Risk Factors for Bleeding and Clinical Ineffectiveness Associated With Clopidogrel Therapy: A Comprehensive Meta‐Analysis

Although clopidogrel is a frequently used antiplatelet medication to treat and prevent atherothrombotic disease, clinicians must balance its clinical effectiveness with the potential side effect of bleeding. However, many previous studies have evaluated beneficial and adverse factors separately. The...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Khoa A. Nguyen, Michael T. Eadon, Ryan Yoo, Evan Milway, Allison Kenneally, Kevin Fekete, Hyun Oh, Khanh Duong, Elizabeth C. Whipple, Titus K. Schleyer
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Wiley 2021-03-01
Series:Clinical and Translational Science
Online Access:https://doi.org/10.1111/cts.12926
id doaj-7dcaa32e7a57423694c4b1e7fc18e9d4
record_format Article
spelling doaj-7dcaa32e7a57423694c4b1e7fc18e9d42021-03-25T15:37:46ZengWileyClinical and Translational Science1752-80541752-80622021-03-0114264565510.1111/cts.12926Risk Factors for Bleeding and Clinical Ineffectiveness Associated With Clopidogrel Therapy: A Comprehensive Meta‐AnalysisKhoa A. Nguyen0Michael T. Eadon1Ryan Yoo2Evan Milway3Allison Kenneally4Kevin Fekete5Hyun Oh6Khanh Duong7Elizabeth C. Whipple8Titus K. Schleyer9College of Pharmacy University of Florida Gainesville Florida USASchool of Medicine Indiana University Indianapolis Indiana USACollege of Pharmacy Purdue University West Lafayette Indiana USACollege of Pharmacy Purdue University West Lafayette Indiana USACollege of Pharmacy Purdue University West Lafayette Indiana USACollege of Pharmacy Purdue University West Lafayette Indiana USACollege of Pharmacy Purdue University West Lafayette Indiana USACollege of Pharmacy Purdue University West Lafayette Indiana USASchool of Medicine Indiana University Indianapolis Indiana USARegenstrief Institute Indianapolis Indiana USAAlthough clopidogrel is a frequently used antiplatelet medication to treat and prevent atherothrombotic disease, clinicians must balance its clinical effectiveness with the potential side effect of bleeding. However, many previous studies have evaluated beneficial and adverse factors separately. The objective of our study was to perform a comprehensive meta‐analysis of studies of clopidogrel’s clinical effectiveness and/or risk of bleeding in order to identify and assess all reported risk factors, thus helping clinicians to balance patient safety with drug efficacy. We analyzed randomized controlled trials (RCTs) of maintenance use in four stages: search for relevant primary articles; abstract and full article screening; quality assessment and data extraction; and synthesis and data analysis. Screening of 7,109 articles yielded 52 RCTs that met the inclusion criteria. Twenty‐seven risk factors were identified. “Definite risk factors” were defined as those with aggregated odds ratios (ORs) > 1 and confidence intervals (CIs) > 1 if analyzed in more than one study. Definite risk factors for major bleeding were concomitant aspirin use (OR 2.83, 95% CI 2.04–3.94) and long duration of clopidogrel therapy (> 6 months) (OR 1.74, 95% CI 1.21–2.50). Dual antiplatelet therapy, extended clopidogrel therapy, and high maintenance dose (150 mg/day) of clopidogrel were definite risk factors for any bleeding. Reduced renal function, both mild and severe, was the only definite risk factor for clinical ineffectiveness. These findings can help clinicians predict the risks and effectiveness of clopidogrel use for their patients and be used in clinical decision support tools.https://doi.org/10.1111/cts.12926
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Khoa A. Nguyen
Michael T. Eadon
Ryan Yoo
Evan Milway
Allison Kenneally
Kevin Fekete
Hyun Oh
Khanh Duong
Elizabeth C. Whipple
Titus K. Schleyer
spellingShingle Khoa A. Nguyen
Michael T. Eadon
Ryan Yoo
Evan Milway
Allison Kenneally
Kevin Fekete
Hyun Oh
Khanh Duong
Elizabeth C. Whipple
Titus K. Schleyer
Risk Factors for Bleeding and Clinical Ineffectiveness Associated With Clopidogrel Therapy: A Comprehensive Meta‐Analysis
Clinical and Translational Science
author_facet Khoa A. Nguyen
Michael T. Eadon
Ryan Yoo
Evan Milway
Allison Kenneally
Kevin Fekete
Hyun Oh
Khanh Duong
Elizabeth C. Whipple
Titus K. Schleyer
author_sort Khoa A. Nguyen
title Risk Factors for Bleeding and Clinical Ineffectiveness Associated With Clopidogrel Therapy: A Comprehensive Meta‐Analysis
title_short Risk Factors for Bleeding and Clinical Ineffectiveness Associated With Clopidogrel Therapy: A Comprehensive Meta‐Analysis
title_full Risk Factors for Bleeding and Clinical Ineffectiveness Associated With Clopidogrel Therapy: A Comprehensive Meta‐Analysis
title_fullStr Risk Factors for Bleeding and Clinical Ineffectiveness Associated With Clopidogrel Therapy: A Comprehensive Meta‐Analysis
title_full_unstemmed Risk Factors for Bleeding and Clinical Ineffectiveness Associated With Clopidogrel Therapy: A Comprehensive Meta‐Analysis
title_sort risk factors for bleeding and clinical ineffectiveness associated with clopidogrel therapy: a comprehensive meta‐analysis
publisher Wiley
series Clinical and Translational Science
issn 1752-8054
1752-8062
publishDate 2021-03-01
description Although clopidogrel is a frequently used antiplatelet medication to treat and prevent atherothrombotic disease, clinicians must balance its clinical effectiveness with the potential side effect of bleeding. However, many previous studies have evaluated beneficial and adverse factors separately. The objective of our study was to perform a comprehensive meta‐analysis of studies of clopidogrel’s clinical effectiveness and/or risk of bleeding in order to identify and assess all reported risk factors, thus helping clinicians to balance patient safety with drug efficacy. We analyzed randomized controlled trials (RCTs) of maintenance use in four stages: search for relevant primary articles; abstract and full article screening; quality assessment and data extraction; and synthesis and data analysis. Screening of 7,109 articles yielded 52 RCTs that met the inclusion criteria. Twenty‐seven risk factors were identified. “Definite risk factors” were defined as those with aggregated odds ratios (ORs) > 1 and confidence intervals (CIs) > 1 if analyzed in more than one study. Definite risk factors for major bleeding were concomitant aspirin use (OR 2.83, 95% CI 2.04–3.94) and long duration of clopidogrel therapy (> 6 months) (OR 1.74, 95% CI 1.21–2.50). Dual antiplatelet therapy, extended clopidogrel therapy, and high maintenance dose (150 mg/day) of clopidogrel were definite risk factors for any bleeding. Reduced renal function, both mild and severe, was the only definite risk factor for clinical ineffectiveness. These findings can help clinicians predict the risks and effectiveness of clopidogrel use for their patients and be used in clinical decision support tools.
url https://doi.org/10.1111/cts.12926
work_keys_str_mv AT khoaanguyen riskfactorsforbleedingandclinicalineffectivenessassociatedwithclopidogreltherapyacomprehensivemetaanalysis
AT michaelteadon riskfactorsforbleedingandclinicalineffectivenessassociatedwithclopidogreltherapyacomprehensivemetaanalysis
AT ryanyoo riskfactorsforbleedingandclinicalineffectivenessassociatedwithclopidogreltherapyacomprehensivemetaanalysis
AT evanmilway riskfactorsforbleedingandclinicalineffectivenessassociatedwithclopidogreltherapyacomprehensivemetaanalysis
AT allisonkenneally riskfactorsforbleedingandclinicalineffectivenessassociatedwithclopidogreltherapyacomprehensivemetaanalysis
AT kevinfekete riskfactorsforbleedingandclinicalineffectivenessassociatedwithclopidogreltherapyacomprehensivemetaanalysis
AT hyunoh riskfactorsforbleedingandclinicalineffectivenessassociatedwithclopidogreltherapyacomprehensivemetaanalysis
AT khanhduong riskfactorsforbleedingandclinicalineffectivenessassociatedwithclopidogreltherapyacomprehensivemetaanalysis
AT elizabethcwhipple riskfactorsforbleedingandclinicalineffectivenessassociatedwithclopidogreltherapyacomprehensivemetaanalysis
AT tituskschleyer riskfactorsforbleedingandclinicalineffectivenessassociatedwithclopidogreltherapyacomprehensivemetaanalysis
_version_ 1724203418589855744