Implementing Surrogate Safety Measures in Driving Simulator and Evaluating the Safety Effects of Simulator-Based Training on Risky Driving Behaviors

Human errors cause approximately 90 percent of traffic accidents, and drivers with risky driving behaviors are involved in about 52 percent of severe traffic crashes. Driver education using driving simulators has been used extensively to obtain a quantitative evaluation of driving behaviors without...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Eunhan Ka, Do-Gyeong Kim, Jooneui Hong, Chungwon Lee
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Hindawi-Wiley 2020-01-01
Series:Journal of Advanced Transportation
Online Access:http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2020/7525721
id doaj-94e35d92dd634f419379e6cbe8a19c55
record_format Article
spelling doaj-94e35d92dd634f419379e6cbe8a19c552020-11-25T03:56:19ZengHindawi-WileyJournal of Advanced Transportation0197-67292042-31952020-01-01202010.1155/2020/75257217525721Implementing Surrogate Safety Measures in Driving Simulator and Evaluating the Safety Effects of Simulator-Based Training on Risky Driving BehaviorsEunhan Ka0Do-Gyeong Kim1Jooneui Hong2Chungwon Lee3Institute of Engineering Research, Seoul National University, Seoul 08826, Republic of KoreaDepartment of Transportation Engineering, University of Seoul, Seoul 02504, Republic of KoreaKorea Development Institute, Sejong 30149, Republic of KoreaDepartment of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Seoul National University, Seoul 08826, Republic of KoreaHuman errors cause approximately 90 percent of traffic accidents, and drivers with risky driving behaviors are involved in about 52 percent of severe traffic crashes. Driver education using driving simulators has been used extensively to obtain a quantitative evaluation of driving behaviors without causing drivers to be at risk for physical injuries. However, since many driver education programs that use simulators have limits on realistic interactions with surrounding vehicles, they are limited in reducing risky driving behaviors associated with surrounding vehicles. This study introduces surrogate safety measures (SSMs) into simulator-based training in order to evaluate the potential for crashes and to reduce risky driving behaviors in driving situations that include surrounding vehicles. A preliminary experiment was conducted with 31 drivers to analyze whether the SSMs could identify risky driving behaviors. The results showed that 15 SSMs were statistically significant measures to capture risky driving behaviors. This study used simulator-based training with 21 novice drivers, 16 elderly drivers, and 21 commercial drivers to determine whether a simulator-based training program using the SSMs is effective in reducing risky driving behaviors. The risky driving behaviors by novice drivers were reduced significantly with the exception of erratic lane-changing. In the case of elderly drivers, speeding was the only risky driving behavior that was reduced; the others were not reduced because of their difficulty with manipulating the pedals in the driving simulator and their defensive driving. Risky driving behaviors by commercial drivers were reduced overall. The results of this study indicated that the SSMs can be used to enhance drivers’ safety, to evaluate the safety of traffic management strategies as well as to reduce risky driving behaviors in simulator-based training.http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2020/7525721
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Eunhan Ka
Do-Gyeong Kim
Jooneui Hong
Chungwon Lee
spellingShingle Eunhan Ka
Do-Gyeong Kim
Jooneui Hong
Chungwon Lee
Implementing Surrogate Safety Measures in Driving Simulator and Evaluating the Safety Effects of Simulator-Based Training on Risky Driving Behaviors
Journal of Advanced Transportation
author_facet Eunhan Ka
Do-Gyeong Kim
Jooneui Hong
Chungwon Lee
author_sort Eunhan Ka
title Implementing Surrogate Safety Measures in Driving Simulator and Evaluating the Safety Effects of Simulator-Based Training on Risky Driving Behaviors
title_short Implementing Surrogate Safety Measures in Driving Simulator and Evaluating the Safety Effects of Simulator-Based Training on Risky Driving Behaviors
title_full Implementing Surrogate Safety Measures in Driving Simulator and Evaluating the Safety Effects of Simulator-Based Training on Risky Driving Behaviors
title_fullStr Implementing Surrogate Safety Measures in Driving Simulator and Evaluating the Safety Effects of Simulator-Based Training on Risky Driving Behaviors
title_full_unstemmed Implementing Surrogate Safety Measures in Driving Simulator and Evaluating the Safety Effects of Simulator-Based Training on Risky Driving Behaviors
title_sort implementing surrogate safety measures in driving simulator and evaluating the safety effects of simulator-based training on risky driving behaviors
publisher Hindawi-Wiley
series Journal of Advanced Transportation
issn 0197-6729
2042-3195
publishDate 2020-01-01
description Human errors cause approximately 90 percent of traffic accidents, and drivers with risky driving behaviors are involved in about 52 percent of severe traffic crashes. Driver education using driving simulators has been used extensively to obtain a quantitative evaluation of driving behaviors without causing drivers to be at risk for physical injuries. However, since many driver education programs that use simulators have limits on realistic interactions with surrounding vehicles, they are limited in reducing risky driving behaviors associated with surrounding vehicles. This study introduces surrogate safety measures (SSMs) into simulator-based training in order to evaluate the potential for crashes and to reduce risky driving behaviors in driving situations that include surrounding vehicles. A preliminary experiment was conducted with 31 drivers to analyze whether the SSMs could identify risky driving behaviors. The results showed that 15 SSMs were statistically significant measures to capture risky driving behaviors. This study used simulator-based training with 21 novice drivers, 16 elderly drivers, and 21 commercial drivers to determine whether a simulator-based training program using the SSMs is effective in reducing risky driving behaviors. The risky driving behaviors by novice drivers were reduced significantly with the exception of erratic lane-changing. In the case of elderly drivers, speeding was the only risky driving behavior that was reduced; the others were not reduced because of their difficulty with manipulating the pedals in the driving simulator and their defensive driving. Risky driving behaviors by commercial drivers were reduced overall. The results of this study indicated that the SSMs can be used to enhance drivers’ safety, to evaluate the safety of traffic management strategies as well as to reduce risky driving behaviors in simulator-based training.
url http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2020/7525721
work_keys_str_mv AT eunhanka implementingsurrogatesafetymeasuresindrivingsimulatorandevaluatingthesafetyeffectsofsimulatorbasedtrainingonriskydrivingbehaviors
AT dogyeongkim implementingsurrogatesafetymeasuresindrivingsimulatorandevaluatingthesafetyeffectsofsimulatorbasedtrainingonriskydrivingbehaviors
AT jooneuihong implementingsurrogatesafetymeasuresindrivingsimulatorandevaluatingthesafetyeffectsofsimulatorbasedtrainingonriskydrivingbehaviors
AT chungwonlee implementingsurrogatesafetymeasuresindrivingsimulatorandevaluatingthesafetyeffectsofsimulatorbasedtrainingonriskydrivingbehaviors
_version_ 1715082850235056128