Advising Dialogue from a Feminist Perspective: Gendered Talk or Emotional Labor?

• Main Authors: Sophie Bailly, Guillaume Nassau, Anouchka Divoux
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Published: Kanda University of International Studies 2015-03-01
• Series: Studies in Self-Access Learning Journal
• Subjects: ALL; powerless speech; feminine and masculine talk; emotional labour
• Online Access: https://sisaljournal.org/archives/mar15/bailly_nassau_divoux/

Adopting a feminist perspective, this exploratory and empirically based study of face-to-face advising dialogue will put into question two related aspects of advising that have seldom been discussed in the literature on advising: the gendered dimension and the psychological support. Based on the general and rarely discussed assumption that women’s speech is more emotional and best suited for establishing and maintaining more equal relationships than men’s speech, and on the fact that many language learning advisors in the world are women, this study examines the ways in which female and male advisors working in different educational contexts verbally establish a relationship where a learner’s autonomy can emerge. The preliminary results suggest that psychological support is provided through a wide range of verbal strategies and that gender seems less significant than work context to explain individual differences.