrence pterygium surgery subconjunctival bevacizumab injection Imaging in glaucoma optical coherence tomography pediatric retinal nerve fiber layer Autogenous tissue grafting lacrimal drainage system lacrimal fossa bypass surgery Cornea excimer laser growth factors myopia photorefractive keratectomy Triamcinolone acetonide human trabecular meshwork cells in vitro Hyperopic implantable collamer lens myopic implantable collamer lens optical quality wavefront aberrations Dacryocystorhinostomy nasolacrimal duct obstruction silicone tube Age anterior chamber depth body height primary angle closure glaucoma sex Children eye injury vitrectomy study eye injury trauma vitrectomy Corneal biomechanics corneal hysteresis corneal resistance factor intraocular pressure keratoplasty ocular response analyser Aspherical intraocular lens quality of vision spherical aberrations Benign excision lids and caruncle no recurrence ocular FH Bevacizumab inflammation sterile endophthalmitis Carotid artery disease ocular ischemic syndrome retinal emboli Blindness cataract India low vision population Awareness glaucoma knowledge North India Aphakia capsular support inadequate intraocular lens implantation iris fixation Extra macular BRVO hyperhomocysteinemia multiple BRVO Medial canthus recurrent retiform hemangioendothelioma Optic atrophy osteopetrosis Lacrimal abscess dacryocystitis cardiobacterium hominis Ethambutol linezolid optic neuropathy Blunt trauma horseshoe-shaped macular tear spectral-domain optical coherence tomography Caesarian section combined occlusion non-ocular surgery perioperative visual loss Choroidal thickness enhanced depth imaging high-altitude retinopathy optical coherence tomography Cosmesis incision minimal strabismus surgery |
url |
http://www.ijo.in/article.asp?issn=0301-4738;year=2014;volume=62;issue=4;spage=508;epage=511;aulast=Sharma |
work_keys_str_mv |
AT richasharma minimallyinvasivestrabismussurgeryversusparalimbalapproacharandomizedparalleldesignstudyisminimallyinvasivestrabismussurgeryworththeeffort AT abadankamitava minimallyinvasivestrabismussurgeryversusparalimbalapproacharandomizedparalleldesignstudyisminimallyinvasivestrabismussurgeryworththeeffort AT sadataobani minimallyinvasivestrabismussurgeryversusparalimbalapproacharandomizedparalleldesignstudyisminimallyinvasivestrabismussurgeryworththeeffort |
_version_ |
1725350474782081024 |