The impact of progesterone receptor expression on prognosis of patients with rapidly proliferating, hormone receptor-positive early breast cancer: a analysis of the IBIS 3 trial

Background: In the Italian Breast Cancer Intergroup Studies (IBIS) 3 phase III trial, we compared cyclophosphamide, methotrexate, 5-fluorouracil (CMF) alone to sequential epirubicin/CMF regimens in patients with rapidly proliferating early breast cancer (RPEBC). We performed a post hoc analysis in t...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Sara Bravaccini, Giuseppe Bronte, Emanuela Scarpi, Sara Ravaioli, Roberta Maltoni, Anita Mangia, Maria Maddalena Tumedei, Maurizio Puccetti, Patrizia Serra, Lorenzo Gianni, Laura Amaducci, Nicoletta Biglia, Valentina Bounous, Angelo Virgilio Paradiso, Rosella Silvestrini, Dino Amadori, Andrea Rocca
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: SAGE Publishing 2020-02-01
Series:Therapeutic Advances in Medical Oncology
Online Access:https://doi.org/10.1177/1758835919888999
id doaj-9c335358d56743fda946544b114d2f88
record_format Article
spelling doaj-9c335358d56743fda946544b114d2f882020-11-25T03:00:25ZengSAGE PublishingTherapeutic Advances in Medical Oncology1758-83592020-02-011210.1177/1758835919888999The impact of progesterone receptor expression on prognosis of patients with rapidly proliferating, hormone receptor-positive early breast cancer: a analysis of the IBIS 3 trialSara BravacciniGiuseppe BronteEmanuela ScarpiSara RavaioliRoberta MaltoniAnita MangiaMaria Maddalena TumedeiMaurizio PuccettiPatrizia SerraLorenzo GianniLaura AmaducciNicoletta BigliaValentina BounousAngelo Virgilio ParadisoRosella SilvestriniDino AmadoriAndrea RoccaBackground: In the Italian Breast Cancer Intergroup Studies (IBIS) 3 phase III trial, we compared cyclophosphamide, methotrexate, 5-fluorouracil (CMF) alone to sequential epirubicin/CMF regimens in patients with rapidly proliferating early breast cancer (RPEBC). We performed a post hoc analysis in the subgroup of patients with hormone-receptor-positive RPEBC on the prognostic role of progesterone receptor (PgR) status. Methods: RPEBC was defined by thymidine labeling index (TLI) >3% or grade 3 or S-phase >10% or Ki67 >20%. We analyzed 466 patients with hormone-receptor-positive RPEBC receiving sequential epirubicin/CMF regimens followed by tamoxifen, and for whom the status of ER and PgR was available. Results: Considering both cut-off values of 10% and 20%, PgR expression was significantly associated with age, menopausal status, and ER expression; HER2 status was associated with PgR status only at a cutoff value of 20% PgR. Upon univariate analysis, tumor size, nodal status, and PgR were significantly associated with disease-free survival (DFS) and overall survival (OS), while age class and local treatment type were associated only with DFS. Patients with PgR <20% showed lower 5- and 10-year DFS [hazard ratio (HR) = 1.48; 95%CI: 1.01–2.18; p  = 0.044] and OS (HR = 1.85; 95%CI: 1.08–3.19, p  = 0.025) rates compared with patients with PgR ⩾20%. Upon multivariate analysis, only tumor size, nodal status, and PgR were independent prognostic factors. Conclusions: Our results highlight the independent prognostic relevance of PgR expression in patients with hormone-receptor-positive RPEBC treated with adjuvant chemotherapy and endocrine therapy, where the definition of prognostic subgroups is still a major need.https://doi.org/10.1177/1758835919888999
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Sara Bravaccini
Giuseppe Bronte
Emanuela Scarpi
Sara Ravaioli
Roberta Maltoni
Anita Mangia
Maria Maddalena Tumedei
Maurizio Puccetti
Patrizia Serra
Lorenzo Gianni
Laura Amaducci
Nicoletta Biglia
Valentina Bounous
Angelo Virgilio Paradiso
Rosella Silvestrini
Dino Amadori
Andrea Rocca
spellingShingle Sara Bravaccini
Giuseppe Bronte
Emanuela Scarpi
Sara Ravaioli
Roberta Maltoni
Anita Mangia
Maria Maddalena Tumedei
Maurizio Puccetti
Patrizia Serra
Lorenzo Gianni
Laura Amaducci
Nicoletta Biglia
Valentina Bounous
Angelo Virgilio Paradiso
Rosella Silvestrini
Dino Amadori
Andrea Rocca
The impact of progesterone receptor expression on prognosis of patients with rapidly proliferating, hormone receptor-positive early breast cancer: a analysis of the IBIS 3 trial
Therapeutic Advances in Medical Oncology
author_facet Sara Bravaccini
Giuseppe Bronte
Emanuela Scarpi
Sara Ravaioli
Roberta Maltoni
Anita Mangia
Maria Maddalena Tumedei
Maurizio Puccetti
Patrizia Serra
Lorenzo Gianni
Laura Amaducci
Nicoletta Biglia
Valentina Bounous
Angelo Virgilio Paradiso
Rosella Silvestrini
Dino Amadori
Andrea Rocca
author_sort Sara Bravaccini
title The impact of progesterone receptor expression on prognosis of patients with rapidly proliferating, hormone receptor-positive early breast cancer: a analysis of the IBIS 3 trial
title_short The impact of progesterone receptor expression on prognosis of patients with rapidly proliferating, hormone receptor-positive early breast cancer: a analysis of the IBIS 3 trial
title_full The impact of progesterone receptor expression on prognosis of patients with rapidly proliferating, hormone receptor-positive early breast cancer: a analysis of the IBIS 3 trial
title_fullStr The impact of progesterone receptor expression on prognosis of patients with rapidly proliferating, hormone receptor-positive early breast cancer: a analysis of the IBIS 3 trial
title_full_unstemmed The impact of progesterone receptor expression on prognosis of patients with rapidly proliferating, hormone receptor-positive early breast cancer: a analysis of the IBIS 3 trial
title_sort impact of progesterone receptor expression on prognosis of patients with rapidly proliferating, hormone receptor-positive early breast cancer: a analysis of the ibis 3 trial
publisher SAGE Publishing
series Therapeutic Advances in Medical Oncology
issn 1758-8359
publishDate 2020-02-01
description Background: In the Italian Breast Cancer Intergroup Studies (IBIS) 3 phase III trial, we compared cyclophosphamide, methotrexate, 5-fluorouracil (CMF) alone to sequential epirubicin/CMF regimens in patients with rapidly proliferating early breast cancer (RPEBC). We performed a post hoc analysis in the subgroup of patients with hormone-receptor-positive RPEBC on the prognostic role of progesterone receptor (PgR) status. Methods: RPEBC was defined by thymidine labeling index (TLI) >3% or grade 3 or S-phase >10% or Ki67 >20%. We analyzed 466 patients with hormone-receptor-positive RPEBC receiving sequential epirubicin/CMF regimens followed by tamoxifen, and for whom the status of ER and PgR was available. Results: Considering both cut-off values of 10% and 20%, PgR expression was significantly associated with age, menopausal status, and ER expression; HER2 status was associated with PgR status only at a cutoff value of 20% PgR. Upon univariate analysis, tumor size, nodal status, and PgR were significantly associated with disease-free survival (DFS) and overall survival (OS), while age class and local treatment type were associated only with DFS. Patients with PgR <20% showed lower 5- and 10-year DFS [hazard ratio (HR) = 1.48; 95%CI: 1.01–2.18; p  = 0.044] and OS (HR = 1.85; 95%CI: 1.08–3.19, p  = 0.025) rates compared with patients with PgR ⩾20%. Upon multivariate analysis, only tumor size, nodal status, and PgR were independent prognostic factors. Conclusions: Our results highlight the independent prognostic relevance of PgR expression in patients with hormone-receptor-positive RPEBC treated with adjuvant chemotherapy and endocrine therapy, where the definition of prognostic subgroups is still a major need.
url https://doi.org/10.1177/1758835919888999
work_keys_str_mv AT sarabravaccini theimpactofprogesteronereceptorexpressiononprognosisofpatientswithrapidlyproliferatinghormonereceptorpositiveearlybreastcanceraanalysisoftheibis3trial
AT giuseppebronte theimpactofprogesteronereceptorexpressiononprognosisofpatientswithrapidlyproliferatinghormonereceptorpositiveearlybreastcanceraanalysisoftheibis3trial
AT emanuelascarpi theimpactofprogesteronereceptorexpressiononprognosisofpatientswithrapidlyproliferatinghormonereceptorpositiveearlybreastcanceraanalysisoftheibis3trial
AT sararavaioli theimpactofprogesteronereceptorexpressiononprognosisofpatientswithrapidlyproliferatinghormonereceptorpositiveearlybreastcanceraanalysisoftheibis3trial
AT robertamaltoni theimpactofprogesteronereceptorexpressiononprognosisofpatientswithrapidlyproliferatinghormonereceptorpositiveearlybreastcanceraanalysisoftheibis3trial
AT anitamangia theimpactofprogesteronereceptorexpressiononprognosisofpatientswithrapidlyproliferatinghormonereceptorpositiveearlybreastcanceraanalysisoftheibis3trial
AT mariamaddalenatumedei theimpactofprogesteronereceptorexpressiononprognosisofpatientswithrapidlyproliferatinghormonereceptorpositiveearlybreastcanceraanalysisoftheibis3trial
AT mauriziopuccetti theimpactofprogesteronereceptorexpressiononprognosisofpatientswithrapidlyproliferatinghormonereceptorpositiveearlybreastcanceraanalysisoftheibis3trial
AT patriziaserra theimpactofprogesteronereceptorexpressiononprognosisofpatientswithrapidlyproliferatinghormonereceptorpositiveearlybreastcanceraanalysisoftheibis3trial
AT lorenzogianni theimpactofprogesteronereceptorexpressiononprognosisofpatientswithrapidlyproliferatinghormonereceptorpositiveearlybreastcanceraanalysisoftheibis3trial
AT lauraamaducci theimpactofprogesteronereceptorexpressiononprognosisofpatientswithrapidlyproliferatinghormonereceptorpositiveearlybreastcanceraanalysisoftheibis3trial
AT nicolettabiglia theimpactofprogesteronereceptorexpressiononprognosisofpatientswithrapidlyproliferatinghormonereceptorpositiveearlybreastcanceraanalysisoftheibis3trial
AT valentinabounous theimpactofprogesteronereceptorexpressiononprognosisofpatientswithrapidlyproliferatinghormonereceptorpositiveearlybreastcanceraanalysisoftheibis3trial
AT angelovirgilioparadiso theimpactofprogesteronereceptorexpressiononprognosisofpatientswithrapidlyproliferatinghormonereceptorpositiveearlybreastcanceraanalysisoftheibis3trial
AT rosellasilvestrini theimpactofprogesteronereceptorexpressiononprognosisofpatientswithrapidlyproliferatinghormonereceptorpositiveearlybreastcanceraanalysisoftheibis3trial
AT dinoamadori theimpactofprogesteronereceptorexpressiononprognosisofpatientswithrapidlyproliferatinghormonereceptorpositiveearlybreastcanceraanalysisoftheibis3trial
AT andrearocca theimpactofprogesteronereceptorexpressiononprognosisofpatientswithrapidlyproliferatinghormonereceptorpositiveearlybreastcanceraanalysisoftheibis3trial
AT sarabravaccini impactofprogesteronereceptorexpressiononprognosisofpatientswithrapidlyproliferatinghormonereceptorpositiveearlybreastcanceraanalysisoftheibis3trial
AT giuseppebronte impactofprogesteronereceptorexpressiononprognosisofpatientswithrapidlyproliferatinghormonereceptorpositiveearlybreastcanceraanalysisoftheibis3trial
AT emanuelascarpi impactofprogesteronereceptorexpressiononprognosisofpatientswithrapidlyproliferatinghormonereceptorpositiveearlybreastcanceraanalysisoftheibis3trial
AT sararavaioli impactofprogesteronereceptorexpressiononprognosisofpatientswithrapidlyproliferatinghormonereceptorpositiveearlybreastcanceraanalysisoftheibis3trial
AT robertamaltoni impactofprogesteronereceptorexpressiononprognosisofpatientswithrapidlyproliferatinghormonereceptorpositiveearlybreastcanceraanalysisoftheibis3trial
AT anitamangia impactofprogesteronereceptorexpressiononprognosisofpatientswithrapidlyproliferatinghormonereceptorpositiveearlybreastcanceraanalysisoftheibis3trial
AT mariamaddalenatumedei impactofprogesteronereceptorexpressiononprognosisofpatientswithrapidlyproliferatinghormonereceptorpositiveearlybreastcanceraanalysisoftheibis3trial
AT mauriziopuccetti impactofprogesteronereceptorexpressiononprognosisofpatientswithrapidlyproliferatinghormonereceptorpositiveearlybreastcanceraanalysisoftheibis3trial
AT patriziaserra impactofprogesteronereceptorexpressiononprognosisofpatientswithrapidlyproliferatinghormonereceptorpositiveearlybreastcanceraanalysisoftheibis3trial
AT lorenzogianni impactofprogesteronereceptorexpressiononprognosisofpatientswithrapidlyproliferatinghormonereceptorpositiveearlybreastcanceraanalysisoftheibis3trial
AT lauraamaducci impactofprogesteronereceptorexpressiononprognosisofpatientswithrapidlyproliferatinghormonereceptorpositiveearlybreastcanceraanalysisoftheibis3trial
AT nicolettabiglia impactofprogesteronereceptorexpressiononprognosisofpatientswithrapidlyproliferatinghormonereceptorpositiveearlybreastcanceraanalysisoftheibis3trial
AT valentinabounous impactofprogesteronereceptorexpressiononprognosisofpatientswithrapidlyproliferatinghormonereceptorpositiveearlybreastcanceraanalysisoftheibis3trial
AT angelovirgilioparadiso impactofprogesteronereceptorexpressiononprognosisofpatientswithrapidlyproliferatinghormonereceptorpositiveearlybreastcanceraanalysisoftheibis3trial
AT rosellasilvestrini impactofprogesteronereceptorexpressiononprognosisofpatientswithrapidlyproliferatinghormonereceptorpositiveearlybreastcanceraanalysisoftheibis3trial
AT dinoamadori impactofprogesteronereceptorexpressiononprognosisofpatientswithrapidlyproliferatinghormonereceptorpositiveearlybreastcanceraanalysisoftheibis3trial
AT andrearocca impactofprogesteronereceptorexpressiononprognosisofpatientswithrapidlyproliferatinghormonereceptorpositiveearlybreastcanceraanalysisoftheibis3trial
_version_ 1724698302640816128