Quality measurement of out-patient neuropsychological therapy after stroke in Germany: definition of indicators and retrospective pilot study

Abstract Background In contrast to the hospital setting, today little work has been directed to the definition, measurement, and improvement of the quality of out-patient medical and therapeutic care. We developed a set of indicators to measure the quality of out-patient neuropsychological therapy a...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: I. Padberg, S. Heel, P. Thiem, A. Diebel, E. Mordhorst, U. Strohmeyer, A. Meisel
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: BMC 2021-02-01
Series:BMC Neurology
Subjects:
Online Access:https://doi.org/10.1186/s12883-021-02092-0
id doaj-8eefee266cea4ea6967003c4655a5251
record_format Article
spelling doaj-8eefee266cea4ea6967003c4655a52512021-02-21T12:23:53ZengBMCBMC Neurology1471-23772021-02-0121111110.1186/s12883-021-02092-0Quality measurement of out-patient neuropsychological therapy after stroke in Germany: definition of indicators and retrospective pilot studyI. Padberg0S. Heel1P. Thiem2A. Diebel3E. Mordhorst4U. Strohmeyer5A. Meisel6Center for Stroke Research, Charité-Universitätsmedizin Berlin, Corporate member of Freie Universität Berlin, Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin, and Berlin Institute of HealthZentrum für ambulante Neuropsychologie und Verhaltenstherapie (Center for out-patient neuropsychology and behavioral therapy)P.A.N.P - Praxis für ambulante Neuropsychologie Potsdam (out-patient clinic for neuropsychology Potsdam)Praxis Diebel (out-patient clinic Diebel)Zentrum für ambulante Rehabilitation (Center for out-patient rehabilitation) ZAR BerlinPraxis für ambulante Neuropsychologie und Psychotherapie (out-patient clinic for neuropsychology and psychotherapy)Center for Stroke Research, Charité-Universitätsmedizin Berlin, Corporate member of Freie Universität Berlin, Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin, and Berlin Institute of HealthAbstract Background In contrast to the hospital setting, today little work has been directed to the definition, measurement, and improvement of the quality of out-patient medical and therapeutic care. We developed a set of indicators to measure the quality of out-patient neuropsychological therapy after stroke. Methods The indicators cover core and interdisciplinary aspects of out-patient neuropsychological work such as mediation of patients into social care in case of need. Selection of the quality-indicators was done together with a consensus group of out-patient therapists and supported by evidence, validity, reliability as well as estimated relevance and variability with the quality of care. The set of indicators was further tested in a retrospective cohort study. Anonymous data of 104 patients were collected from out-patient clinical records of five clinics between November 2017 and April 2018. Associations between process and outcome quality were estimated exploitatively. Results Results allowed for the identification of areas with greater variability in the quality of process care and indicated that attention training as recommended by current guidelines had the lowest overall rate for meeting the quality-aim (met in 44% of the cases). This was followed by time < 1 month until the start of therapy (63% met) and mediation into social care in case of need (65% met). We further observed that overall quality and involving relatives in the therapy was associated with higher rates of professional reintegration (p-value = 0.03). However, the need for mediation into social care was associated with a reduced chance for successful professional reintegration (p-value = 0.009). Conclusion In conclusion, we describe a first set of quality indicators which cover different aspects of out-patient neuropsychological therapy and sufficient variability with care. First data further suggests that meeting the specified quality aims may indeed have relevant effects on outcomes.https://doi.org/10.1186/s12883-021-02092-0StrokeOut-patientQuality-indicatorsNeuropsychologyProfessional-reintegrationInterdisciplinary work
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author I. Padberg
S. Heel
P. Thiem
A. Diebel
E. Mordhorst
U. Strohmeyer
A. Meisel
spellingShingle I. Padberg
S. Heel
P. Thiem
A. Diebel
E. Mordhorst
U. Strohmeyer
A. Meisel
Quality measurement of out-patient neuropsychological therapy after stroke in Germany: definition of indicators and retrospective pilot study
BMC Neurology
Stroke
Out-patient
Quality-indicators
Neuropsychology
Professional-reintegration
Interdisciplinary work
author_facet I. Padberg
S. Heel
P. Thiem
A. Diebel
E. Mordhorst
U. Strohmeyer
A. Meisel
author_sort I. Padberg
title Quality measurement of out-patient neuropsychological therapy after stroke in Germany: definition of indicators and retrospective pilot study
title_short Quality measurement of out-patient neuropsychological therapy after stroke in Germany: definition of indicators and retrospective pilot study
title_full Quality measurement of out-patient neuropsychological therapy after stroke in Germany: definition of indicators and retrospective pilot study
title_fullStr Quality measurement of out-patient neuropsychological therapy after stroke in Germany: definition of indicators and retrospective pilot study
title_full_unstemmed Quality measurement of out-patient neuropsychological therapy after stroke in Germany: definition of indicators and retrospective pilot study
title_sort quality measurement of out-patient neuropsychological therapy after stroke in germany: definition of indicators and retrospective pilot study
publisher BMC
series BMC Neurology
issn 1471-2377
publishDate 2021-02-01
description Abstract Background In contrast to the hospital setting, today little work has been directed to the definition, measurement, and improvement of the quality of out-patient medical and therapeutic care. We developed a set of indicators to measure the quality of out-patient neuropsychological therapy after stroke. Methods The indicators cover core and interdisciplinary aspects of out-patient neuropsychological work such as mediation of patients into social care in case of need. Selection of the quality-indicators was done together with a consensus group of out-patient therapists and supported by evidence, validity, reliability as well as estimated relevance and variability with the quality of care. The set of indicators was further tested in a retrospective cohort study. Anonymous data of 104 patients were collected from out-patient clinical records of five clinics between November 2017 and April 2018. Associations between process and outcome quality were estimated exploitatively. Results Results allowed for the identification of areas with greater variability in the quality of process care and indicated that attention training as recommended by current guidelines had the lowest overall rate for meeting the quality-aim (met in 44% of the cases). This was followed by time < 1 month until the start of therapy (63% met) and mediation into social care in case of need (65% met). We further observed that overall quality and involving relatives in the therapy was associated with higher rates of professional reintegration (p-value = 0.03). However, the need for mediation into social care was associated with a reduced chance for successful professional reintegration (p-value = 0.009). Conclusion In conclusion, we describe a first set of quality indicators which cover different aspects of out-patient neuropsychological therapy and sufficient variability with care. First data further suggests that meeting the specified quality aims may indeed have relevant effects on outcomes.
topic Stroke
Out-patient
Quality-indicators
Neuropsychology
Professional-reintegration
Interdisciplinary work
url https://doi.org/10.1186/s12883-021-02092-0
work_keys_str_mv AT ipadberg qualitymeasurementofoutpatientneuropsychologicaltherapyafterstrokeingermanydefinitionofindicatorsandretrospectivepilotstudy
AT sheel qualitymeasurementofoutpatientneuropsychologicaltherapyafterstrokeingermanydefinitionofindicatorsandretrospectivepilotstudy
AT pthiem qualitymeasurementofoutpatientneuropsychologicaltherapyafterstrokeingermanydefinitionofindicatorsandretrospectivepilotstudy
AT adiebel qualitymeasurementofoutpatientneuropsychologicaltherapyafterstrokeingermanydefinitionofindicatorsandretrospectivepilotstudy
AT emordhorst qualitymeasurementofoutpatientneuropsychologicaltherapyafterstrokeingermanydefinitionofindicatorsandretrospectivepilotstudy
AT ustrohmeyer qualitymeasurementofoutpatientneuropsychologicaltherapyafterstrokeingermanydefinitionofindicatorsandretrospectivepilotstudy
AT ameisel qualitymeasurementofoutpatientneuropsychologicaltherapyafterstrokeingermanydefinitionofindicatorsandretrospectivepilotstudy
_version_ 1724258164340162560