A Revised Historical Fire Regime Analysis in Tunisia (1985–2010) from a Critical Analysis of the National Fire Database and Remote Sensing

Long-term fire history reconstructions provide fruitful information in the context of global change. Global remotely-sensed burned areas offer a uniform estimate of fire regimes worldwide, but hardly capture small fire events and cover only the last 20 years. Burned areas from national statistics of...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Chiraz Belhadj-Khedher, Nikos Koutsias, Anastasia Karamitsou, Taoufik EI-Melki, Bahri Ouelhazi, Abdelazziz Hamdi, Habiba Nouri, Florent Mouillot
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: MDPI AG 2018-01-01
Series:Forests
Subjects:
Online Access:http://www.mdpi.com/1999-4907/9/2/59
id doaj-a43fac9d0e8845ccbad7b9686f3c979c
record_format Article
spelling doaj-a43fac9d0e8845ccbad7b9686f3c979c2020-11-24T22:35:00ZengMDPI AGForests1999-49072018-01-01925910.3390/f9020059f9020059A Revised Historical Fire Regime Analysis in Tunisia (1985–2010) from a Critical Analysis of the National Fire Database and Remote SensingChiraz Belhadj-Khedher0Nikos Koutsias1Anastasia Karamitsou2Taoufik EI-Melki3Bahri Ouelhazi4Abdelazziz Hamdi5Habiba Nouri6Florent Mouillot7Université Manouba, UR Geomatique & Geosystemes, Campus Universitaire BP 95, Manouba 2010, TunisiaDepartment of Environmental and Natural Resources Management, University of Patras, G. Seferi 2, Agrinio GR-30100, GreeceDepartment of Environmental and Natural Resources Management, University of Patras, G. Seferi 2, Agrinio GR-30100, GreeceUniversité Manouba, UR Geomatique & Geosystemes, Campus Universitaire BP 95, Manouba 2010, TunisiaInstitut de Recherche pour le Développement (IRD), 2 rue des sports, Tunis 1004, TunisiaLaboratoire des ressources sylvo-pastorales, Institut Sylvo-Pastoral de Tabarka, Tabarka 8110, TunisiaInstitut de Recherche pour le Développement (IRD), 2 rue des sports, Tunis 1004, TunisiaInstitut de Recherche pour le Développement (IRD), UMR CEFE 5175, CNRS, Université Montpellier, Université Paul Valery Montpellier, EPHE, IRD, 1919 Route de Mende, 34293 Montpellier CEDEX 5, FranceLong-term fire history reconstructions provide fruitful information in the context of global change. Global remotely-sensed burned areas offer a uniform estimate of fire regimes worldwide, but hardly capture small fire events and cover only the last 20 years. Burned areas from national statistics often lack credibility due to discrepancies in fire report protocols between countries, partial data records and uncertain burned area estimates from field observations. However, they constitute a unique and valuable alternative long-term key source of information. We provide here a detailed critical analysis of the fire database in Tunisia, on the southern boundary of the Mediterranean basin and with a contrasted socio-economic environment compared to the more studied European side. We analyzed the fire record database with a quality checking protocol, combined with remote sensing burned area characterization from Landsat images. The high uncertainties in fire numbers could not lead to any conclusion for an accurate trend estimate. The corrected burned area lead to an average yearly burned area of 1799 ha year−1 compared to previous estimates of 1017 ha year−1, leading to a fraction of burnable land affected by fires of 0.19%, on the lowest range of observations in the Mediterranean basin. From this corrected database, we revised the usually assumed burned area decrease in this region, with no significant trend detected over the 1985–2010 period. We conclude on the need for thorough assessment of data quality in fire history reconstruction from national statistics to prevent misleading conclusions, and for an increased credibility, in order to be further used in fire models benchmarking or fire weather analysis. Our results can contribute to the under-represented fire regime analysis on the southern boundary of the Mediterranean basin.http://www.mdpi.com/1999-4907/9/2/59forest fireremote sensingfire regimedata quality assessmentMediterranean ecosystems
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Chiraz Belhadj-Khedher
Nikos Koutsias
Anastasia Karamitsou
Taoufik EI-Melki
Bahri Ouelhazi
Abdelazziz Hamdi
Habiba Nouri
Florent Mouillot
spellingShingle Chiraz Belhadj-Khedher
Nikos Koutsias
Anastasia Karamitsou
Taoufik EI-Melki
Bahri Ouelhazi
Abdelazziz Hamdi
Habiba Nouri
Florent Mouillot
A Revised Historical Fire Regime Analysis in Tunisia (1985–2010) from a Critical Analysis of the National Fire Database and Remote Sensing
Forests
forest fire
remote sensing
fire regime
data quality assessment
Mediterranean ecosystems
author_facet Chiraz Belhadj-Khedher
Nikos Koutsias
Anastasia Karamitsou
Taoufik EI-Melki
Bahri Ouelhazi
Abdelazziz Hamdi
Habiba Nouri
Florent Mouillot
author_sort Chiraz Belhadj-Khedher
title A Revised Historical Fire Regime Analysis in Tunisia (1985–2010) from a Critical Analysis of the National Fire Database and Remote Sensing
title_short A Revised Historical Fire Regime Analysis in Tunisia (1985–2010) from a Critical Analysis of the National Fire Database and Remote Sensing
title_full A Revised Historical Fire Regime Analysis in Tunisia (1985–2010) from a Critical Analysis of the National Fire Database and Remote Sensing
title_fullStr A Revised Historical Fire Regime Analysis in Tunisia (1985–2010) from a Critical Analysis of the National Fire Database and Remote Sensing
title_full_unstemmed A Revised Historical Fire Regime Analysis in Tunisia (1985–2010) from a Critical Analysis of the National Fire Database and Remote Sensing
title_sort revised historical fire regime analysis in tunisia (1985–2010) from a critical analysis of the national fire database and remote sensing
publisher MDPI AG
series Forests
issn 1999-4907
publishDate 2018-01-01
description Long-term fire history reconstructions provide fruitful information in the context of global change. Global remotely-sensed burned areas offer a uniform estimate of fire regimes worldwide, but hardly capture small fire events and cover only the last 20 years. Burned areas from national statistics often lack credibility due to discrepancies in fire report protocols between countries, partial data records and uncertain burned area estimates from field observations. However, they constitute a unique and valuable alternative long-term key source of information. We provide here a detailed critical analysis of the fire database in Tunisia, on the southern boundary of the Mediterranean basin and with a contrasted socio-economic environment compared to the more studied European side. We analyzed the fire record database with a quality checking protocol, combined with remote sensing burned area characterization from Landsat images. The high uncertainties in fire numbers could not lead to any conclusion for an accurate trend estimate. The corrected burned area lead to an average yearly burned area of 1799 ha year−1 compared to previous estimates of 1017 ha year−1, leading to a fraction of burnable land affected by fires of 0.19%, on the lowest range of observations in the Mediterranean basin. From this corrected database, we revised the usually assumed burned area decrease in this region, with no significant trend detected over the 1985–2010 period. We conclude on the need for thorough assessment of data quality in fire history reconstruction from national statistics to prevent misleading conclusions, and for an increased credibility, in order to be further used in fire models benchmarking or fire weather analysis. Our results can contribute to the under-represented fire regime analysis on the southern boundary of the Mediterranean basin.
topic forest fire
remote sensing
fire regime
data quality assessment
Mediterranean ecosystems
url http://www.mdpi.com/1999-4907/9/2/59
work_keys_str_mv AT chirazbelhadjkhedher arevisedhistoricalfireregimeanalysisintunisia19852010fromacriticalanalysisofthenationalfiredatabaseandremotesensing
AT nikoskoutsias arevisedhistoricalfireregimeanalysisintunisia19852010fromacriticalanalysisofthenationalfiredatabaseandremotesensing
AT anastasiakaramitsou arevisedhistoricalfireregimeanalysisintunisia19852010fromacriticalanalysisofthenationalfiredatabaseandremotesensing
AT taoufikeimelki arevisedhistoricalfireregimeanalysisintunisia19852010fromacriticalanalysisofthenationalfiredatabaseandremotesensing
AT bahriouelhazi arevisedhistoricalfireregimeanalysisintunisia19852010fromacriticalanalysisofthenationalfiredatabaseandremotesensing
AT abdelazzizhamdi arevisedhistoricalfireregimeanalysisintunisia19852010fromacriticalanalysisofthenationalfiredatabaseandremotesensing
AT habibanouri arevisedhistoricalfireregimeanalysisintunisia19852010fromacriticalanalysisofthenationalfiredatabaseandremotesensing
AT florentmouillot arevisedhistoricalfireregimeanalysisintunisia19852010fromacriticalanalysisofthenationalfiredatabaseandremotesensing
AT chirazbelhadjkhedher revisedhistoricalfireregimeanalysisintunisia19852010fromacriticalanalysisofthenationalfiredatabaseandremotesensing
AT nikoskoutsias revisedhistoricalfireregimeanalysisintunisia19852010fromacriticalanalysisofthenationalfiredatabaseandremotesensing
AT anastasiakaramitsou revisedhistoricalfireregimeanalysisintunisia19852010fromacriticalanalysisofthenationalfiredatabaseandremotesensing
AT taoufikeimelki revisedhistoricalfireregimeanalysisintunisia19852010fromacriticalanalysisofthenationalfiredatabaseandremotesensing
AT bahriouelhazi revisedhistoricalfireregimeanalysisintunisia19852010fromacriticalanalysisofthenationalfiredatabaseandremotesensing
AT abdelazzizhamdi revisedhistoricalfireregimeanalysisintunisia19852010fromacriticalanalysisofthenationalfiredatabaseandremotesensing
AT habibanouri revisedhistoricalfireregimeanalysisintunisia19852010fromacriticalanalysisofthenationalfiredatabaseandremotesensing
AT florentmouillot revisedhistoricalfireregimeanalysisintunisia19852010fromacriticalanalysisofthenationalfiredatabaseandremotesensing
_version_ 1725725190597378048