Revisited analysis of a SHIVA01 trial cohort using functional mutational analyses successfully predicted treatment outcome

It still remains to be demonstrated that using molecular profiling to guide therapy improves patient outcome in oncology. Classification of somatic variants is not straightforward, rendering treatment decisions based on variants with unknown significance (VUS) hard to implement. The oncogenic activi...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Maud Kamal, Gabi Tarcic, Sylvain Dureau, Oded Edelheit, Zohar Barbash, Charlotte Lecerf, Claire Morel, Benjamin Miron, Celine Callens, Nicolas Servant, Ivan Bieche, Michael Vidne, Christophe Le Tourneau
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Wiley 2018-05-01
Series:Molecular Oncology
Subjects:
Online Access:https://doi.org/10.1002/1878-0261.12180
id doaj-8ccbc3a7f951415ab3e910883c870dbd
record_format Article
spelling doaj-8ccbc3a7f951415ab3e910883c870dbd2020-11-25T03:54:59ZengWileyMolecular Oncology1574-78911878-02612018-05-0112559460110.1002/1878-0261.12180Revisited analysis of a SHIVA01 trial cohort using functional mutational analyses successfully predicted treatment outcomeMaud Kamal0Gabi Tarcic1Sylvain Dureau2Oded Edelheit3Zohar Barbash4Charlotte Lecerf5Claire Morel6Benjamin Miron7Celine Callens8Nicolas Servant9Ivan Bieche10Michael Vidne11Christophe Le Tourneau12Department of Drug Development and Innovation Institut Curie Paris & Saint‐Cloud FranceNovellusDx Jerusalem IsraelDepartment of Biostatistics Institut Curie Paris FranceNovellusDx Jerusalem IsraelNovellusDx Jerusalem IsraelDepartment of Drug Development and Innovation Institut Curie Paris & Saint‐Cloud FranceDepartment of Drug Development and Innovation Institut Curie Paris & Saint‐Cloud FranceNovellusDx Jerusalem IsraelDepartment of genetics Institut Curie Paris FranceInstitut Curie/INSERM U900 Saint‐Cloud FranceDepartment of genetics Institut Curie Paris FranceNovellusDx Jerusalem IsraelDepartment of Drug Development and Innovation Institut Curie Paris & Saint‐Cloud FranceIt still remains to be demonstrated that using molecular profiling to guide therapy improves patient outcome in oncology. Classification of somatic variants is not straightforward, rendering treatment decisions based on variants with unknown significance (VUS) hard to implement. The oncogenic activity of VUS and mutations identified in 12 patients treated with molecularly targeted agents (MTAs) in the frame of SHIVA01 trial was assessed using Functional Annotation for Cancer Treatment (FACT). MTA response prediction was measured in vitro, blinded to the actual clinical trial results, and survival predictions according to FACT were correlated with the actual PFS of SHIVA01 patients. Patients with positive prediction had a median PFS of 5.8 months versus 1.7 months in patients with negative prediction (P < 0.05). Our results highlight the role of the functional interpretation of molecular profiles to predict MTA response.https://doi.org/10.1002/1878-0261.12180drug responsein vitro functional assaymutationoncogenic activityvariant with unknown significance
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Maud Kamal
Gabi Tarcic
Sylvain Dureau
Oded Edelheit
Zohar Barbash
Charlotte Lecerf
Claire Morel
Benjamin Miron
Celine Callens
Nicolas Servant
Ivan Bieche
Michael Vidne
Christophe Le Tourneau
spellingShingle Maud Kamal
Gabi Tarcic
Sylvain Dureau
Oded Edelheit
Zohar Barbash
Charlotte Lecerf
Claire Morel
Benjamin Miron
Celine Callens
Nicolas Servant
Ivan Bieche
Michael Vidne
Christophe Le Tourneau
Revisited analysis of a SHIVA01 trial cohort using functional mutational analyses successfully predicted treatment outcome
Molecular Oncology
drug response
in vitro functional assay
mutation
oncogenic activity
variant with unknown significance
author_facet Maud Kamal
Gabi Tarcic
Sylvain Dureau
Oded Edelheit
Zohar Barbash
Charlotte Lecerf
Claire Morel
Benjamin Miron
Celine Callens
Nicolas Servant
Ivan Bieche
Michael Vidne
Christophe Le Tourneau
author_sort Maud Kamal
title Revisited analysis of a SHIVA01 trial cohort using functional mutational analyses successfully predicted treatment outcome
title_short Revisited analysis of a SHIVA01 trial cohort using functional mutational analyses successfully predicted treatment outcome
title_full Revisited analysis of a SHIVA01 trial cohort using functional mutational analyses successfully predicted treatment outcome
title_fullStr Revisited analysis of a SHIVA01 trial cohort using functional mutational analyses successfully predicted treatment outcome
title_full_unstemmed Revisited analysis of a SHIVA01 trial cohort using functional mutational analyses successfully predicted treatment outcome
title_sort revisited analysis of a shiva01 trial cohort using functional mutational analyses successfully predicted treatment outcome
publisher Wiley
series Molecular Oncology
issn 1574-7891
1878-0261
publishDate 2018-05-01
description It still remains to be demonstrated that using molecular profiling to guide therapy improves patient outcome in oncology. Classification of somatic variants is not straightforward, rendering treatment decisions based on variants with unknown significance (VUS) hard to implement. The oncogenic activity of VUS and mutations identified in 12 patients treated with molecularly targeted agents (MTAs) in the frame of SHIVA01 trial was assessed using Functional Annotation for Cancer Treatment (FACT). MTA response prediction was measured in vitro, blinded to the actual clinical trial results, and survival predictions according to FACT were correlated with the actual PFS of SHIVA01 patients. Patients with positive prediction had a median PFS of 5.8 months versus 1.7 months in patients with negative prediction (P < 0.05). Our results highlight the role of the functional interpretation of molecular profiles to predict MTA response.
topic drug response
in vitro functional assay
mutation
oncogenic activity
variant with unknown significance
url https://doi.org/10.1002/1878-0261.12180
work_keys_str_mv AT maudkamal revisitedanalysisofashiva01trialcohortusingfunctionalmutationalanalysessuccessfullypredictedtreatmentoutcome
AT gabitarcic revisitedanalysisofashiva01trialcohortusingfunctionalmutationalanalysessuccessfullypredictedtreatmentoutcome
AT sylvaindureau revisitedanalysisofashiva01trialcohortusingfunctionalmutationalanalysessuccessfullypredictedtreatmentoutcome
AT odededelheit revisitedanalysisofashiva01trialcohortusingfunctionalmutationalanalysessuccessfullypredictedtreatmentoutcome
AT zoharbarbash revisitedanalysisofashiva01trialcohortusingfunctionalmutationalanalysessuccessfullypredictedtreatmentoutcome
AT charlottelecerf revisitedanalysisofashiva01trialcohortusingfunctionalmutationalanalysessuccessfullypredictedtreatmentoutcome
AT clairemorel revisitedanalysisofashiva01trialcohortusingfunctionalmutationalanalysessuccessfullypredictedtreatmentoutcome
AT benjaminmiron revisitedanalysisofashiva01trialcohortusingfunctionalmutationalanalysessuccessfullypredictedtreatmentoutcome
AT celinecallens revisitedanalysisofashiva01trialcohortusingfunctionalmutationalanalysessuccessfullypredictedtreatmentoutcome
AT nicolasservant revisitedanalysisofashiva01trialcohortusingfunctionalmutationalanalysessuccessfullypredictedtreatmentoutcome
AT ivanbieche revisitedanalysisofashiva01trialcohortusingfunctionalmutationalanalysessuccessfullypredictedtreatmentoutcome
AT michaelvidne revisitedanalysisofashiva01trialcohortusingfunctionalmutationalanalysessuccessfullypredictedtreatmentoutcome
AT christopheletourneau revisitedanalysisofashiva01trialcohortusingfunctionalmutationalanalysessuccessfullypredictedtreatmentoutcome
_version_ 1724471343063236608