Can Deep Learning Extract Useful Information about Energy Dissipation and Effective Hydraulic Conductivity from Gridded Conductivity Fields?

We confirm that energy dissipation weighting provides the most accurate approach to determining the effective hydraulic conductivity (K<sub>eff</sub>) of a binary K grid. A deep learning algorithm (UNET) can infer K<sub>eff</sub> with extremely high accuracy (R<sup>2<...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Mohammad A. Moghaddam, Paul A. T. Ferre, Mohammad Reza Ehsani, Jeffrey Klakovich, Hoshin Vijay Gupta
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: MDPI AG 2021-06-01
Series:Water
Subjects:
Online Access:https://www.mdpi.com/2073-4441/13/12/1668
id doaj-8be57cd252c74c6a8c7899be14492e24
record_format Article
spelling doaj-8be57cd252c74c6a8c7899be14492e242021-07-01T00:13:52ZengMDPI AGWater2073-44412021-06-01131668166810.3390/w13121668Can Deep Learning Extract Useful Information about Energy Dissipation and Effective Hydraulic Conductivity from Gridded Conductivity Fields?Mohammad A. Moghaddam0Paul A. T. Ferre1Mohammad Reza Ehsani2Jeffrey Klakovich3Hoshin Vijay Gupta4Department of Hydrology and Atmospheric Sciences, University of Arizona, Tucson, AZ 85721, USADepartment of Hydrology and Atmospheric Sciences, University of Arizona, Tucson, AZ 85721, USADepartment of Hydrology and Atmospheric Sciences, University of Arizona, Tucson, AZ 85721, USADepartment of Hydrology and Atmospheric Sciences, University of Arizona, Tucson, AZ 85721, USADepartment of Hydrology and Atmospheric Sciences, University of Arizona, Tucson, AZ 85721, USAWe confirm that energy dissipation weighting provides the most accurate approach to determining the effective hydraulic conductivity (K<sub>eff</sub>) of a binary K grid. A deep learning algorithm (UNET) can infer K<sub>eff</sub> with extremely high accuracy (R<sup>2</sup> > 0.99). The UNET architecture could be trained to infer the energy dissipation weighting pattern from an image of the K distribution, although it was less accurate for cases with highly localized structures that controlled flow. Furthermore, the UNET architecture learned to infer the energy dissipation weighting even if it was not trained directly on this information. However, the weights were represented within the UNET in a way that was not immediately interpretable by a human user. This reiterates the idea that even if ML/DL algorithms are trained to make some hydrologic predictions accurately, they must be designed and trained to provide each user-required output if their results are to be used to improve our understanding of hydrologic systems.https://www.mdpi.com/2073-4441/13/12/1668deep learningmachine learninghydrogeologyeffective hydraulic conductivityenergy dissipationUNET
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Mohammad A. Moghaddam
Paul A. T. Ferre
Mohammad Reza Ehsani
Jeffrey Klakovich
Hoshin Vijay Gupta
spellingShingle Mohammad A. Moghaddam
Paul A. T. Ferre
Mohammad Reza Ehsani
Jeffrey Klakovich
Hoshin Vijay Gupta
Can Deep Learning Extract Useful Information about Energy Dissipation and Effective Hydraulic Conductivity from Gridded Conductivity Fields?
Water
deep learning
machine learning
hydrogeology
effective hydraulic conductivity
energy dissipation
UNET
author_facet Mohammad A. Moghaddam
Paul A. T. Ferre
Mohammad Reza Ehsani
Jeffrey Klakovich
Hoshin Vijay Gupta
author_sort Mohammad A. Moghaddam
title Can Deep Learning Extract Useful Information about Energy Dissipation and Effective Hydraulic Conductivity from Gridded Conductivity Fields?
title_short Can Deep Learning Extract Useful Information about Energy Dissipation and Effective Hydraulic Conductivity from Gridded Conductivity Fields?
title_full Can Deep Learning Extract Useful Information about Energy Dissipation and Effective Hydraulic Conductivity from Gridded Conductivity Fields?
title_fullStr Can Deep Learning Extract Useful Information about Energy Dissipation and Effective Hydraulic Conductivity from Gridded Conductivity Fields?
title_full_unstemmed Can Deep Learning Extract Useful Information about Energy Dissipation and Effective Hydraulic Conductivity from Gridded Conductivity Fields?
title_sort can deep learning extract useful information about energy dissipation and effective hydraulic conductivity from gridded conductivity fields?
publisher MDPI AG
series Water
issn 2073-4441
publishDate 2021-06-01
description We confirm that energy dissipation weighting provides the most accurate approach to determining the effective hydraulic conductivity (K<sub>eff</sub>) of a binary K grid. A deep learning algorithm (UNET) can infer K<sub>eff</sub> with extremely high accuracy (R<sup>2</sup> > 0.99). The UNET architecture could be trained to infer the energy dissipation weighting pattern from an image of the K distribution, although it was less accurate for cases with highly localized structures that controlled flow. Furthermore, the UNET architecture learned to infer the energy dissipation weighting even if it was not trained directly on this information. However, the weights were represented within the UNET in a way that was not immediately interpretable by a human user. This reiterates the idea that even if ML/DL algorithms are trained to make some hydrologic predictions accurately, they must be designed and trained to provide each user-required output if their results are to be used to improve our understanding of hydrologic systems.
topic deep learning
machine learning
hydrogeology
effective hydraulic conductivity
energy dissipation
UNET
url https://www.mdpi.com/2073-4441/13/12/1668
work_keys_str_mv AT mohammadamoghaddam candeeplearningextractusefulinformationaboutenergydissipationandeffectivehydraulicconductivityfromgriddedconductivityfields
AT paulatferre candeeplearningextractusefulinformationaboutenergydissipationandeffectivehydraulicconductivityfromgriddedconductivityfields
AT mohammadrezaehsani candeeplearningextractusefulinformationaboutenergydissipationandeffectivehydraulicconductivityfromgriddedconductivityfields
AT jeffreyklakovich candeeplearningextractusefulinformationaboutenergydissipationandeffectivehydraulicconductivityfromgriddedconductivityfields
AT hoshinvijaygupta candeeplearningextractusefulinformationaboutenergydissipationandeffectivehydraulicconductivityfromgriddedconductivityfields
_version_ 1721349229796917248